207 Matching Annotations
  1. Jul 2023
  2. Apr 2021
    1. Nietzsche sees the full development of the individual conditioned by the most ruthless struggle of individuals; socialism

      Nietzsche and Marxism were the two popular philosophies at the time. Simmel sees in them (and perhaps their popularity) particular manifestations of his own theory. A tried-and-true method of sublating previous work "A and B are right, but didn't see the whole picture; but here's how I'm even more right without undercuting A and B."

    2. the person resists to being leveled down and worn out by a social-technological mechanism.

      Notice that this doesn't take place via social/communal action. "The Person", the individual has an individual struggle. Collectivities (class consciousness) are a completely different matter.

      Also note Engel's comment in Condition of the Working Classon Gaelic in Scotland after industrialization penetrated via infrastructural improvements

    3. structures like the metropolis set up between the individual and the super-individual contents of life

      The metropolis, not just the city, as not just a particular place, but rather a form of social organization, through which individuals become part of a super-individual machine.

      -Note the population boom of the 19th Century Leipzig in Saxony: 32k (1800) to 149k (1880) to 590000 (1910)

      In 1800, only two cities in eventual DE hat more than 100k In 1849 up to 3

      1880, 14 (Berlin over a million)

      1910, 20 over 236k, Berlin > 2 million

      Shortly after 1910, DE became more urban than rural.

      "Strange" things happen when you go from a predominately rural society to an urban society, e.g. Country Western music in the USA.

    4. ntensification of nervous stimulation which results from the swift and uninterrupted change of outer and inner stimuli.

      Note also the general rise in the interest of the tension between interior/exterior at this point.

      Beginning of the stream-consciousness narratives (Schnitzler's Leutnant Gustl in 1900)

      Cf. also Joachim Radkau's Die Zeitalter der Nervösität (The Age of Nervousness), which argued that there was a perceived increase of clinical "nervousness" cases stemming from stress and perceptions of the speed of life from 1871 to 1945.

    5. Lasting impressions, {4} impressions which differ only slightly from one another, impressions which take a regular and habitual course and show regular and habitual contrasts-all these use up, so to speak, less consciousness than does the rapid crowding of changing images

      Speed of changes in perception takes up vital resources of consciousness.

    6. a deep contrast with small town and rural life with reference to the sensory foundations of psychic life

      Modern urban life is complicated! You have to worry about transportation, rent, your retirement plan, you utility bills, your streaming services subscriptions, etc.

      Compare this to rural life in the 19th century. You might have to pay rent to a landlord (if a peasant), and taxes, and tolls when crossing borders or using private roads, but the complications of everyday urban life didn't yet exist.

      Plus, there's always something (bad) happening on the subway.

    7. rhythm of life

      "Rhythm": Rural farming life did not have a daily schedule as rigid as urban life.

      Just as much of the disagreement about "wage slavery" of factory jobs was its intrusion into daily rhythms.

      A rural worker worked according to seasons, could take time off whenever, might have to work early in the morning to late at night some times (of his/her own reasoning), while urban workers had set schedules determined by relatively precise clocks (particularly large public clocks in town halls)

      example: Clocks were apparently targets for revolutionaries in the 1830 Paris Revolution.

    8. shocks and inner upheavals; it is only through such upheavals that the more conservative mind

      Visceral reaction stems from unconsciously held beliefs that are violated.

    9. metropolitan child shows when compared with children of quieter and less changeable milieus.

      Example of my father-in-law seeing the Kölner Dom for the first time: While some on that train hadn't seen it before, no one stood up and screamed like he did.

    10. The small-town life in Antiquity and in the Middle Ages set barriers against movement and relations of the individual toward the outside, and it set up barriers against individual independence and differentiation within the individual self.

      Gesellschaft vs. Gemeinschaft

    11. He reacts with his head instead of his heart.

      "head vs. heart", implying reason over emotion. Think of how scary monsters in movies become less scary when we have a name for them. Without a name, we can only rely on the "heart" sensory impression (terror, uncanniness), but if we have a name for it, we can put it in a category.

      example of the uncanny.

    12. The reaction to metropolitan phenomena is shifted to that organ which is least sensitive and quite remote from the depth of the personality.

      Naming/classifying/having a mental "mastery" over a think is easiert than empathsizing constantly.

      Think about reactions to homeless people. Most people want to sympathsize with them individually, but we construct categories ("drug addict") that allow us to not let them affect us.

    13. -What other terms does Simmel use as synonyms for  metropolis"?      What other terms does he use for "rural life"?

