disagreement (most frequently by southerners, against civil-rights legislation
more history I was unaware of, but makes sense
disagreement (most frequently by southerners, against civil-rights legislation
more history I was unaware of, but makes sense
The disparity in size between states has exploded.
ok this is crazy - thinking about reforming a system and what does it mean for a system to be accepted as being obsolete. why is this so hard to accept?
rdheaded political compromise between people who believed in some version of what we’d call “democracy” and people who didn’t. The Founders
important history (not even predicted to be good)
The Senate is affirmative action for white people. If we had to design political institutions from scratch, nobody — not even Republicans — would be able to defend a system that massively overreprese
we know it is this way
The reason is simple: Residents of small states have proportionally more representation, and small states tend to have fewer minority vo
did not think about this before
hild H
use this as evidence for factors contributing to YLL from perinatal conditions
1,167.901,566.00778.6
drug induced deaths - specifically for males as a target population
290.2265.4314.91,251.51,710.885
difference in YLL for black v white due to perinatal conditions
Absolved of thought, of responsibility, of guilt, and finally of humanity, all is well: the head of the state thinks for us, we need only obey. If the head of the state happens to be criminally insane, that is not our affair.
spoken about in beautiful minds - diffusion of responsibility for both those ordering the tasks (but doing actually doing them with their own hands) and those executing them (those who are just following orders of higher ups). In htis case it seems Eichmann is victim ot both of these forces due to the nature of his position
he never thought of the murdered; he thought of the effect they made on him, and the probable bad effect on the nerves of the young SS.
spoke of any horrors in terms of his own "people" and the effect on them
closing the file against future intrusion on his work.
stark language
His voice is ugly, with a hard R, a sound that makes one think of a hammer and a knife. Neither by voice, accent, nor vocabulary is he an educated man.
imagery
mankind
uses this language throughout- wants to extend this issues beyond jews and germans as it often is isolated here
Behind me, in the public section of the courtroom, an old woman with a worn fine face, wearing a kerchief on her head and a newspaper around her shoulders, against the unaccustomed air cooling, wept -- without movement, without sound, and without stopping
tells this like a story, accounting the events of the whole courtroom
miserly crack
lol
Moving to Opportunity program, which randomly assigned families living in high-poverty neighborhoods to groups that were and were not given vouchers to move to low-poverty areas. Children in these famil
like the documentary
Feminist theories show how such male-gendered laws are structured and enforced at a cost to women's health. Similarly, laws permitting younger marriage of girls than boys promote the stereotyping of women in childbearing and service roles, and exclude them from the education and training that boys receive to fulfill their masculine destiny as family and social leaders
laws that give way for differences in health later in life.
Supplying appropriate care for women may be characterized as a duty of positive human rights to which states must allo- cate resources.
duty to allocate spending on a human rights basis
Positive rights may be difficult to observe in states with strained resources. However, it is a notorious fact that states invoking poverty to justify nonobservance of duties to de- fend women's health often provide disproportionately large military budgets.
allocation of spending in governments as a solution to addressing gendered health needs. not just negative rights
Human rights regarding health require that the state pro- vide health care that individuals are not able to obtain or provide on their own.
more on positive rights
introduce a gender perspective into na- tional health policies.
positive rights, considering the discrimination of women and not just removing barriers
Women's negative human rights require that states remove all such barriers to women's pursuit of their health interests, except for those governing safety and efficacy of health services in general
one side is removing barriers, negative rights
omen's poor physical and psychological health may represent a metaphor for the poor health of women's rights in the body politic and in influential community institutions, whether political, economic, religious, or health car
health is a reflection of influences and rights
Rights relevant to health include those to protect women's employment and grant equal pay for work of equal value; to education; to information; and to political participation, influence, and democratic power within legislatures. These last rights permit women's rights to be respected in the general conduct of states
rights of women as human rights
Modern analysis has shown systemic denial and suppression of information concerning women's victimiza- tion by violence and rape in their homes.
gendered health differences via denial of issues as issues
Clinically trained health professionals enhance their di- agnostic and therapeutic capacities via recognition of the links between women's health status and the social environments they inhabit.
going on to how we can improve health differences in the clinical setting
The critical transition is from doctors treating women as inferior to men, physiologically different only in reproductive functions, to recognizing women as equal to men, only different because of the gendered experiences that affect their health.
