We argue that these factors work their effects on nationalism through the process of persuasion and myth- making in the marketplace of ideas.
ARGUMENT
We argue that these factors work their effects on nationalism through the process of persuasion and myth- making in the marketplace of ideas.
ARGUMENT
first define nationalist mythmaking and explain the scope of our claims. Second, we present our concept of the market- place of ideas and offer hypotheses about conditions that facilitate nationalist mythmaking, illustrating these propositions with examples from that classic hotbed of nationalist mythmaking, the Weimar Republic, and from other recent and historical cases. Third, we test our argument against two hard cases, ethnic conflict in the former Yugoslavia and in Rwanda, both dramatic clashes that seem superficially to fit the conventional view that a government media mo- nopoly is the problem, and unfettered speech the antidote. Fourth, we explore cases with comparatively moderate outcomes to determine the conditions under which democratization does not produce intense nationalist mythmak- ing. We conclude with suggestions for better institutionalizing public debate in new democracies.
order of contents
evolutionary changes in agricultural productivity are an essential condition for successful take-off; for modernization of a society increases radically its bill for agricultural products. In a decade or two both the basic structure of the economy and the social and political structure of the society are transformed in such a way that a steady rate of growth can be, thereafter, regularly sustained
The disruptive innovations cause shifts and changes but the call for modernization can be adaptable and not always canceling out of previous forms.
Britain and the well-endowed parts of the world populated substantially from Britain (the United States, Canada etc.) the proximate stimulus for take-off was mainly (but not wholly) technological.
from industrial to agricultural, technological advancements are progressing due to some of the Major Powers: Britain, U.S., and Canada
uilding of an effective centralized national state--on the basis of coalitions touched with a new nationalism, in opposition to the traditional landed regional interests, the colonial power, or both, was a decisive aspect of the preconditions period; and it was, almost universally, a necessary condition for take-off.
Political tool; The equilibrium of the economy and balance of social values/morality the most affected aspect was politics.
New types of enterprising men come forward--in the private economy, in government, or both--willing to mobilize savings and to take risks in pursuit of profit or modernization.
Investors
economic progress is a necessary condition for some other purpose, judged to be good: be it national dignity, private profit, the general welfare, or a better life for the children.
The necessity of economic progress
These invasions-literal or figurative-shocked the traditional society and began or hastened its undoing; but they also set in motion ideas and sentiments which initiated the process by which a modern alternative to the traditional society was constructed out of the old culture
'The Transition' Literal War or the Fear of invasion
Western Europe of the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries as the insights of modern science began to be translated into new production functions in both agriculture and industry, in a setting given dynamism by the lateral expansion of world markets and the international competition for them
Pre Context / Purpose
process of transition; that is, the period when the preconditions for take-off are developed; for it takes time to transform a traditional society in the ways necessary for it to exploit the fruits of modern science, to fend off diminishing returns, and thus to enjoy the blessings and choices opened up by the march of compound interest
Second stage
subject of this book; that is, the post-traditional societies, in which each of the major characteristics of the traditional society was alteredin such ways as to permit regular growth: its politics, social structure, and (to a degree) its values, as well as its economy
Subject of the book ..?
'traditional society' we are grouping the whole pre-Newtonian world : the dynasties in China; the civilization of the Middle East and the Mediterranean; the world of medieval Europe. And to them we add the post-Newtonian societies which, for a time, remained untouched or unmoved by man's new capability for regularly manipulating his environment to his economic advantage
Adjacent to central fact: The purpose and evidence
he value system of these societies was generally geared to what might be called a long-run fatalism; that is, the assumption that the range of possibilities open to one's grandchildren would be just about what it had been for one's grandparent
Inequality and hierarchies exist within due to the tools of manipulation, slavery, and genocide.
in agriculture, the level of productivity was limited by the inaccessibility of modern science, its applications, and its frame of mind
i.e.: for the cap or also known as a 'disruptive innovation' for a societal manipulation in gain of an economic advantage.
central fact about the traditional society was that a ceiling existed on the level of attainable output per head
Central Fact
static
lacking in movement, uninteresting, undesirable
the traditional society, the preconditions for take-off, the take-off, the drive to maturity, and the age of high mass-consumption.
The Five Stages of [Economic] Growth
agreed on all sides, that the powers properly belonging to one of the departments ought not to be directly and completely administered by either of the other departments. It is equally evident, that none of them ought to possess, directly or indirectly, an overruling influence over the others, in the administration of their respective powers
Checks and Balances
political apothegm
Def.: A concise saying or maxim
Governor-General of the British dominion of Pakistan.
Jinnah got promoted yall
The partition of India would also mean the partition of these provinces;
Hindu and Sikh minorities of punjab had to be considered as well
Mountbatten quickly saw that Britain could only withdraw by transferring power not to one government, but to two.
another threat or factoring solution to deal w/ the threat
June 6th, the League accepted the plan. On June 22nd, so did the Congress but at the same time it refused to support the interim gov- ernment which was to put the plan into effect.
