59 Matching Annotations
  1. Nov 2019
    1. Imposing a split between men and women that corresponded to a separation be-tween the public arena of the autonomous, competitive, possessive in-dividual and the private, selfless world of familial domesticity was as essential to the colonizing process as it was to the organization of the expanding nation-state and its market-oriented economy.

      needing to introduce Western misogyny to break apart Native livelihoods

    2. She taught her to "take land before you ever take money" and not to "fall in line with the white peoples' demands that we should blend in with civi-lized people."47 Even into the 198os women passed "the power down from generation to generation" that came from sustaining a tradi-tional relationship to the land.

      how Native women actively preserved their culture and traditions

    3. Christine Galler told the assem-bled delegates, "I am a woman and you might think it funny that the Colvilles elect a woman ... but the capacity of an Indian woman's head has the same amount as a man or a white man."

      decentering European men in the construction of manhood

    4. Within the Department of the Interior more powerful agencies successfully pressed for the erection of dams along the Columbia River that would flood Native American lands and interrupt the salmon runs.

      how American progress almost always ruins indigenous land or practices

      e.g. Dakota Access Pipeline, TMT on Mauna Kea

    5. Collier's di-rector of Indian education reorganized the curriculum to teach girls some farming skills, but the Bureau· of Indian Affairs continued to em-phasize women's primary role as domestic. Like other New Deal agen-cies, it placed the need to restore men's jobs and men's place in the economy before any feminist concerns about women's economic independence.

      Only teaching Native girls farming skills as a necessity of the Great Depression

      Did not reconfigure the gender dynamics to be equal, especially after economic recovery

    6. Administrators condemned the backwardness of Native Americans as the major reason for their failure to become self-supporting agriculturalists and housewives, yet their own policies reflected a rigid adherence to gender ideology that limited the possibility of success.

      This versus the fluidity of gender roles and performances prior to assimilation

    7. They in-sisted that Native Americans undertake the risks of small farm agriculture at a time when white farmers were struggling to survive. Having denied women the education and skills necessary for farming, they proceeded to define women as unable to farm. In drawing up reg-ulations "relating to the Indians and Their Lands," Oscar Lipps, the chief official of the Northern Idaho Agency, included among those too disabled to cultivate their own land "unmarried women," "widows who have no sons of suitable age," and "all married women whose husbands and sons are not in a condition to cultivate." Only adult males were defined as "able-bodied."31 As a consequence, land owned by women readily passed into white hands.

      Even though Native women were legally allowed to own land, they face barriers where they tended to lose their land due to the legal definition of "unable to cultivate"

    8. "citizenship and Chris-tianity should go hand in hand" with individual land title.

      separation of church and state?

      how the construction of American whiteness and citizenship is tied to Christianity (e.g. dismissal of indigenous beliefs and religions)

    9. these women justified their activism in the public realm on the basis of the special qualities they had acquired through their location in the private world of home, family, and moth-erhood.

      Early feminism agitated for more educational opportunities for women, but it was to train them to perform better in the domestic sphere.

      It was not radical and reinforced the idea that the woman belonged in the home.

    10. In the I 88os legislation was proposed to "help the Indians to become independent farmers and stockmen by making them individual land holders," loosen "the fatal tribal bonds," and open the way "for their entrance into citizenship.1

      White Americans saw Native American kinship as a weakness rather than an asset

    11. Sixty years later, their successors were still trying to teach female converts to "dress better, to put aside the blanket, and to make bread" so they would become "refined, talented, learned American ladies.I/

      reflects the failures of conversion attempts but also the resiliency of Native women to preserve their cultural and traditional practices

    12. Indeed, a fluid notion of gender identity enabled some men and women to assume the activities

      fluidity of gender

      gender expression and performance not tied to sex

    13. Among these peoples women played a major role in the production and trade of subsistence items, principally through gathering roots, berries, and other edible plants. Women also shared in the collective work of fishing that sup-plied most of the protein in their diets, caught small animals for food, and joined the buffalo hunts that ventured across the Rocky Moun-tains into the Great Plains. By virtue of their contributions, women controlled the distribution of the food, the dwellings their labor had built, and all the products of their labor.

