36 Matching Annotations
  1. Dec 2021
    1. The NSE has been used to create digital storytelling apps for themuseum visitors in the case of two museums so far, the University ofAthens History Museum and the Criminology Museum. In both cases thestorytelling apps have been created through the collaboration of themuseum curators, domain experts as well as creative designers and sto-rytellers. In all cases an iterative design process has been followed,alternating design and development with evaluation activities. In thecase of the History Museum, the app, named “What should I study”, is currently available in Google Play Store for download and also to visitorson demand with mobile devices provided by the museum.

      It's very unique that the NSE has been used to create an app that addresses the ability of mobile access to archaeology.

    1. Zines can become highly collaborative projects, especially within public and community archaeology, and allows for both archaeologists and non-archaeologists alike to flex their various skills and expertise. As more academics become less enchanted with normative methods of publication and communication, perhaps we are due for an

      This is interesting to see the new developments in the field and the accessibility to displaying the skills individuals have in the academic setting.

    1. Courses for Individuals How To Do Archaeology Always wanted to go on a dig? This step-by-step 'How To Do Archaeology' course will guide you through what archaeologists do - and how you can get involved! Learn more How To Be A Junior Archaeologist Archaeology isn't just for adults! This course is for kids and teens who want to be the archaeologists of the future. Learn more How To Do Photogrammetry Want to create your own 3D models? Photogrammetry is fast becoming an essential skill for any archaeologist or heritage-lover who wants to record or share their discoveries online. Learn more How To Do Archaeology Always wanted to go on a dig? This step-by-step 'How To Do Archaeology' course will guide you through what archaeologists do - and how you can get involved! Learn more How To Be A Junior Archaeologist Archaeology isn't just for adults! This course is for kids and teens who want to be the archaeologists of the future. Learn more How To Do Photogrammetry Want to create your own 3D models? Photogrammetry is fast becoming an essential skill for any archaeologist or heritage-lover who wants to record or share their discoveries online. Learn more How To Do Archaeology Always wanted to go on a dig? This step-by-step 'How To Do Archaeology' course will guide you through what archaeologists do - and how you can get involved! Learn more How To Be A Junior Archaeologist Archaeology isn't just for adults! This course is for kids and teens who want to be the archaeologists of the future. Learn more How To Do Photogrammetry Want to create your own 3D models? Photogrammetry is fast becoming an essential skill for any archaeologist or heritage-lover who wants to record or share their discoveries online. Learn more prevnext

      This website is an excellent resource to build the connective and collaborative learning experience that was discussed in the article by Perry in the previous week. The use of different mediums and starting points of comprehension allows for the access into the field from different levels. This is wonderful to see as it can encourage the youth of tomorrow or an adult simply seeking a new passion in life. By offering these starting points it allows for the user to feel comfortable transitioning into the field with readily available resources at their finger tips. the classroom aspect also encourages group learning which in my experience creates better comprehension and problem solving.

    1. Although a significant portion of the enslaved population in the Americas were Muslim, scholarly research of Muslims in the American colonial and antebellum periods has been limited. To date, the most extensive research on enslaved African Muslims in the field of historical archaeology is chronicled in my dissertation, “How Religion Preserved the Man: Exploring the History and Legacy of African Islam through the Yarrow Mamout (ca 1736-1823) Archaeology Project.” Without a local community concerned about the historical integrity of the small Georgetown property, this community would have continued to be lost, their history forgotten. And yet, just as Islam sustained their bodies and minds through the peculiar institution of slavery, Islam helped preserved the community, history, and enduring legacy of enslaved African Muslims.

      This website is directly demonstrating how the engagement of a community can preserve and aid in the archaeological research being done. By including the groups that have inhabited the area during the period of research it allows for input and perspective that may have otherwise not been tied in.