      Note the idea of "Gesellschaft" :: (mass) society vs. "Gemeinschaft" :: community.

    14. Here the multiplicity and concentration of economic exchange gives an importance to the means of exchange

      Vs. barter and other less formalized systems of exchange (footnote mentions custom like birthday gifts)

    15. They share a matter-of-fact attitude in dealing with men and with things; and, in this attitude, a formal justice {8} is often coupled with an inconsiderate hardness.

      Commodification. People and possessions become "assets", defined by a numeric (quantitive) value) vs. a qualitative value. This is also known as reductive positivism.

    16. genuine individuality, because relationships and reactions result from it which cannot be exhausted with logical operations

      Quality vs. quantity: You can't put a price on genuine individuality, and thereby can mark it as part of your "bottom line". You can do that with assests that have numeric values.

    17. Money is concerned only with what is common to all: it asks for the exchange value, it reduces all quality and individuality to the question: How much?

      Commodification, very Marxist.

    18. objective measurable achievement is of interest

      Note the overlap of science here. This is an age where science and industry interact intimately, and take over much of the decision-making processes. What would be the objectively right thing for the company/state to do?

    19. balancing of service and return

      aka Transactionalism

      Analyze DJT's presidency, often referred to as "transactional" (quid pro quo). When did he not act transactionally: When he saw images of children on TV (gas attacks in Syria)

    20. intellectually calculating economic egoisms of both parties need not fear any deflection because of the imponderables of personal relationships

      Since you don't know the child laborer sewing your T-Shirt from Walmart, you only think about the immediate price of the T-Shirt.

    21. London has never acted as England's heart but often as England's intellect and always as her moneybag!

      London as Wall Street before Wall Street, and governments from London working less for the betterment of the whole nation than for London's interests (does it help the rural farmer that Queen Victoria is now the Empress of India?_

    22. the same psychic currents characteristically unite. Modern mind has become more and more calculating.

      Permeation of this "intellectual" way of thinking in all forms of thinking.

    23. orresponds to the ideal of natural science: to transform the world into an arithmetic problem, to fix every part of the world by mathematical formulas.

      Positivism: The attempt to remove non-objective thought from our reasoning

    24. just as externally this precision has been effected by the universal diffusion of pocket watches.

      Time as a precision measurement. The regimentation of the day, it's disection into units ("The Mythical Man-Month"), e.g. man-hours, billable hours. TIme is money!

    25. The relationships and affairs of the typical metropolitan usually are so varied and complex that without the strictest punctuality in promises and services the whole structure would break down into an inextricable chaos.

      Metropolis as more than just a geographical place or accummulation of people, it's a machine that millions of moving parts, regulated by timetables. (What's one of the most important non-calculating part of modern computers?)

    26. technique of metropolitan life

      metropolitan life is in fact a technology. (cf. Marshall McLuhan, The Medium is the Message), a machine that takes in raw materials, and produces finished goods.

    27. These traits must also color the contents of life and favor the exclusion of those irrational, instinctive, sovereign traits and impulses which aim at determining the mode of life from within, instead of receiving the general and precisely schematized form of life from without.

      Consumerism and mass society; pop music (example of Country Music in the US). A mechanism that regiments and standardizes not only work, but also leisure.

      Schematization: regimentation and standardization.

    28. Their natures discovered the value of life alone in the unschematized existence which cannot be defined with precision for all alike.

      Strongly individual, and as such against regimentation (standardization)

    29. An incapacity thus emerges to react to new sensations with the appropriate energy.

      Not so much a "depressed" state, but an attitude of disinterest designed to preserve mental resources. If you cared about every single person you met while walking down a busy street, you probably wouldn't make it to work much less out of bed the next day. To survive this new social sphere and all its stimulli, you have to "filter out" excessive agitation by adopting a "there-is-nothing-new-under-the-sun" attitude, either by one's own volition, or by trial and error.

    30. impersonality; on the other hand, they have promoted a highly personal subjectivity.

      Impersonal, but highly personal (standardized self-centered-ness)

    31. the meaning and differing values of things, and thereby the things themselves, are experienced as insubstantial

      Flattening of the meaning of objects.

    32. For money expresses all qualitative differences of things in terms of "how much?" Money, with all its colorlessness and indifference, becomes the common denominator of all values;

      A reduction of all being into numeric value. A way to measure things that would seemingly be immeasurable.

    33. their individuality, their specific value, and their incomparability.

      Dis-enchanting, de-fetishization of things.

      Fungibility

      Frodo/Bilbo's ring: How much for it?

