concluded that people who follow this kind of diet have a 33 per cent lower risk of depression than people who don’t
curious what they define as depression here
concluded that people who follow this kind of diet have a 33 per cent lower risk of depression than people who don’t
curious what they define as depression here
is now being recommended as a diet that can make you happy because it encourages a diverse and healthy gut microbiome
uh. didn't we disprove this claim earlier in the unit?
We need to get our diet diverse and cut out the chemicals before thinking about psychobiotics
i hear ya, but what about those with eating disorders or restrictive diets who are unable to eat balanced meals? or those who can't afford healthy food?
That might mean we’re dealing with stress less effectively
another factor in why everyone's mental health sucks now?
The public too have become wary
understandably so, although it's super annoying that medical scams killed the public's trust in actual science
That means that one standard treatment won’t work on everybody, so we may well end up needing personalised probiotics, which will be expensive
the idea of personalized medicine is actually super interesting, and something that i think would be worth exploring down the road, although capitalism will likely hinder it
Sadly, we’re unlikely to see any of these treatments very soon
:(
so the evidence so far is that some of these probiotics might do just as well as the more commonly prescribed drugs
this is super encouraging!!
they also brought about improvements in language skills, social interaction and behaviour
as an autistic person, i feel very divided about this. on one hand, i crave having social skills come easily for me like they do for neurotypicals, but there's also a vocal portion of the community who oppose any sort of treatment to make them seem more "normal."
“We don’t have the trials at the moment to make those recommendations, but it will happen in the future.”
how long? will the coronavirus delay this?
As such, any nutritional deficiencies in your diet that lead to a drop in the diversity of your gut bacteria population could have a negative impact on your mental wellbeing.
another instance of the link between mental health and diet -- this is super interesting! the tie between the two makes the connection make a lot more sense tbh
serotonin – an essential brain chemical known to influence mood
interesting! it sounds like they work very similarly to ssris, even if the method is a little different
tryptophan
huh?
We’re over the first hurdle of saying there’s a link, but we’re a long way from pinning down the exact mechanisms and treatments
this statement is much more in line with the tone of the other article
higher quality of life
i wonder how they define this
But doctors have long known that mental health problems, such as bipolar disorder and even autism, are often associated with gut problems, for example inflammation
i actually didn't know this until now! huh
This year a large review of studies found that probiotics yielded a small but significant effect in reducing anxiety and depression. A smaller study, published in the journal Translational Psychiatry, found that introducing a Bifidobacterium probiotic into the guts of healthy volunteers reduced their feelings of stress and improved their memory
it sounds like they're using the same data from the other article but framing it in a more optimistic way
The hope is that they will eventually provide powerful new treatments for depression and other mental health conditions, as well as helping us to deal with everyday stress and anxiety
this is extremely exciting!!!
if they’re happy, you’re happy too
another correlation between bodily health and overall health!
said
to answer the question of who should be educated about this, i like the idea of educating the general public! i think a lot of people are blissfully unaware of injustices like this that are occurring, and since at least on paper, governments are supposed to follow popular opinion, maybe that will inspire them to take action
To argue that money is more important than human health is appalling, and at the end of the day if we don’t protect farm workers, we’re not gonna have food. It’s that simple,” he said
it's sad that we need to be reminded of this, but it's very true
Farm worker advocates have been working with state agencies and the governor’s office since March 19 to pin down adequate rules to protect workers who live in the U.S. and those who are on work visas
ideally there wouldn't need to be advocates and the state would automatically protect them, but here we are
United Farm Workers and other advocates filed a lawsuit about a week ago against Washington state, arguing that farm workers do not have adequate protections
i wonder in what ways?
“We’ve been relying on symptom checks for deciding who needs to be tested, and who needs to be isolated,” Kling said. “And maybe we need to think differently about the whole thing
this is what happens when there isn't adequate tests!!
A tall person wouldn’t feel weird asking that, so why should I?
this is a great way of putting things in perspective!!