    1. As a final note, this has also been an experiement in open science and reproducible research. Obviously this essay is not a highly scientific work, but it's completely open (ie. no login or subscription required). All the data and code to reproduce the results are freely available, for example on the day of archaeology blog and the code repository attached to this essay (and the software to run the code is aslo free and open source). This approach to research is uncommon in archaeology, perhaps because of the relatively small scale of most archaeological research compared to fields where openness and reproducibility are more normal (ie. astronomy and genomics). It might be worth considering making this normal for archaeology, not least for the lowering of barriers to putting to work of archaeologists into the hands of the public, and helping them get a richer understanding of what the past was like, and how we know what it was like.

      This experiment is quite useful in the development of fundamental digital research skills. It uses the concept of transcoding in a sense to build skills and produce more efficient results when conducting research based off of the use of digital aid.

    2. For example, medieval churches and Idaho in topic 22 and the cat circus in topic 7 are rather dissonant combinations. However, many of the topics seem quite distinctive and coherent, such as 4, 6, and 20.

      Are these key words selected simply based on the frequency they appear in any given article with a filter then applied for sentence constructing words such as "as, to, the, etc."

    3. By browsing the topics I can see what they key ideas are without having to read every word of every post. This approach is inspired by Matt Jockers' analysis of the 2010 Day of Digital Humanities blog posts, and Shawn Graham, who did a similar analysis of the 2011 Day of Archaeology blog posts and has also written an accessible introduction to topic modelling.

      I've noticed the incorporation of this modelling in your work during prior weeks and think it is a very unique manner to comprehend information and collect relevant sources for projects.

    1. Heart-centred practice, then, can turn archaeologists into activists. In our case, it makes our work as much about social justice in the present as about reconstructing the past. It demands that we work to shift the values and priorities of our own disci-pline and academia more broadly so that they do not work counter to the aims of integrating the hand, brain, and heart.

      This is a very unique approach to the academic world and out of all the recent strategies and research methods I believe this should be incorporated into the academic world whole heartedly.

    2. We argue that a heart-centred approach to archaeology makes our research caring work – work done with and for others – and that its out-comes, while more personally rewarding for us as people, are not valued in the same way within academia as those of a mind-centred approach.

      This is one of two sentences for this weeks readings that have connected with me on a personal level. I genuinely believe there is often a disconnect that people fall into throughout their life as the do work simply to complete it or gain access to the next meaningful task in their life. This quotation brings me hope that people are thoroughly enjoying the work they are conducting in an attempt to contribute and better the world around them.

    1. The colonial collecting project was a destructive mechanism by which Indigenous cultural materials were removed from communities and detached from local knowledge systems. Much of this material remains today not only physically distant from local communities, but also lodged within a legal system that steadfastly refuses local claims to stewardship of these materials ...incorporating Indigenous knowledge systems into library and archive practices will not just enhance relationships and create access to records, but more importantly, it has the potential to decolonize archival practices and modes of access

      This is horrible to see how cultural material has been stripped away from Indigenous groups and makes me think of the attempts by the Canadian government to eliminate indigenous culture. In no regard am I a legal professional but restricting access to the group that was stolen from does not seem legally or ethically correct. This needs to be changed to put more power in the hands of the indigenous group, or at least more inclusion needs to be incorporated while the work on the materials is being done.

    2. e salient point is that the communities themselves decide together how best to share and circulate their cultural materials. For example, if a tribe has traditional access parameters around the viewing of sacred materials limited only to elders, or if some songs should only be heard in specific seasons, ...they can use these protocols to determine access within the database itself.

      This is the first time that I've come across the group indigenous to the area is the one in charge of the research being conducted. This is wonderful to read and to the best of my knowledge addresses a gap in cultural disassociation.

    1. My own experience of attempting to capture large datasets from social media via the use of web scraping with Python entailed a week-long training course, the purchase of numerous ‘teach yourself’ books, and intense frustration on my journey.

      I've gone through a similar experience when trying to create a web crawler for one of my professors. I had no background using python but had the idea to fill a need if i would be able to develop a web crawler for my professors research purposes. After extensive work and coding videos I realized the code I had built off of the instructional videos was not adapted for the newest version of python that I had built it in. Infuriating to say the least.