how gender changes medical provision. basic concept of medical treatment being different bc not seen as equal. how it should be framed
Illness alone was used to explain women's unhappiness in the midst of affluence and caring family members, a situation that by conventional stan- dards should produce contentedness
distress in clinical setting attributed to disease and not life conditions. goes back to argument that medicine has moved towards science and laboratory focus
hether it is dis- criminatory and socially unconscionable to criminalize a medical procedure that only women need is a question that usually goes not simply unanswered, but unasked.
gendered perceptions of male dominance results in authority denying women of control over reproduction via birht control and abortion
Women's image as vectors of disease to sexual partners and to children they conceive has been recycled in the modern pandemic of AIDS
how gendered perceptions in health care have lead to worse health outsomes
omen being primary or sole economic supports of their families, and also being unmarried, widowed, or abandoned mothers of their children.
yet they have unqeual opportunity deprives families and women of econ, psych, social determinants of health
Societies have modelled their role ex- pectations on these assumptions of the natural order of hu- mankind. Historic social structures, including the organiza- tion and conduct of warfare, the hierarchical ordering of in- fluential religious institutions, the attribution of political power, the authority of the judiciary, and the influences that shape the content of the law, reflect this gender difference of male dominance and female subordination.
role of women in society - suboordinate roles may lead to less control over health
Sex is a matter of biological differen- tiation, whereas gender is a social construct by which vari- ous activities and characteristics are associated with one or the other sex
(if you need a source for sex vs gender)
1994 World Report on Women's Health, issued by the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics, concluded that future improve- ments in women's health require not only improved science and health care, but also social justice for women and re- moval of socially and culturally conditioned barriers to women's equal opportunity.
how an action by societies moves towards fixing the issue of gendered health disparities
Accordingly, women have been considered only to the extent that they are different from men, focusing medical attention on reproductive characteristics.
women as applications of male developed medicine -- gendered difference?
Their practical needs are addressed through programs like the Safe Mother- hood Initiative, co-sponsored by several UN agen
program that aknowledges practical needs of women but not the gender specific needs
But it can also deny a woman consideration as anything more than a vehicle for human reproduction. Women's reproductive function fits within a social frame- work of gender that affects women's capacities and health
how gender effects reproductive health
. Sex categorization and the accomplishment of gender are not the sam
still female even if unfeminine.
To be sure, equality under the law does not guarantee equality in other arena
while we may have the equal rights amendment, this doe nt absolve us of responsibility to continuously work towards gender equality
n. Doing gender furnishes the interactional scaffolding of social structure, along with a built-in mechanism of social control. In appreciating the institutional forces that maintain distinctions between women and men, we must not lose sight of the interactional validation of those distinctions that confers upon them their sense of "naturalness" and "rig
this si not something that is purely institutional, but our interactions with others also perpetuatate existing norms
If we do gender appropriately, we simultaneously sustain, reproduce, and render legitimate the institutional arrangements that are based on sex category. If we fail to do gender appropriately, we as individuals-not the institutional arrangements-may be called to account (for our character, motives, and predispositio
reasons gender divisions are sustained in society
re contrived with respect to the fact that others will judge and respond to us in particular ways. We have claimed that a person's gender is not simply an aspect of what one is, but, more fundamentally, it is something that one does, and does recurrently, in interaction with ot
gender is something that is maintained through social interactions with the knowledge that we will be judged and responded to in certain ways.
128 GENDER & SOCIETY / June 1987 categories of being (Garfinkel 1967, pp. 116-18) with distinctive psychological and behavioral propensities that can be predicted from their reproductive functions. Competent adult members of these soci- eties see differences between the two as fundamental and enduring- differences seemingly supported by the division of labor into women's and men's work and an often elaborate differentiation of feminine and masculine attitudes and behaviors that are prominent features of social organization. Things are the way they are by virtue of the fact that men are men and women are women-a division perceived to be natural and rooted in biology, producing in turn profound psycho- logical, behavioral, and social consequences. The structural arrange- ments of a society are presumed to be responsive to these diff
gender divisions are permanent. distinct psychological and behavioral characteristics determined by reproducitve function
he other. Sex, we told students, was what was ascribed by biology: anatomy, hormones, and physiology. Gender, we said, was an achieved status: that which is constructed through psychological, cultural, and
defintion of sex and gender
n. Rather than as a property of individuals, we conceive of gender as an emergent feature of social situations: both as an outcome of and a rationale for various social arrangements and as a means of legitimating one of the most fundamental divisions of so
gender is the way we interact with each other and a way to legitimate social divisions
ng ‘overly intellectual’ and‘obscure’ messages
hard to convey messages of feminine and masculine stereotyoing to those who have never thought of t this way before. how do u distinguish in a messaging campaign?
women and men
issues with marketing include the danger of gender stereotypes persisting, but this may be necessary of we conclude that certain health risks are due to socialized behaviors. perhaps identifying these stereotypes offers more beneit than harm as it may be harmful to ignore them.