      how Native women engaged in reproductive labor

    14. women were to be sheltered within the private space of the home while their husbands were to "be allowed a man's rights and privileges and be held to the performance of a man's obligations" and enjoy "the autonomy of the individual.

      see previous annotation

    15. As elsewhere, the colonizing process by which the United States es-tablished control over indigenous peoples involved the "domestica-tion" of women

      Rendering women to only exist inside the house. She is not supposed to be participating in the public sphere, and, if necessary, must be accompanied by a man, probably her father or husband.

    16. She must be recognized, with affection and respect, as the center of domestic life.

      What does this form of recognition mean? Native women were already recognized and highly valued in their communities for their reproductive labor.

    17. Nothing will be more apt to raise the Indians in the scale of civilization than to stimulate their attachment to permanent homes

      Tying a man to a permanent piece of land as part of American republicanism

      needed to create the image that the American Dream is achievable even by people whose cultures did not align with ideals of republicanism

    18. "We live just like white folks," a Native American husband was quoted as saying in a 1933 report issued by the Bureau of Indian Affairs, "since my wife joined the extension club.1

      extension club?

      perhaps assimilation projects that does outreach for Native American women

    Annotators

    1. Although all women in American society have had to justify their abili-ties and fight for legitimate rights, native women have had to work double-time in their efforts. Like women of other ethnic minorities, Indian women have had to confront the effects of sexism in its most insidious form. They face a peculiar kind of sexism, one that is grounded in the pernicious and ever-present ideologies of racism. Native women are judged not only as females but as Indians. They are oppressed not only by their gender but by their class and ethnic status as well. The stereotypic images from which the larger society draws its picture of Indian women clearly reflect the double-barreled character of their oppression

      This addresses the concept of intersectionality before it was coined.

    2. Disclaiming and dismantling false perceptions from the past has been a necessary step in developing a more accurate awareness of women's present con-ditions and their place in history.

      Scholars have to first prove that these racist and misogynistic views are wrong before making their point.

      In having to do this, they inherently point out the issues with academia as an institution.

    3. While it is recognized that men and women have been impacted in different ways by such problems as poverty and unemployment, most American Indians maintain that their problems must be tackled through the united efforts and interests of men as well as women.

      how coalitions and power building can erase its more marginalized members

    4. Increasingly, they are moni-toring research and insisting that studies have direct relevance to the pressing needs of their own com-munities.

      demanding that the work be for the community

      roots of ethnic studies? "for the community; by the community"

    5. Despite the recent surge of publications on women in different cultures, writings on American Indian women have lagged behind.

      Perhaps this is due to the harmful (and intentional) representation that Native Americans don't exist today?

      While many women of color are producing work about their own identities, Native American women are struggling to gain access to these opportunities, rendering silenced by these barriers on a mainstream level.

    6. Through the gathering of new information and the rein-terpretation of old data, scholars are beginning to remedy the oversights and prejudices of their prede-cessors by incorporating women into the analysis of total social formations.

      Sometimes, only reinterpretations are needed because Plains women have always been documented. However, the documentation as well as the analysis are often made in a racist and gendered perspective.

    7. Many ethnographic descriptions, for example, portray the work of Plains Indian women as menial and monotonous--a view clearly originating from Euro-American ideas on the value of household labor ( see Kehoe in this volume)

      Ethnographies were culturally incompetent

    8. n this century, only a hand-ful of books and articles have been written about Plains Indian women, and most of these are auto-biographical

      Plains women literally had to start writing themselves into history because they were being left out of the narrative.

    9. n keeping with the pervasive European idea that women constitute the passive, inferior, and hidden side of humanity, Plains Indian women are rarely visible as individuals or a category of people in the early journals of tra-ders, missionaries, explorers, and government agents

      Plains women are gendered through European gender constructs, which are obviously different from the culture they are situated in. By placing European values on these women's experiences, it erases the cultural values that Native Americans have.

