10 Matching Annotations
  1. Nov 2024
    1. T.J. is one of more than 200,000 students in New York City public schools classified as having adisability, which can be anything from mild dyslexia to a complex physical disorder. These studentsare a small city unto themselves, and the special education system that serves them is awash indelays, misinformation and confusion

      These students form a large group on their own, and the special education system designed to help them is facing many problems. The special education system is filled with delays, incorrect information, and confusion, making it difficult for students to get the help they need. The passage highlights the challenges faced by students with disabilities in navigating a complicated special education system.

    1. This passage speaks volumes about the “coming-out” experience and how it is portrayed inAmerican film and media. Oftentimes when non-LGBTQ+ people hear the term “coming-out,”they always attribute it to this giant event that happens once in a person's life. But in reality,coming-out as queer, gay, lesbian, trans, or non-binary and gender nonconforming is somethingthat occurs repetitively and continuously for many LGBTQ+ youth. When Ngo says that “you’repotentially coming-out whenever you meet someone new” he attributes it to his own K-12experiences in middle and high school. Ngo believes that many of his peers and classmateswould “hint” that they’re queer, and they would come-out at different times and with differentpeople who fall under the same spectrum. Ngo even explains how coming-out became arecurring activity with his own mother, “I will say that, in terms of coming out in middle andhigh school, it’s definitely true that there is no set coming out experience. I told my Mom, andshe didn’t believe me, I told her later and she didn’t believe me. I told her two years later and shedidn’t believe me” (Ngo, 2022). In his book, Mayo explains how LGBTQ+ youth lack supportfrom family members within their immediate household and school environments, “these [lackof supports] may include a lack of role models in schools, discomfort with parental involvementor, especially in the case of children with LGBTQ parents, difficult relations between school andfamily” (Mayo 2014). And this ties back to that idea of a continuous coming-out experience

      This passage talks about the "coming-out" experience for LGBTQ+ people and how it is shown in American movies and media. Many non-LGBTQ+ people think of coming out as a big event that happens once, but for many LGBTQ+ youth, it is something that happens over and over again throughout their lives. Ngo mentions that you might come out every time you meet someone new, based on his experiences in middle and high school. He observes that his classmates often hinted at being queer and came out at different times to different people. He shares a personal story about coming out to his mother multiple times, saying, "I told my Mom, and she didn't believe me... I told her two years later, and she didn't believe me." In his book, Mayo discusses how LGBTQ+ youth often don't get support from their families or schools. This lack of support can include not having role models in schools or having tough relationships between families and schools. This all connects back to the idea that coming out is not just a one-time thing but a continuous process for many LGBTQ+ individuals.

    1. King's story underscores the strength of young gender nonconforming,gay, and transgender people, their sense of confidence about their identity,and, as well, the very real dangers they can face in public schools. As ayoung person of color, King's experience was further amplified by racism.Wearing eye shadow to school and trying to be authentic in this hostilecontext of school, King was continually open to taunting and bullying, andtried to keep strong by flirting with tormentors (

      King's story shows how strong young people can be when they don't conform to traditional gender roles, are gay, or are transgender. They can feel confident about who they are, but they also face real dangers in public schools. As a young person of color, King dealt with not only issues related to gender but also racism. For example, King wore eye shadow to school to express their true self, but this made them vulnerable to teasing and bullying. King tried to stay strong by flirting with those who tormented them to cope with the harsh environment.

    2. he rela-tionship among gender bias, homophobia, and harassment is complicated.On the one hand, young women of all sexualities experience harassment,including homophobic harassment if they act in ways that do not fit thenorms for women.

      The relationship between gender bias, homophobia, and harassment is complicated. Young women often face harassment, no matter their sexual orientation. This can include homophobic bullying when they don’t act like traditional women are expected to. For example, if a young woman acts more assertively or dresses in a way that is seen as masculine, she might experience negative reactions not only because of her gender but also because of assumptions about her sexuality.

    3. Schools, like the rest of the social world, are structured by heterosexism-the assumption that everyone is and should be heterosexual (that such anassumption should have to be stated or even reinforced by policies indicatesthat everyone might not be heterosexual but they should be). Curricula, texts,and schools too often are constructed to reflect that heterosexuality is notonly the norm but also the only possible option for students. Heterosexismalso is reinforced by homophobia, overt expressions of dislike, harassment,and even assault of sexual minority people, a practice that members of theschool community often ignore or dismiss as typical behavior based on theheterosexist assumption that either there are no LGBTQ people present inschool communities or, if there are, those LGBTQ people ought to learnto expect a hostile environment.

