1 Matching Annotations
  1. Aug 2025
    1. so so far the whole tune has been an unnatural minor but in that verse Paul McCartney switches from a natural minor to e Dorian mode and the two scales are a little bit different so here's a Dorian mode it's identical to E natural minor except for this this sixth scale degree so an e natural minor it's C natural you need Dorian it's C sharp and that's a subtle change but it does change the mood quite a bit

      mode 調式

      Dorian 多利安調式,最接近 Aeolian/自然小調,但是較不全盤悲傷憂鬱,因為有那一個突出的升高半音的第六音。

      想想 Scarborough Fair 的第二個樂句,本來以爲是自然小調,但聽到 35653#423 -> 應換成多利安來思考,於是變成 61216756 (不再有臨時升降記號)。全曲應該改成多利安調式的思考:第一樂句於是從自然小調 663337176 變成 226663432。很妙吧!