But this radical message has long since been co-opted by clothing brands, diet companies and soap corporations
this is what happens when there's not a strong grassroots movement to go off. for example, pride is still coopted by lots of companies, but there are enough lgbt activists out there to ensure that the message doesn't get too off track
A similar approach with fifth- and sixth-graders actually increased their intention of bullying their fat classmates
this is really interesting (in a very sad way) and worth delving into more. do middle schoolers just suck??
Another survey showed that two years of getting kids to exercise and eat better didn’t noticeably affect their size but did improve their math scores—an effect that was greater for black kids than white kids
kinda telling that this was considered a failure! at least we already know what to do
they have presided over a country where daily exercise has become a luxury and eating well has become extortionate
yes!!! politicians are so incredibly out of touch
The United States spends $1.5 billion on nutrition research every year compared to around $60 billion on drug research
wonder how much michelle obama spent on her (well meaning but problematic) childhood nutrition campaign? probably more then 1.5 bil
Health plans refuse to treat this as anything other than a personal problem
insurance companies can choke
Telling someone, 'Lay off the cheeseburgers' is never going to work if you don't know what those cheeseburgers are doing for them
listening to your damn patients SHOULDNT be revolutionary but
There’s a lot we can do right now to improve fat people’s lives—to shift our focus for the first time from weight to health and from shame to support
as angry as the food industrial complex makes me, i really like the idea of taking this approach, given how unlikely it is for any of that to change in the immediate future
Diet is the leading cause of death in the United States, responsible for more than five times the fatalities of gun violence and car accidents combined
ngl im a lil skeptical of this
our food supply
more ways in which capitalism is screwing us over!
most of the time, thin folks sit around brainstorming about how to be better allies
while their heart is in the right place, i feel like if you go to this when you're thin, your heart is already in the right place, so you're just preaching to the choir
Fat people, though, never get a moment of declaring their identity, of marking themselves as part of a distinct group. They still live in a society that believes weight is temporary, that losing it is urgent and achievable, that being comfortable in their bodies is merely “glorifying obesity
this is a super interesting point! i rly like of reclaiming fat as part of your identity
Surveys of higher-weight people, however, reveal that they hold many of the same biases as the people discriminating against them
this is what happens when there are no communities made for fat people! internal fatphobia adds up
One explanation is that navigating increasingly white spaces, and increasingly higher stakes, exerts stress on racial minorities that, over time, makes them more susceptible to heart problems
this is super interesting -- i wonder if there are any other situations in which something similar is true
A 2017 survey found that 89 percent of obese adults had been bullied by their romantic partners
this is extremely upsetting
She obsessed over her own, calling herself “enormous” despite being two sizes smaller than her daughter
growing up with a mom who was hyper skinny and always concerned with health, that 100% rubbed off onto me. don't do it y'all!!
spent months looking for a single public health campaign, worldwide, that attempted to reduce stigma against fat people and came up empty
wow!!! this is seriously telling :/
Kids as young as 3 describe their larger classmates with words like “mean,” “stupid” and “lazy.
how much of this is evolutionary and how much is learned?
“These findings suggest the possibility that the stigma associated with being overweight,” the study concluded, “is more harmful than actually being overweight
but of course people will still use this as credence for the whole "fat people don't live as long" argument. ugh!!!
What’s worse, only a few cities and one state (nice work, Michigan) officially prohibit workplace discrimination on the basis of weight
crazy considering how much progress has been made in other areas regarding discrimination!! fatphobia and ableism need more attention :/
Then, when she’s alone, she eats all the leftovers by herself, in the dark
this is why shame doesn't work!!
Men aren’t supposed to think about this stuff—and I think about it constantly
i really feel for men with body issues given that there's literally no resources out there for them
“A lot of my job is helping people heal from the trauma of interacting with the medical system
this position shouldn't have to exist!!!
Three separate studies have found that fat women are more likely to die from breast and cervical cancers than non-fat women
ugh, i wonder if this is part of where "obesity causes cancer" comes from
At the time, I was training for serious winter mountaineering trips, hiking every weekend and going to the gym four times a week.
we need more representation of fat and fit people!!!