      Schools, like other parts of society, often operate under heterosexism. This means there is an assumption that everyone is or should be heterosexual. When policies have to state this assumption, it suggests that not everyone is heterosexual, but the expectation is that they should be. The way school programs and materials are set up often shows that heterosexuality is not just seen as normal but as the only option for students. Heterosexism is also supported by homophobia, which includes negative feelings, bullying, or even violence against LGBTQ people. Unfortunately, people in schools often ignore or accept this behavior as normal, believing that either there are no LGBTQ individuals in their school or that those who are present should deal with a hostile environment.

    1. Acknowledging the existence of m~ilnp~e cultural,local, and global forms of same-sex affection and ge~der d1vers1ty may beone starting point. Examining the variety of expre~s1~ns of tolerance a_ndvalue of minority identities within minority and maJ_onty cultures may giv_einsights into the differences that make up even seemmgly co~~rent and urn-fied cultures and subcultures. These issues should be familiar to an_yonethinking carefully about how to study and educate about_ any !orm of iden-tity. But there are particular features to sex and gender identity that makeaddressing it challenging.

      Recognizing that there are many different ways people show same-sex affection and express their gender is a good first step. Looking at how different cultures, both minority and majority, accept and value these identities can help us understand the variety within cultures that may seem similar on the surface. These ideas are essential for anyone who wants to study or teach about identity. However, discussing issues related to sex and gender identity can be tricky due to some unique challenges that come with these topics.

    2. Despite pressures to conform to normative gender, gender remains inplay. While this sense of play may open possibilities, play with gender orplay with sexuality also raises anxieties and bias against transgender andgender nonconforming youth. Such bias and harassment affect gender non-conforming, transgender, or cisgender youth at a higher rate than gender con-forming youth and may come from peers or school personnel (Grossman &D' Augelli, 2006). By suggesting to adults that there are more possible identi-ties for students to inhabit than adults might consider normal or even possi-ble, such play may indicate not only adult insufficiency of understanding butperhaps also adult lack of control of young people's identities. Unexpecteddifferences in identity or behavior may seem to break rules, even rules thatadults think didn't need to be articulated, like those indicating that boys andgirls, or young men and young women, dress in particularly gendered ways.

      Even though there is pressure for people to fit into traditional ideas of gender, many still express themselves in different ways. This exploration of gender can create new opportunities, but it can also lead to worries and biases against transgender and gender non-conforming youth. These biases and harassment happen more often to gender non-conforming, transgender, or even cisgender youth compared to those who fit traditional gender roles. This negativity can come from both peers and teachers. When adults see that there are more ways for students to express their identities than what they think is "normal," it shows that adults might not fully understand these identities. It may also suggest that adults feel they are losing control over how young people identify themselves. Surprising differences in how someone identifies or behaves can seem like they break unspoken rules, like the idea that boys and girls should dress in specific ways.

    3. The com-plexity of gender and sexuality is interwoven, as well, with messages, defi-nitions, and reworkings of the meanings of other categories of identitylike race, ethnicity, social class, disability, and religion, among others.

      Gender and sexuality are complex and are connected to other parts of a person's identity, like race, ethnicity, social class, disability, and religion. This means that how we understand gender and sexuality can change based on these other identities. For example, the way someone experiences their gender may be influenced by their race or social class. Recognizing these connections helps us see the full picture of a person's identity and their different experiences.

    4. Heterosexism and heteronormativity, the beliefs and social practicesthat maintain the dominance of heterosexuality over other forms of sexu-ality, rely on a stable conception of binary genders. Men have to act inaccordance with norms regulating masculinity, and women nee<l to be femi-nine, not only in order for their genders to be legible in expected ways butalso to justify the "opposites attract" version of heterosexuality. Gen<lerand sexuality, then, sort out who is "normal," and the categories providenorms that interact with one another.

      Heterosexism and heteronormativity are ideas and practices that support heterosexuality as the dominant sexual orientation. These concepts depend on clear and fixed ideas about two genders: male and female. Men are expected to behave according to certain rules about masculinity, while women must follow norms related to femininity. This reinforces traditional views of gender roles and sexuality, making it difficult for other sexualities and gender identities to be accepted.

    5. Practices like having elementary students line up bygender or organizing teams of boys against girls, she argues, highlight theimportance of gender differences to young students at a time when theyalso are working through different ways of being gendered themselves.Concerned that the institutional culture of schools not only creates rigidideas about gender but also pits one gender against the other, she suggeststhat adults in schools consider more carefully the messages about genderthat even simple practices, like making gender-based small groups or en-couraging gender-segregated play, convey to young people.

      The author points out that practices in schools, such as having kids line up by gender or forming teams of boys against girls, can make gender differences very important to young students. At this age, children are figuring out their own identities related to gender. The author is worried that schools create strict ideas about what it means to be a boy or a girl and encourage competition between the genders. She suggests that adults in schools should think more about the messages these simple actions send about gender. For example, dividing students into gender-based groups or promoting gender-segregated play might have a negative impact on how children view themselves and each other.