    10. Typically, the native woman is portrayed as a "Princess" (chief's daughter) who mediates the conflict between Redmen and Whi temen, or else she is cast as a "Squaw" who has been used and abandoned by a philandering trader or soldier

      Native Plains women are positioned in relativity to white men and not as an independent person/character. Their importance is only relative to how they help the white men.

    11. Where are Plains Indian women in the mass media? They are present but hidden in the background of popu-lar images. In most Hollywood movies (with the recent exception of Walks Far Woman), Plains Indian women are mere backdrops on stages dominated by the actions and dialogue of men. They are seen fleeing burning ti pis while the men are fighting off the U.S. cavalry. Women are located on the sidelines scraping hides or gathering roots as the camera focuses in on a line of warriors returning from battle. Inside the tipi, women sit in the background making moccasins or cooking a meal while the debates of an all male coun-cil dominate the picture.

      Native Plains women are literally represented in the margins -> misrepresentation that Native women are unimportant to their society

    12. is portrayed clashing with the U.S. cavalry, swooping down on wagon trains, or fighting off the attacks of enemy tribes. The image of the warrior appears as an emblem in advertizing, as a mascot for sports teams, and as a major subject in the bronze statuary of city parks and squares. Equally popular in media myth-making are the hunters. Whether depicted surrounding herds of buffalo or stalking the lone antelope, the hunter shares equal billing with the warrior in the creation of popular symbols and myths.

      hyper-masculinity of Native American men

    13. Chiefs constitute the most dominant symbol in this image-making. Commonly shown wearing a Plains Indian costume of fringed buckskin and a full-feathered headdress, the chief has dominated classic characterizations of Indians in the mass media. Scores of factual and fictional accounts have focused on the lives of such well-known men as Sitting Bull, Quanah Parker, Red Cloud, and Geronimo. Photographs and paintings of these and lesser known Indian men fill the pages of coffee-table picture books on Native Americans, and they are printed on widely distributed posters, greeting cards, and post cards.

      Even in representation, racist stereotyped are reinforced. These representations are not for the sake of representing, but rather for the sake of creating these caricatures that align with the construction of whiteness.

    14. Since the end of the nineteenth century, the cultures of the Teton, Blackfeet, Comanche, Pawnee, and other native peoples of the Great Plains have formed the basis for popular stereotyping of Indian life in the United States and Canada.

      Government facilitated settlement meant that more white Americans were coming in direct contact with Native Americans. Written accounts like Little House on the Prairie incorporated racist stereotypes about the Plains Native Americans, which was then disseminated to the public.

    Annotators

  2. Oct 2019
    1. As Kathleen Bahr has noted in her study of Apache families, grandmoth-ers held the ultimate responsibility for the well-being of their grand-children. As bearers of cultural heritage, they played a vital role in sustaining their families well into their old age.5

      valuing elders for their cultural knowledge

    2. n Navajo society, to speak well and per-suasively is a highly lauded skill and a sign of exceptional intelligence. Traditionally, male leaders were called naat'áanii, or ones who speak persuasively. In contemporary studies, only men have been associ-ated with leadership roles in which the ability to speak persuasively and with eloquence is central.47 In contrast, Juanita is associated with oratory skills, suggesting that some abilities in Navajo society are not limited to the male gender.

      how both types of skills are valued despite its gendered aspect

    3. Traditionally, Navajos have established kin relationships before any communication could be initiated. Furthermore, as historian Theda Perdue notes, women have been central to establishing kin relationships between tribal groups.33

      similar to Caddo culture where women were the ones creating bonds

    4. Although those of us present, storyteller and listeners, did not witness the events or see the actors in the story, there is faith that the events occurred at some time and that the actors were living beings.30

      the need for "proof" as a western concept

    5. The fact that indigenous identity is presently a topic of discussion reflects contemporary preoccupations with biological identity and blood notions of authenticity. Studies that discuss these issues also demonstrate that identities are cultural constructions that differ across time, culture, and race.2