... being difficult
three tiers of government at independence,
FIRST: Formed out of existing provinces SECOND: Formed out of separate Hindu and Muslim federations (a Hindustan and Pakistan) THIRD: Central Government –– Representatives of the federations will convene to come to a resolution on DEFENSE, COMMS, AND FOREIGN AFFAIRS
provincial autonomy,
What does this mean?
Rahmat Ali, to give it a name ‘Pakistan’ derived thus: *p’ stood for the Punjab, ‘A’ for Afghanistan or the North-West Fron- tier Province, ‘K’ for Kashmir, ‘S’ for Sind and ‘tan’ for Baluchistan. It translated as the ‘land of the pure’.
Super freaking interesting + something i didn't know before about the creation of Pakistan / how the name was originated
Presi- dent of the Muslim League session at Allahabad, he proposed the creation of a Muslim state in the north-west of India.
Pakistan is NW of India
many soon lost interest when they found it to be dominated by a view of the future favouring Muslims of the Pun- jab.
hierarchy moved members back out by the end of 1920
By the First World War they were increasingly young profes- sional men from the same province — lawyers and newspaper editors. In the 1920s the platform was virtually deserted;
Founded in 1906 and mostly deserted by 1920 due to members seeking out other groups/parties to join.
Saiyid founded in 1877 in the form of the Mohammadan Anglo- 42 Islam’s Raj: workmen building the royal city of Fathpur Sikri for the Mughal Emperor Akhbar - completed in 1584, it wasa symbol of past Muslim power and prestige in India. Oriental College at Aligarh,
Saiyid Ahmad Khan, Founded Aligarh Anglo-Oriental College
divided it into Hindu, Muslim and British periods
Why did the British divide the history into 3 periods?
Roughly a quarter of the population, they were in no way a united group.
1st point of reason for India's muslims establishement
) why many Muslims were reluctant to join the Congress, the party of the Indian nationalist movement, and (2) why this fact led to a surgical division of the land.
2 issues of partition have to address:
classic nationalist interpretation,
what does this mean?
Approaches to partition depend very much on where the individual is situated.
perspective
past fifty years India and Pakistan have been in a state of con- stant hostility, fighting three wars in 1947-48, 1963 and 1971,
Kashmir Conflict
1947 into the sovereign states of India and Pakistan is one of the more important events of twentieth-century world his- tory.
Aug 15 1947- India gained sovereignty to become a state over India.
India emerged as a secular democracy when all around large areas of Asia were about to undergo the ordeals of revolu- tions, dictatorships and civil wars.
1976
These oppositional dualities create an incentive for black police officers to align themselves with the norms that the institution values and signal that they do not have the qualities that are in opposition to those values.
THE DIVERSITY OF POLICING -- To apply yourself where necessary so that there is a protection of your body but a targeting on others so that you aren't ousted as well...
eerie.
The effect of this tension is that race — the very thing that might lead one to surmise that black police officers can change the racial culture of policing — might limit their capacity to do so.
To infiltrate the system from within, the oldest trick in the book, is often the least able to be played out because of the circumstances of police culture in addition to the way they seek policeman for various roles / geographic location differs and matter as well.
Thus, it behooves black police officers to get along with their colleagues, to be good team players, and to fit into their work environ-ment. In short, black police officers have an incentive to “work their identities” to demonstrate that they belong.
Diversity of policing: They must show that they are good black men that can disciple, be strong, and be brave/courageous in order to demonstrate that they belong–hence, "Work their identities"
is Crews a victim because as a Black male he is vulnerable to sexual violence? Or is Mr. Crews a victim because he was victimized by a toxic male?
A QUESTION
And they're not here.... My wife, for years, prepared me. She said: "If you ever get goaded, if you ever get prodded, if you ever get anyone trying to push you into any situation, don't do it, don't be violent." (Kelly, [45], paras. 4–5)
How sweeeeet –– your white wife acknowledges your black masc. and TEACHES you to not be defensive. If you really, genuinely learned, then good. But in recent tweets, it has taught him to also only trust this one, one, white womAn.
You only have a few chances to make yourself a viable member of the community
Bloop, this is why Terry don't even love his daughters i guess.
many of the responses on Twitter blamed him for not defending himself from the assault and knocking the attacker out. Crews explained that Black men are not able to defend themselves from violence even when they are attacked by a weaker aggressor.
His "Blackness" and "Masculinity" were supposed to protect him or allow him to better defend itself –– toxic.
But this seems to enable them to focus on the other aspects of their lives instead of just focusing on how they're going to get their next supply of the drug
So, the harm reduction site provides a window of opportunity for the user to get their fix without worry so they can worry about the other aspects of their life.
inefi caciou
ineffcacious: not producing the desired effect.