Gender equality legislation in the USA currently disallows such sex-specificdiscriminations unless sex-specific risk behaviours are proven to be genetically orbiologically base
interventions based on "gender" are currently not allowed
What, for example, might be the impact on female depression, ormen’s negative coping behaviours?
could be an interesting point to bring up as far as spreading health messages? upside is that there is evidence it could be effective (see smoking examples) downside is promoting gender stereotypes
edia images of female smoking asfashionable. Following the campaign, the percentage of young women, aged 1835, who smoked, dropped by an average of 4%,
marketing works!
man
to talk about interventions that have and have not worked: marketing and cigarette smoking
hat depression in women, and alcohol use and risk-taking in men, aregendered manifestations for similar underlying distress. Po
interesting point about dalys being similar if you consider the causes
Theway that gender interacts with stigma, to affect compliance with care, can differsignificantly by locale, depending on local confidence about TB treatment, andgendered aspects of the marriage and job markets
example of TB on how gender roles for both men and women can affect how or if they seek treatment
As the proportion ofactive infections is similar among boys and girls, the greater number of activeinfections among adult women is attributed to their greater contact with infectedchildren. These disparities in vulnerability are compounded by men’s greateraccess to cataract surgery in many parts of the developing world. Hence, theglobal excess of female blindness is attributed to an (hypothesized) sex-linkedvulnerability to cataract, a gendered risk of trachoma, and a gendered distributionof eye care services. Thi
example of how something can be both gender and sex linked. calls for further research on things that may be assumed to be sex linked basde on raw data and why gender analysis is so important
or the possibility that the relevantdiagnostic criteria are, themselves, gender-biased, lea
criteria for evaluating disease may be developed differentially based on gendered perspectives
This extends to subtle but widespread assumptionsabout the inevitability of interpersonal violence,
example of how assuming things to be sex linked means not addressing them the way they should be addressed
Differential gendered obligations to children, the sick, and the community affectexposure to infections (e.g. trachoma, influenza), and the structure andresponsiveness of the health system itself biases care.
focused on gender perceptions: women more likely to care for the sick (exposure) and fewer referals for women when presenting the same symptoms (more on strictly how a physician sees women)
endered leisure activities and ways of coping with life stress, shapedby social messaging about what leisure activities a male or female shouldundertake, result in differential rates of cigarette smoking,
health outcomes due to liesure actvities
health outcomes, such as the greater risk ofdrowning among males worldwide, because of their roles as fishermen andboatmen, and, by contrast, the greater number of burnings among women, due totheir responsibility for cooking and fire-tending
health outcomes may be attributable to labor divisions
Several authors have highlighted possible gender biases, in currentdiagnostic instruments, that would lead to under-diagnosis of male depression(Rutz 1999, Bech 2001, Moeller Leimkuehler et al. 2007). The feministcommunity, in fact, has questioned, for some time, assumptions that womenare inherently vulnerable to mental illness (Chessler 1972). Ironically, thediagnosis and gendered causes of depression may receive more concertedattention, given the growing interest in male depressio
elaborates on the disproportionate diagnosis of women with mental disorders as being due to gender based discrimination. highlights the issue of conflation of the two.
Epidemiologic data maybe subject to systematic biases, including intrinsic sex and gender biases (Sundby1998, Hanson 2002). For example, select conditions are known to be under-reported, by one sex or another, due to gender-based fears of stigma anddiscrimination
another reason it is difficult to tell whether sex based differences in disease occur
s how sex and gender vulnerabilities may be overlaid on oneanother in ways that can exacerbate sex differences in outcome, or mitigate risks(e.g. the female excess in blindness)
some might be due exclusively to one factor but others could be a combination of both due to exacerbation of outcomes
An acknowl-edgement that certain aspects of gendered behavioural expectations are harmfulto health, or even potentially fatal, begs a discussion on whether re-visioninggender may be warranted for public health purposes.
why we should distinguish gender and sex in research and medical literature
Principal among these is that sex and gender are frequentlyconflated in the epidemiologic and medical literature.
difficult to understand "what gender does" to health since they are studied interchangably