9 Matching Annotations
  1. Oct 2020
  2. learn-us-east-1-prod-fleet02-xythos.content.blackboardcdn.com learn-us-east-1-prod-fleet02-xythos.content.blackboardcdn.com
    1. With both his to ria ns a detailed examinat io n o f pa rti c ul ar cases ends up reduci ng a llegedly strong causes to weak o r pa rtia l o nes, which o nly operate in a minority of insta nces.

      The arguments are based on circumstance, each case focuses on something else.

    2. Few topi cs remind us more vividly that the past is a foreign country, whose assumptions w ere o ften very different from our own.

      IMPORTANT: The past was a different place. Their laws and beliefs differ widely from ours. Much like a foreign country, their traditions and views may seem bizarre to someone from outside the country

    3. One of the mos t tiresome fo rms of this, o fte n found in writings o n w itc hcraft, is to treat o ur a ncesto rs as if they w e re little bett er th an me nt a l defectives.

      There is a habit of seeing our ancestors as stupid. They were acting in a way that was normalized and expected in those times. Similar things could be said about us in the future.

    4. here has been a rash o f medi cal pseudo-expl anati ons, invoking syphilis, ergot ism and magic mushrooms.6 A feminist myth has come into existence, usuall y accompanied by wild inllati on of the numbers, in which women w ere the real target, parti cul arl y in their ro le as healcrs.7

      Different peoples' backgrounds result in different interpretations of the past that fit their views and beliefs

    5. M ost o f us, I assume, would agree that any seri ous interpretati on of European witchcraft must be multifactori al, relating it to a number of discrete, or at least separabl e, causes

      Witchcraft doesn't appear under exact circumstances, each case is different and shouldn't be looked at in a general scope

    6. crtainly there is not much hope that new evidence will transform the situati on in some dramati c fashi on.

      There isn't a magical answer to painting a correct picture of the past

    7. It does seem at least possib le that th e strong ly e mp irical bi as of most h isto ri a ns has contributed to this s ituatio n, a nd th at the wood is at times being lost fo r th e tr ees

      Bias has painted a tilted picture of the past

    8. One of the reasons for studying witchcraft has been that it illuminates many other subjects, and can help us to reconstruct th e di stincti ve social and intell ectual character of a past age

      Witch craft appears under very specific conditions and by studiyng the past we can learn about societies that allowed those conditions to appear