I would first note that it is cheaper, under the Opening the Future model, to support the OA route than to buy every new book that the Press publishes. This route saves libraries money.
This is true, but as libraries increasingly move from a "just in case" to "just in time" model of collection building, probably not relevant. We want access to the book when it is needed, which is fine if it is already open, but less helpful if we have to wait until enough people subscribe. And we probably only want to pay for that book, not a whole bunch of others that might be from the same press but aren't necessarily of interest to our community.