The idea that we can all learn to “write in general” is not just a harmless myth. It’s a dangerous idea that needs to die because it hurts students and frustrates teachers and employers. And writers who believe it are easily discouraged because they don’t know how to learn what they need to learn in new writing situations.
While I agree that it is not possible to "write in generaI", I disagree with the sentiment that the skills are never transferrable because I believe the overall writing techniques and conventions learned in English can be applied to other subjects. While the papers may not all be structured in the same way, I think there are general writing themes that remain consistent (thesis, evidence, conclusion). These attributes of a paper will always be relevant, no matter the subject. While not all papers are argumentative per se, I do believe they are in some sense. In nearly every essay I have written, I have been trying to back up a claim through references and evidence that my claim holds true. In other words, defending my point.