    2. The recent challenges faced by the academic community who wish to access platform data is a reminder that digital scholars need to first engage with increasingly complex technological skills, and tools with which to collect data, such as the use of APIs and web scraping. In practical terms, this means that social/digital archaeologists need to either have previous experience of digital data capture and coding skills, or time and money to acquire these skills, or have access to human and computing resources who can provide these technical research support.

      This seems to be a serious barrier in the field of digital archaeology. This class is a perfect example in my mind as all of the students are coming from different technological backgrounds. Now to put it into further perspective most students have a access to the digital world and resources for learning through our university. Without this affiliation individuals are greatly disadvantaged when trying to enter the field of digital archaeology.

    1. For example, when collecting oral histories, the origins of individuals or their families can be a sensitive topic: regional origin, sect, the length of time settled in Qatar, and population group or tribal affiliation are tied in with status and politics to a degree that make them uncomfortable topics in a modernized Qatar.

      This is quite interesting that there is a stigma or class division so deeply involved in the region that discussing ones origins or family lineage becomes a unsettling topic.

    1. It is rare to conduct research in archaeology without reusing older datasets. This is still largely done based on syntheses of published material in 'text-form' rather than data. In the absence of a more thorough review, this has the risk of reusing data for which the correspondence between texts and data has not been verified, which could add to the general 'crisis credibility' in science. However, encouraging and rewarding transcoding has the potential to transform the field in providing a positive message when 'wrong' results are found. It is necessary to make this process public in order to reaffirm always that discoveries are not straightforward and that it takes errors and debates to progress.

      The closing remarks of this article take a very light hearted approach to the topic of transcoding and mistakes. I truly believe that the use of transcoding to identify mistakes is a brilliant idea that also allows for a greater understanding of the material being transferred. But it also acknowledges that mistakes need to be learnt from, they are inevitably going to happen so it's better to us them as a learning experience that as a point of failure.

    2. On the contrary, an apprehension shared among researchers is that pointing out errors may cause more damage than benefit. It could harm the reputation of the data publisher or analyser and eventually the credibility of discipline itself. However, remaining inactive may prove even more counter-productive, as we will not be able to answer the question: 'Is archaeology a trustworthy discipline?' How is it possible to invert these potential damages into benefits for the people behind the dataset, the reproducers, and ultimately archaeology and its public?

      I believe that all data has error in it to some extent it's just a matter of limiting that. Human error needs to be accounted for in the creation of work.

    1. uch collaborative digital experiences can encourage participants not merely to identify with the past, but to rethink their place in the present and future, imagining the world and its inhabitants in a more complex and malleable fashion.

      It's quite interesting how this research is addressing the literary gap of how to connect strangers through these collaborative learning interactions. The aspect of how it can effect their comprehension of the world moving forward is quite impactful in my opinion especially in a time period where social interactions are quite limited.

    1. The last ideals – transparency and accountability – were key in the framing of President Obama’s well-known ‘Open Government Directive’ in 2009 which directed agencies to make government data open by default. And many more countries, states and cities have followed suit to host open data portals and write open data into policy. Seventeen countries and over fifty cities and states have adopted the International Open Data Charter which outlines a set of six principles guiding the publication and accessibility of government data.

      Is this in response to the information that was brought forth by Edward Snowden regarding the invasion of privacy by the United States government?

  2. Nov 2021
    1. Everyone can help to make these shifts, no matter how they self-identify. When you are visiting archaeological or historical sites, or even looking at the architecture and images in your built environment, ask yourself: Who and what is foregrounded here? What, and who, is missing from this story? Try to read between the lines when you hear interpretations of past cultures. How have racial constructs in the present limited understandings of the past?