      cultural identity vs. biological identity

    6. It was under American rule that began in 1846 that war and con-flict escalated. By the 1860s, slave raiding had reached an all-time high since the American military encouraged such enemies of the Navajos as the Utes, Comanches, and New Mexicans to attack Navajos, which they eagerly did because Navajo women and children were very valu-able in the slave markets

      divide and conquer tactic to destabilize indigenous communities

    7. For example, although non-Indian accounts claim that Juanita was a Mexican slave whom Manuelito married and favored among his wives, Navajo oral accounts depict her as a Navajo woman. Mostly, her descendants say they have not heard stories that she may have been a Mexican slave adopted into a Navajo clan.20 Indeed, sometimes when I return to Tohatchi, I inevitably come across some relative who has heard of my research project and asks, “So, was Juanita a Mexican?” It is interest-ing to note what pieces of information and knowledge linger, whereas others receive little if any attention. No doubt, Navajos’ knowledge of Juanita is informed by non-Navajo accounts. Our grandmother’s identity is shrouded in the history of the slave trade, in which indige-nous women and children were targeted. Taken as captives and forced to become part of their host society, many crossed cultural boundar-ies. Being adopted into a host society in the Southwest during colonial

      difference in accounts demonstrates the ways slaves and family are viewed in Navajo vs. white American persepctives

    8. When he became insistent, Changing Woman told him that she would consider his request, but that she must think about it; if it suited her, she would comply. Such narratives indicate Navajo women’s sense of self and the autonomy that they enjoy in their society

      Navajo women's power rooted their care and emotional labor for their family

    9. ust as Changing Woman sustained her children, so do Navajo women today. All things that sustain life, including the earth, agricultural fields, corn, sheep, and even men who are nurturing, are called mother.15 Furthermore, moth-erhood is the role from which Navajo women speak with authority.1

      why Navajo women are valued and granted authority

    10. When Changing Woman reached womanhood with her first men-ses, the first Kinaaldá was performed for her. She was dressed cer-emonially and thereafter known as Yooł gai Asdzáán. The Holy People came to the ceremony and blessed her with prayers and songs that today are part of the Blessingway Ceremony. Her birth, coming of age into womanhood, and the birth of her own sons, Naayéé Neezgháni (Monster Slayer) and Tó Bájísh Chíní (Born for Water), furnish the template for women’s roles in Navajo society.13 As Gary Witherspoon recounts, the ceremony and the accompanying prayers and songs enabled Changing Woman to have the power to create a new people who would transmit this power to the next generations.14 Today the Kinaaldá remains an important ceremony for many Diné girls who reach womanhood.

      menstruation as a celebration insread of something to hide

      how creation stories explain tradtion

    11. The next generation, the great-grandchildren of Manuelito and Juan-ita, also experienced boarding schools and were sent away for long periods. In the 1930s, other ancestors saw the beginning of reliance on wage labor, when livestock could no longer provide independence. Because of such historical experiences under federal Indian policy, which sought to exterminate the Navajos culturally, the oral tradition was profoundly disrupted.

      physical separation of generations as a form of cultural genocide; weakening oral traditions: weakening bonds between elders and the youth

    12. His retention of these documents impressed upon me how Navajos are concerned about the past and how they hope to learn more about their history, including family stories.

      relearning history as a way to heal and stop intergenerational trauma

    13. Dághá Chíí, shown in figures 10 and 13, was a Navajo scout who served with the U.S. military in the 1880s. In the late 1930s, when he was elderly, he was awarded a pension for his services.4

      high enlistment of Native Americans in military due to lack of access to other professions

    14. Anthropologist Gary Witherspoon in his study of Navajo kinship and marriage notes that the mother and child relationship determines all others among Nava-jos. This is the relationship upon which concepts of K'e, or kin rela-tionships, are based.2 This is true of Hastiin Ch'il Hajin and Asdzáá Tł'ógi’s descendants, who acknowledge K'e based on Asdzáá Tł'ógi’s maternal clan, the Tł'ógi.