5 percent got help arranging a follow-up visit
this is incredibly low -- i wonder how it compares to skinny patients
think weight falls under their authority
very good point!! eye doctors don't comment on a patient's oral health
The reason for this is that physicians are often required, in writing, to prove to hospital administrators and insurance providers that they have brought up their patient’s weight and formulated a plan to bring it down
so they're encouraging doctors to ignore the issue at hand in order to push their own agenda? wonderful
Primary care physicians only get 15 minutes for each appointment, barely enough time to ask patients what they ate today, much less during all the years leading up to it
i very much think this is an issue, but i'm curious about what the solution would be
“He managed to denigrate my fatness and my blackness in the same sentence,” she says.
if you needed another reason to hate fatphobia, there's 100% a huge intersection between that and race
have spent more than a decade of their lives in the high-stakes, high-stress bubble of medical schools
while it's obviously no excuse, i do think the cutthroat environment of school probably doesn't help :/
shaming smokers and drug users with D.A.R.E.-style “just say no” messages may have actually increased substance abuse by making addicts less likely to bring up their habit with their doctors and family members
which is why i'm skeptical that the "smoking problem" has really improved that much in the last 40 years!
bioethicist Daniel Callahan argued for more stigma against fat people
for a bioethicist, that's incredibly unethical
It’s the last area of medicine where we prescribe tough love,” says Mayo Clinic researcher Sean Phelan.
isn't mayo clinic supposed to be all progressive and body positive? emphasis on the supposed to part
Some of these doctors are simply applying the same presumptions as the society around them
honestly doctors judging patients for their weight is not only worse then society judging people, as the doctors are in a position of power, but also far more common
discovered that 14 percent had barred all new patients weighing more than 200 pounds.
how is this remotely legal???
And my doctor was congratulating me
this is why some people don't trust doctors!!
her body would start to process food differently
don't think that's how it works buddy
still couldn’t shop at J. Crew
honestly i think the limited store selection is an underrated aspect of fatphobia
exhausted and dizzy from hunger, shivering in the Kansas heat
when i say that trying to be skinny is often far more dangerous then being fat, this is what i mean
only 11 percent of large people depicted in news reports were wearing professional clothing
wow!!!
grip strength
is this actually a good measure of health or are they trying to show how arbitrary weight is?
battling hunger all day, every day, for the rest of your life
this is interesting, given that commonly held beliefs (which are usually true in my experience) suggest that your appetite will decrease once you eat less. curious where the truth lies in this one
Since 1959, research has shown that 95 to 98 percent of attempts to lose weight fail and that two-thirds of dieters gain back more than they lost
wow!!! i wish these numbers were published more
I avoided so many activities where I thought my weight would discredit me
this is what happens when fat people get jack for media representation! (along with many other variants of fat phobia obviously)
It feels like the worst kind of weakness
great analogy! being fat and being weak are two things that are very over stigmatized in american culture
Nearly half of 3- to 6- year old girls say they worry about being fat.
will this lead to an even higher amount of eating disorders in the future? probably :/
It is also an excuse to bully fat people in one sentence and then inform them in the next that you are doing it for their own good
yes!!! i don't think many people realize how condescending and harmful telling people to lose weight "for their own good" is
nearly 80 percent of adults
these are much higher numbers then i've previously heard -- i wonder what their guidelines for obesity are
must compete with the traditions, assumptions and financial incentives of the society implementing it.
health and capitalism don't mix :/
startled to death by a loud noise
is that where this saying came from?
But doing it is really hard, and we have to work on it
you know what else is hard? making sure that wealth is equitable so people can actually practice this if they choose!
“When we get through this current epidemic, we are all going to want to be healthy
there's a big difference between healthy as in not infected with COVID, and healthy as in eating the right foods!
He encourages people to follow three steps to improve their health. Limit fast carbs and prioritize slow carbs like beans, legumes, whole grains, nuts, fruits and vegetables. Watch your LDL cholesterol, a strong driver of heart disease, and eat a largely plant-based diet to help lower it if necessary. And lastly, engage in daily exercise to help control your weight and improve your overall metabolic health.
these are all decent weight loss tips...for those who can actually afford that!!