    34. The self-preservation of certain personalities is brought at the price of devaluating the whole objective world, a devaluation which in the end unavoidably drags one's own personality down into a feeling of the same worthlessness.

      Personality preserved through commodification, which makes personality itself a non-qualitative phenomenon.

    35. If so many inner reactions were responses to the continuous external contacts with innumerable people as are those in the small town, where one knows almost everybody one meets and where one has a positive relation to almost everyone, one would be completely atomized internally and come to an unimaginable psychic state.

      Big cities have lots of people, to which you can't empathsize completely without becoming overwhelmed.

    36. a relatively small circle firmly closed against neighboring, strange, or in some way antagonistic circles. However, this circle is closely coherent and allows its individual members only a narrow field for the development of unique qualities and free, self-responsible movements.

      Earlier, the fundamental psychological unit was the family or clan (e.g. where neighboring families/clans were viewed suspiciously)

    37. What appears in the metropolitan style of life directly as dissociation is in reality only one of its elemental forms of socialization.

      Indifference is not completely unnatural to use. We can feel antipathy naturally, and this builds on that tendancy.

    38. The self-preservation of very young associations requires the establishment of strict boundaries and a centripetal unity.

      Conformity. Within rural communities, those who didn't adhere to certain group standards were separated.

    39. freedom of movement, far beyond the first jealous delimitation. The individual also gains a specific individuality to which the division of labor in the enlarged group gives both occasion and necessity.

      Increase in individuality, possibilities for autonomy.

    40. Even today a metropolitan man who is placed in a small town feels a restriction similar, at least, in kind

      "Big city girl moves to a small town in the South."

    41. so today metropolitan man is "free" in a spiritualized and refined sense, in contrast to the pettiness and prejudices which hem in the small-town man.

      Liberation potential of the small city. Go to a city and let your freak flag fly; be who you want to be.

    42. For the reciprocal reserve and indifference and the intellectual life conditions of large circles are never felt more strongly by the individual in their impact upon his independence than in the thickest crowd of the big city.

      Indifference and reserve a model of toleration.

    43. For here as elsewhere it is by no means necessary that the freedom of man be reflected in his emotional life as comfort.

      Trade off between feeling of belonging and ability to be yourself.

    44. It is rather in transcending this visible expanse that any given city becomes the seat of cosmopolitanism.{18}

      Metropolis as a place that expands beyond the smaller forms of identification (nation-state).

      "Urban" socialism based on cross-national concerns of a common class ("Workers of the World Unite!") vs. "National Socialism"

    45. At this point, the quantitative aspect of life is transformed directly into qualitative traits of character. The sphere of life of the small town is, in the main, self-contained and autarchic. {19}

      Quantitative turns qualitative in the city in its ability to offer wider connections to the whole world (Cultural Globalism) vs. small town that is largely self-interested

    46. This is the counterpart to the independence, and it is the price the individual pays for the independence, which he enjoys in the metropolis.

      De-personalization in the city; even the greatest figures are not bigger than the city.

    47. In the same way, a city consists of its total effects which extend beyond its immediate confines.

      Cities provide economic and social effects beyond itself in proportion to its size.

      "Sphere of influence"

    48. The essential point is that the particularity and incomparability, which ultimately every human being possesses, be somehow expressed in the working-out of a way of life.

      The city as a space for developing a private being. People aren't looking into you, butting into your business; cities offer different and increasingly specialized amenities. (Different options for food, etc.)

    49. They produce thereby such extreme phenomena as in Paris the remunerative occupation of the quatorzième. They are persons who identify themselves by signs on their residences and who are ready at the dinner hour in correct attire, so that they can be quickly called upon if a dinner party should consist of thirteen persons.

      New specialized that depend on the ever increasing sophistication of a public.

      Think of "Influencers", or "Twitch streamers".

    50. It is decisive that city life has transformed the struggle with nature for livelihood into an inter-human struggle for gain

      2nd Nature: Subsistance versus nature is no longer humanities primary struggle in the present day (anthropocene), but rather, a struggle against a "new 2nd nature" (cf. Marcusé), truly all man-made.

    51. For specialization does not flow only from the competition for gain but also from the underlying fact that the seller must always seek to call forth new and differentiated needs of the lured customer.

      Specialization by discovering new niches.

      Hotels for dogs.

    52. First, one must meet the difficulty of asserting his own personality within the dimensions of metropolitan life. Where the quantitative increase in importance and the expense of energy reach their limits, one seizes upon qualitative differentiation in order somehow to attract the attention of the social circle by playing upon its sensitivity for differences

      That is, finding your niche within a setting that has leveled all other means of differentiation.