      This author finishes off their article in an excellent manner, it makes me think about instances in my life where I've learned information but was not told the whole story. The largest example I can think of is the historical learning that happens in school regarding Canada's past. The history of Canada has been completely told from the perspective of white colonial settlers and the side of the indigenous people has barely been voiced. Directly building on the point of the author here.

    1. In many ways, the movement for open access, defined as freeof charge and free of many copyright and licensing restrictions,conceptualized by Suber (2012:4) as the barrier-free revolution, isperfectly suited to the demands of higher education. Discourseon open science parallels demands to remove economic andphysical barriers to training within increasingly tense researchand scholarly ecosystems

      This is an interesting perspective, from my research on access to higher education I've found that law schools for example selectively limit the amount of people that can attain the knowledge of the law. The restriction of this information has previously been used to create rarity around lawyers for example. Making individuals more of a rarity than others. This also limits how others in society can access the information already in existence. The barrier free revolution could easily crush the constructs of capitalist societies if patents and copyrights were stripped away.

    Annotators

    1. By seeking information about specific children of the LodzGhetto, participants learn more deeply about the forced movement andlabor and genocide of Jews and other persecuted individuals under theNazi regime. Participants may gain a new perspective on the scale of suchatrocities when combing through the numerous records, and investigatingthe details of the students’ lives may better serve to humanize them asindividuals rather than anonymous statistics.

      This is a wonderful representation of how a quantitative research method may be effective regarding certain aspects of research but when it comes to diversification of stories and personal connections it limits the context. The experiences of individuals involved is therefore left out and the exclusion of this information can numb the researcher to the emotional aspects of the work they're conducting.

    1. Heath Fogg Davis agrees: his book Beyond Trans argues that we don’t need to classify people by sex on passports and licenses, for bathrooms or sports, among other things.

      This topic is very thought inducing as there could be an argument that he is correct. But there is also discourse that I have in my sports and politics class that brings forth many points about the transitioning of athletes from one gender division to another in competition. There is also a comfortability factor that could be involved regarding the bathroom argument. I personally don't believe a young girl would be fully comfortable sharing a washroom with a grown man.

    2. Seager’s research focus is gender, the environment, and policy (see figure 4.1), and she points out that there is more global data on gender being collected than ever before. And yet, these data collection efforts often still leave many people out, including nonbinary people, lesbians, and older women.

      This passage of the reading confuses me, the author talks about gender but then crosses over listing other variables such as age, and sexuality. I'd like to know the explanation behind this trend being pointed out, is it simple refusal of answering questions by non-binary individuals due to the discomfort of only being offered male or female options in the gender data collection?

    3. and she points out that there is more global data on gender being collected than ever before. And yet, these data collection efforts often still leave many people out, including nonbinary people, lesbians, and older women.

      This passage of the reading confuses me, the author talks about gender but then crosses over listing other variables such as age, and sexuality. I'd like to know the explanation behind this trend being pointed out, is it simple refusal of answering questions by non-binary individuals due to the discomfort of only being offered male or female options in the gender data collection?

    1. The data shown here – open budget data about government procurement in São Paulo – do not look very technically complicated. Rather, the complicated part is figuring out how the business process behind them works – how does the government run open bids? How do they decide who gets awarded a contract? Are all bids published here or just the ones that got the contract?

      The author asks some excellent questions here and I have personally wondered how the data produced by governments is verified or validated. Especially when outside contractors are used to acquire the information it devotes a certain level of trust from the viewer of the data to not only the government, but also to the chosen contractor. I'm therefore quite sceptical about individual figures when there are no other supporting numbers or data sets to confirm the general context of the data set. This is due to the manipulation and corruption many governments have been known to participate in.

    2. Shortly thereafter, they had to issue an apologetic retraction because their numbers were just plain wrong. The outlet had used the Global Database of Events, Language and Tone (GDELT) as their data source. GDELT is a big data project by computational social scientist Kalev Leetaru, with previous development by Philip Schrodt and Patrick Brandt.

      Should this false data be blamed on the organization that created it or by the organization that caused histeria due to the publishing of it.