The less often you eat them, he said, the less you will crave them
this is also something i've picked up! which is unfortunate, i've noticed that if i eat too much processed foods, healthier foods stop tasting as good :/
accelerate weight gain
god forbid!!!
As a result, Dr. Kessler said, they fail to turn off our hunger switch
this is interesting! i do def hear what he's saying, i've noticed a lot of "junk food" doesn't actually fill me up
“The physical properties of the original starch molecule are no longer the same
this is actually pretty interesting -- i do 100% think that over processing of foods are an issue
grain-based desserts such as cookies, doughnuts and granola bars are the largest source of calories in the American diet
would be interesting to actually dissect why this is!
successful diets
why are these diets successful?
including genetics, environment, diet and lifestyle
and financial situation!
two minutes later I say to myself, ‘Why did I do that
also not loving how he's promoting food guilt!
That may not be surprising: They are cheap, satisfying and shelf stable
how much is because they're comfort food, how much is because they're non perishable, and how much is because they're cheaper?
Yet even he is not immune from the problems plaguing many of us. For years he yo-yo dieted and fought to control his weight
dont love that they're painting struggling with your weight as a "problem!" this isn't to say being a certain weight can't be a problem, but it feels like they're painting struggling with eating too many fast carbs as problematic
which investigated how processed food companies design products that have powerful effects on the brain
kind of interesting how he published a book blaming companies for putting fast carbs in foods after working at the corrupt FDA
conditions that can increase the risk of complications from Covid-19
true, but there are also other ways to negate this -- like staying quarantined!
avoiding the urge to make frequent trips to the kitchen throughout the day to snack on these foods can be tricky.
especially when people are in a worse emotional state!
especially when European and American coronavirus quarantine strategies look superficially similar to those used by authoritarian nations such as China or Singapore
i wonder if part of people's resistance was seeing the initial response in china and gawking at it thinking "that could never be us" (until it was)
while providing support for everyone who is forced indoors
can't think of a whole lot of government led support efforts going on right now, would def be a good thing to expand on lore
“We elect people to [make] decisions at a national level to look after ourselves. That’s not authoritarianism, that’s democracy.”
in theory this makes sense, but i do think we're a lot farther from actual democracy then she's implying
I think what this [pandemic] is showing is that collectivism is absolutely necessary,” she said
will this have a long term impact on our mindset regarding climate change? probably not, but i hope so
As an individual, I have a right not to be infected by somebody who is not paying attention,” she said
this feels like just as much someone expressing their individual freedom as someone wanting to go out, yet this mindset is being ignored...
I think we’re just starting to lose a little bit of our sense of country and our sense of rights.”
i wonder how much she actually believes this vs is using it as an excuse. i'd imagine the majority of people who are using this argument have some inkling deep down that's it's a logical fallacy, albeit one that they don't want to face
Arizona state Rep. Anthony Kern (R) and Oklahoma Gov. Kevin Stitt (R) both tweeted (and deleted) defiant photos from crowded restaurants. “We can’t all just shut ourselves and stay home,” Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI) told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. “The economy has to move forward.”
not to over generalize, but i don't think it's a coincidence that every senator who talked about this was right leaning
One of the most important things for people is to have a sense that they are in control of their own life, that they have agency
how of this comes from the american mantra of liberty and free will?
shut down social gatherings.
i didn't see any linked sources for this article -- is it reliable?