      queering white American ideas about family

    15. The impetus to record narratives of my ancestors is moti-vated by the same reasons as those expressed by other Native scholars, who note that the history of Indian education has meant a loss of tra-ditional knowledge and Native languages and little if any access to our own histories.

      re: education as a form of assimilation & cultural genocide

      • valuing knowledge over belief, not a lot of work produced about Native American Studies
    1. Women,children,andtheelderlywereroustedoutoftheircabinsanddirectedatgunpointbysoldiers.Menwereyankedfromthefields,withmanyunabletolocateandjointheirdisheveledfamilies.

      separation of family from the beginning of the march

      form of genocide

    2. Women,children,andtheelderlywereroustedoutoftheircabinsanddirectedatgunpointbysoldiers.Menwereyankedfromthefields,withmanyunabletolocateandjointheirdisheveledfamilies.

      separation of family from the beginning of the march

      form of genocide

    3. Thetheftanddestructionoflives,lands,andcultureslinktheseeventsasholocausts,andinthespecificcontextofCherokeehistory,slaveryandremovalareintimatelyconnected.TheexpulsionofCherokeepeopleclearedthewayfortheexpansionofAmericanslaveryintothoseabandonedlands;theexpansionofslaverythencontributedtotherapidgrowthofcottonproductionthatwoulddramaticallyboosttheU.S.economy.

      how white supremacy and capitalism worked hand in hand while benefiting each other

    4. in1835thestateofGeorgiaenlistedtheGeorgiaGuardtoseizetheCherokeeprintingpressandthusdisablethepublicationoftheCherokeePhoenix.

      stopped mass communication among the Cherokee Nation, making it harder for them to organize united as one

    5. TheAmericanIndians,nowlivinguponlandsderivedfromtheirancestors,andneveralienatednorsurrendered,haveaperfectrighttothecontinuedandundisturbedpossessionoftheselands....TheserightsofsoilandsovereigntyareinherentintheIndians,tillvoluntarilysurrenderedbythem;andcannotbetakenawaybycompactsbetweencommunitiesofwhites,towhichcompactstheIndianswerenotaparty.”

      refers to consent, agency, and sovereignty of Native Americans

    6. Doubtlessitwillbepainfultoleavethegravesoftheirfathers;butwhatdothey[do]morethanourancestorsdidorthanourchildrenarenowdoing?Tobettertheirconditioninanunknownlandourforefathersleftallthatwasdearinearthlyobjects.

      Jackson is comparing white English settler-colonizers, who willingly migrated from Europe to what is now New England, to the forceful and violent displacement of indigenous communities from their homeland. It pales in comparison because one was willing and the other was not.

    7. TheSupremeCourtdecidedinfavorofCherokeesemisovereignty,definedas“domesticdependentnation[hood]”anddeemedGeorgia’sactionillegal.

      illegal removal of Cherokee peoples

      re: laws are a social construct and often a tool for white supremacy

    8. TheratificationoftheCherokeeConstitutionin1827furtherincensedGeorgiaofficials,whoinsistedthatthenotionofasovereignCherokeerepublicviolatedthestate’srightstocertainlands.

      The Cherokee Nation attempted to assimilate into "civilization" but still was not seen as legitimate in their sovereignty

    9. Twiceshewasforcedoutofherhome,madetorecoverandrebuild,firstatthehandsofslavecatchersandthenatthehandsofAmericansoldiers.
      • re: discussions about the relationship between Native Americans and African Americans -> "African Americans can be settlers and anti-indigenous" -> untrue, considering that many kidnapped Africans were indigenous people themselves

      • intergenerational trauma of displacement

      • how displacement itself can haunt intergenerationally; people who had ancestors that were displaced are highly likely to be displaced

    10. thelessonshehadlearnedfromhersixtyyearsaslaveandtenyearsfree:thattherewasnobadluckintheworldbutwhite-people

      white privilege working to benefit white people but strips people of color--especially Black folks--of opportunities and access

    Annotators