  3. Oct 2021
    1. In conclusion, although the database currently contains data for just a handful of cemeteries, we anticipate that as it grows in popularity and more groups upload their datasets, it will become an essential open access tool for genealogical and burial monuments research.

      The ethical boundaries regarding burial sites still seems very grey in my eyes and I believe it will run into complications within certain religions and countries. If so will this simply halt the expansion of the database for geographic areas or religious areas of the world?

    2. The study of burial spaces can encompass a broad range of topics and interests, and address different scales of analysis. For example, one might explore the role of churchyards and cemeteries as a whole, questioning the perceived differences between ecclesiastical and municipal management, and the social, political and legal trends that changes in burial space provision represent and reflect (Rugg 2013a, 2013b).

      I commented on the article by Katherine Cook regarding the potential for demographic records due to the cross referencing of burial datasets and church records in early western civilizations. This could help create a better understanding of the topics mentioned here as well as create a better picture for historians as a whole.

    3. The database currently includes data from sites in England and the Isle of Man, but it is hoped that its geographical range might be increased in the future.

      Does the research from our class qualify for data input into this database?

    1. Finally, there is also a lag in the emergence of commemoration amongst the freed com-munity; many of the families that established themselves and acquired wealth and stabilityprior to emancipation do not begin commemorating their dead until much later periods.This was perhaps influenced by the position and inclusion of African-Barbadians withincongregations, as well as the growing economic and social stability that was beingachieved throughout society in the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries.

      This is unfortunate to hear but demonstrates the collective thoughts of the time period towards treating and western world regarding people of colour. The barriers that can be seen by indigenous/people of colour in caucasian communities is quite sickening. Even the realm of proper burials reflects this matter as outlined in the article. It's also intriguing to see how the cross referencing of data from monoliths with church records can allow a basic reconstruction of populations in earlier settlements of Barbados.

    2. Dating after1887, the simple monument was later updated with a small block of coral stone andlong inscription on a metal plaque that highlight Waterman’s achievement as a talentedand prolific stone mason, and his ‘reputation for his sensitive work with sawn coralstone’. This material statement not only references Waterman’s trade and talents, butalso a longer history of using carved coral stone to subvert traditionally British materialculture and make statements within significant venues for creating and negotiatingmemory and social relationships

      It is interesting to see how Waterman has adapted to create a regional variation to monuments as a way to drive away from typical British norms.

  4. Sep 2021
    1. Several simple steps could serve to increase ethical rigor in digital archaeology, and allow specialized practitioners and more general users of digital archaeological methods and tools to operate within consensus-led frameworks of ethical decision making.

      This seems to be the first article that offers solutions to the questions regarding ethical barriers in digital archaeological methods

    2. The assumption that archaeologists will behave ethically in fieldwork, analysis, and publication relies on a further assumption, that they have been taught what ethics mean in those contexts.

      Building off of this point there are also different ethical boundaries when you look at cultural differences.

    1. ‘We have the right to a safe, secure andnon-threatening working and livingenvironment. We do not tolerate anyform of discriminatory, abusive, aggres-sive, harassing, threatening, sexually—orphysically-intimidating, or related prob-lematic behaviours that compromise thewellbeing, equality, security or dignity ofother human beings.’

      I completely agree with this point, its strange to me thought that people simply just aren't inclusive in this day and age. Especially in a workplace, you're there to do a job how can someones identity bother someone to the extent that threats are necessary.

    1. It is no exaggeration to say that the advancement of archaeology in Canada will need a revolution in digital literacy, data management and informatics, and even social media and web platforms.

      It's interesting to see the extent that the lack of digital archeological education is lacking within Canada.

    2. For exam-ple, there are those who see the incor-poration of technology as employing a tool or set of tools

      This made me think of an article i saw earlier regarding UCLA working with Apple to detect depression, and cognitive decline in users. I just thought this was an interesting example of tools being incorporated into real life scenarios