    53. Finally, man is tempted to adopt the most tendentious {20} peculiarities, that is, the specifically metropolitan extravagances of mannerism, caprice, and preciousness.

      New urban manners. David Sedaris on Texan college students on the Paris Metro.

    54. For many character types, ultimately the only means of saving for themselves some modicum of self-esteem and the sense of filling a position is indirect, through the awareness of others.

      The Flaneur and the Dandy as urban "types". Originality requires a knowledge of what pre-exists in the marketplace of personality.

    55. The temptation to appear "to the point," to appear concentrated and strikingly characteristic, lies much closer to the individual in brief metropolitan contacts than in an atmosphere in which frequent and prolonged association assures the personality of an unambiguous image of himself in the eyes of the other.

      Making a bit first impression (urban) vs. an impression that is built on prolonged interaction (rural)

    56. sum of spirit

      Spirit as in a common, extra-personal consciousness (no ghosts intended).

      This is a common idea from the Enlightenment times, i.e. that periods of time have certain thought patterns associated with them, e.g. "Zeitgeist".

    57. If, for instance, we view the immense culture which for the last hundred years has been embodied in things and in knowledge, in institutions and in comforts, and if we compare all this with the cultural progress of the individual during the same period-at least in high status groups - a frightful disproportion in growth between the two becomes evident.

      Human beings have been less capable of adapting to the new cultural and social conditions of the last century (that is, the 19th Century and its rapid urbanization and industrialization)

    58. with reference to spirituality, delicacy, and idealism.

      In the English-speaking world, think of Romanticism, which often showed the horrors of the new age in juxtaposition to a sentimentality for the past. In German-speaking areas, this reappeared in Neo-Romanticism, but also in the Youth and Reform movements (which appeared in the UK and USA as the Boy Scouts, in DE as the Wandervogel, FKK [nude bathing], and various other movements aimed at "returning to nature")

    59. space-conquering technology

      Architecture as well as transportation.

      The 19th Century saw the creation of the arcade, basically the predecessor of the shopping mall, where patrons could shop without worrying about the weather. Similarly, intra- and inter-continental travel became increasingly fast. Finally, don't forget about the telegraph and telephone, which made communication instantaneous.

    60. The atrophy {24} of individual culture through the hypertrophy {25} of objective cultur

      Think of "objective culture" as mass culture. Over this period, we start to see cultural forms that spread beyond localities to ever-larger and (economically) varied audiences.

    61. They were restraints which, so to speak, forced upon man an unnatural form and outmoded, unjust inequalities. In this situation the cry for liberty and equality arose, the belief in the individual's full freedom of movement in all social and intellectual relationships.

      i.e. social liberalism

    62. individuals liberated from historical bonds now wished to distinguish themselves from one another.

      The flip side of political equality: Undifferentiation. To make up that gap, it becomes necessary to try to replace it with another sense of individuality.

    63. The external and internal history of our time takes its course within the struggle and in the changing entanglements of these two ways of defining the individual's role in the whole of society.

      i.e. the two roles of equality and irreplacibility.

    64. this specialization makes each man the more directly dependent upon the supplementary activities of all others.
      • The inherent conflict of a liberal democracy founded on negative rights (non-interference with others) vs. communitarian necessities. -Compare to the mask debate: 18th Century liberal Enlightenment saw more importance in right to property (to do with my body what I want) vs. 19th century communal functionalism, where the body is seen not in its isolation, but as a larger, broader "meta-body".
    65. In addition to more liberty, the nineteenth century demanded the functional specialization {1} of man and his work; this specialization makes one individual incomparable to another, and each of them indispensable to the highest possible extent.
      • Juxtaposed against individual liberty, we see industrialization and capitalization. Both entail a division of labor.
      • "Functional" akin to a cog in a machine.
    66. The eighteenth century called upon man to free himself of all the historical bonds in the state and in religion, in morals and in economics. Man's nature, originally good and common to all, should develop unhampered.
      • The enlightenment, and its interest in challenging historical bonds
      • Ideas of natural rights as negative rights ensuring man's essential nature allowed to persist.
      • Rousseau and the purity of the primitive
    67. The deepest problems of modern life derive from the claim of the individual to preserve the autonomy and individuality of his existence in the face of overwhelming social forces, of historical heritage, of external culture, and of the technique of life.
      • Autonomy and Individuality as Enlightenment concepts
    68. The fight with nature which primitive man has to wage for his bodily existence attains in this modern form its latest transformation.

      Marcuse's idea of a "second" nature.