On 2016 Apr 04, Sujai Kumar commented:

Disclaimer: I am one of the authors of this paper.

This is the peer-reviewed version of the bioRxiv preprint that systematically refutes each of the 8 lines of evidence provided by Boothby et al for extensive HGT.

We hope this paper will correct the scientific record. A blog post describing the behind-the-scenes aspects of this paper is available at Eight things I learnt from #tardigate

On 2016 Apr 04, Sujai Kumar commented:

Disclaimer: I am one of the authors of this paper.

This is the peer-reviewed version of the bioRxiv preprint that systematically refutes each of the 8 lines of evidence provided by Boothby et al for extensive HGT.

We hope this paper will correct the scientific record. A blog post describing the behind-the-scenes aspects of this paper is available at Eight things I learnt from #tardigate