On March 12, the United Kingdom’s Prime Minister Boris Johnson championed a “herd immunity” strategy, which seemed to encourage young people to go about their business and contract Covid-19.
wow, i didn't realize he did as bad of a job with the coronavirus as Trump did. kind of ironic that he ended up contracting it
suggested this optimism was bolstered by people’s belief that they had fewer human interactions than their peers, making their risk of contracting the virus inherently lower
how much of this came from social media giving the illusion of people's lives being more action packed then they are?
often in public discourse around smoking, drinking and driving, and vaccines.
it's telling that these three things (or at least drinking and driving and not getting vaccines) are such easy things to avoid and yet many people still do them
It’s about our risk to others, and that might make it a little more difficult to understand
we've been conditioned to value our own well being over everything else, and the coronavirus is showing how widespread this mindset has become
“The fact is we have to continue as a population to go on with our lives,” Michael J. Bradley Jr., the parade’s grand marshal, told PBS.
while i get this sentiment, anyone using the fact that we have to go on with our lives as an analogy is hilariously off base. a cancer patient doesn't ignore their illness because they don't want chemo to impact them living their lives! you can still "go on" while adjusting what you do, the notion that you have to keep everything the exact same is some blatant denial
“America will again and be soon open for business
it's telling that the first analogy he thought of was a business related one
Disney World in Florida
interesting that he name dropped a specific business -- were he and disney linked somehow?
During the Great Depression, President Franklin D. Roosevelt made an enemy of an emotion, telling the public, “We have nothing to fear but fear itself
this almost feels invalidating, as if it's unreasonable to feel fear during a massive economic crash. a very good example of men in power pushing a mantra of emotional suppression!
they often contain a kernel of a consumerist message
i've noticed somewhat of a consumerist message during the coronavirus, especially towards local restaurants and businesses affected by this. i'm all for supporting local business, but the responsibility shouldn't be on the people, esp given how much this is hurting so many of them financially
Twenty years later, in World War II, the British government coined “Keep Calm and Carry On” to boost morale in anticipation of a Nazi invasion.
this was a terrible choice in a war that directly affected many of its citizens (especially jews), and feels like a clear example of the government clearly not being able to put itself in the mindset of its citizens
After half a century, however, the phrase was exhumed — in part as a message to those weathering the Great Recession.
will this keep being brought up in every disaster? it's kind of interesting thinking about how calming messages like that can be hurtful, and how to strike a balance between compassion and realism
This has a mortality rate of 10 times that.
interestingly, 10 times 0.1 still isn't that high of a number. people should be focusing on the rate of infectiousness, not the rate of death
At this moment there are 546 confirmed cases of CoronaVirus, with 22 deaths.
i don't recall hearing this comparison until Trump said it -- how did this inform people's opinion of the coronavirus?
tweeted on March 9
is Trump really a reliable source??
But without a good frame of reference for the present crisis, we’ve looked to lessons learned from past calamities, including natural disasters, terrorism, war, and economic collapse, to guide us.
while i understand why people are drawing on them in absence of a different point of comparison, looking at past disasters really does feel like comparing apples to oranges. they're different issues, so naturally they're gonna get different solutions
For at least a century, citizens have believed that in the midst of a disaster, their job is to go on with their daily lives as best they can — otherwise, the enemy will win
this is a super interesting point! i didn't make the connection until now, but that's very much an American mindset, especially post 9/11 (which is really the last time everyday life has been uprooted to this extent)
“[W]e have an obligation to keep our buildings open,” company chair Marcelo Claure and CEO Sandeep Mathrani wrote in a memo.
it's interesting that he's painting a fairly selfish decision as one for the greater good
“Coffee is not essential at all,” one barista told Vice.
is quoting your own article really a reliable source?
And so the crisis has also revealed humanity’s tendency to flout the rules.
i wonder if people would take this more seriously if the government hadn't already pissed so many people off in various ways
But in the United States, Australia, and much of Europe, these restrictions are harder to devise and enforce, mostly because democratic norms and a strong sense of individual liberty prevail.
is this mantra of individualism as common in Australia and Europe since liberty is distinctly an American thing?
“It was delicious,” she tweeted, “and I took my sweet time eating my meal. Because this is America. And I’ll do what I want.”
a prime example of how much of an intersection there is between individualism and perceived american standards of liberty
Such heavy-handedness might even make things worse, as it may well shift the voluntary compliance we see today into resistance
will COVID change people's relationship with the police or even lead to some type of revolution?