6 Matching Annotations
  1. Oct 2024
    1. Controversy over my article was so heated that news of it spread from the rarefied world of academic philosophy into the New York Times. I was widely misinterpreted as saying that transgender and transracial identities are the same, or that gender and race are constructed in exactly the same way.

      Oh no! Someone, somewhere, was wrong on the internet! Certainly would be sad in a newspaper like the New York Times. So, was it the NYT that spread this misinformation? Was it any colleagues? Was it the comment section? How could I know! No quotes.

    1. My research lies at the intersection of critical race, feminist and animal ethics. Throughout my research, I have considered several ways in which animals, women and racially subordinated groups are oppressed, how this oppression often overlaps and how it serves to maintain erroneous and harmful conceptions of humanity. Uniting these lines of research is an underlying concern to theorize justice for oppressed groups.

      Seems like someone who could engage with the material.

    2. Calls for intellectual engagement are also being shut down because they “dignify” the article.

      But the argument is she didn't intellectual engage at a level reasonable for a journal article.

  2. Oct 2021
    1. (He was not charged in the death but was convicted of carrying a concealed weapon.) “Nothing bad happened to his career,” Chappelle says. “Do you see where I’m going with this?” In the United States, he says, you can shoot and kill a Black person, “but you better not hurt a gay person’s feelings.”

      He was not charged in the death because self-defence is considered reasonable. The concealed weapons charge because he had a concealed weapon. It also seems inappropriate to racialise an event between two black men without justification.

    2. But if there was a meeting where this was decided, no one invited me.

      This has been a long-standing discussion and has become more public and more nuanced over the last decade specifically. If Helen Lewis is unaware of this, it's because she, as a journalist, hasn't involved herself in these conversations among comedians.

    3. On Rotten Tomatoes, the show has an approval rating of 43 percent from critics … and 97 percent from the audience.

      When culture war issues raise their head people organize down votes or up votes using these review site. This makes the audience ranking unrepresentative of the actual audience.