11 Matching Annotations
  1. Sep 2025
    1. Given that few of my students will ultimately find their way into the academy and that, within that already small cohort, only a fraction will choose to do so in the field of philosophy, the question of why study philosophy has a particular resonance for them, and for me as their teacher.

      I agree the lack of knowledge surrounding philosophy contributes to the low interest rate. However along with that I think the unreliability or even lesser knowledge of career opportunities also contribute to the low number of philosophy majors.

    2. Philosophy, far from being an intellectual diversion for the elite, can be central to the empowerment of those who are so often disempowered outside of the classroom. It is, therefore, one of the ironies of our current times that an increase in inequality has been accompanied by a systematic attack on the humanities.

      Philosophy isn't just for higher-ups or great scholars. It is an important tool relevant to any and everyone. By understanding this we can progress and push past barriers.

    3. It sells philosophy short

      While short, I think this is such a true and important sentence. Philosophy encompasses so much that it's difficult to just nail it down to one simple short definition.

    4. But this transformation can only happen if philosophy not only arms her with the critical tools she will need but also with the ability to imagine and construct an alternative.

      The author is emphasizing both skills are required to be successful. The use of critical tools and imagination go hand in hand and won't be as useful if apart when trying to confront the "soundness, validity, necessity and possibility," of a situation, as the author earlier mentioned.

    5. But, if her philosophical education has sharpened her critical skills, she will then question the underlying assumptions. She might wonder if we should think of our political relationships using a contractual model.

      It's both interesting and helpful to see how the author continues with her initial analogy to help the readers stay engaged. This provides a more present "real life" situation easier for the audience to understand.

    6. When successful, students use what they learned in this exercise to begin developing a sense of what they think would be a fair way of distributing resources and to critique the political and social institutions under which they live.

      It's interesting to think that this exercise could contribute so much to a growing understanding of philosophy.

    7. But though our students might find a refuge in fiction, the task of philosophy is not to shelter us from the world.

      This goes back to the previous paragraph where the author discussed not accepting our unfortunate circumstances. To live in fiction would be ignoring our troubles and the world.

    8. n order to do this, we encourage students to develop critical thinking skills – to think hard about soundness, validity, necessity, and possibility – but we also ask them to imagine how things could be different than they are.

      This ties into or explains one of the large subjects in philosophy which is questions of existence.

    9. You simply accept the challenges in front of you as those you must overcome. But in many cases these challenges are the result of your actions, the actions of others, social and political institutions, or a combination of all of these. Therefore, the first step in this kind of philosophical education is to shake students out of a complacent and uncritical acceptance of the world as it is.

      This passage is empowering in a way. Specifically the sentence, "You simply accept the challenges in front of you as those you must overcome." It's as if the author is directly calling out the audience and creating a wake up call to not accept the challenges we face, but instead use the resources philosophy provides to change your circumstance.

    10. Why, these students might ask, is the knowledge that philosophy aims at any deeper than that of more practical fields such as medicine, science, or the law?

      In my opinion philosophy conveys deeper knowledge because it encompasses so many areas of study and other forms of knowledge. As the author mentioned fields such as law, medicine or science, are more practical in the sense that they have a more clean cut rule of what to know and what not. However philosophy can be seen in all three of those areas of study and more. Such as the ethics involved in medicine, or the logistics and critical thinking in science or law.

    11. Picture yourself as a young mother with two children. You enrol in university to obtain a bachelor’s degree, hoping to give yourself a better chance at a job that pays a living wage. Maybe you receive government loans to pay for tuition, and rely on your family’s help, but you still don’t have enough to pay for living expenses and childcare.

      I like that the author uses this analogy not just to grab the readers attention but also throughout the whole text to carry over their point.