7 Matching Annotations
  1. Aug 2023
    1. The measures which the museum curator takes to present the thing to the public areself-liquidating. The upshot of the curator’s efforts are not that everyone can see theexhibit but that no one can see it. The curator protests: why are they so indifferent?W hy do they even d eface the exhibit? D on’t they know it is theirs? But it is not theirs.It is his, the cura tor’s. By the most exclusive sort of zoning, the museum exhibit, thepark oak tree, is part of an ensemble, a package, which is almost impenetrable to them.The archaeolo gist who p uts his find in a museum so that everyone can see itaccomplishes the reverse of his expectations. The result of his action is that no one cansee it now but the archeologist. He would have done better to kee p it in his pocket andshow it now and then to strangers.

      This makes me think of how history is written and taught, "history is written by the victor" as the saying goes, so when we only are taught or learn that part of history we only get the package that is documented, and therefore don't actually learn the entirety of the history, we just learn one part and we can't fully grasp the situation. It's similar here, the museum is allowing everyone to see the artifacts and exhibits but they can't fully understand them because it's being presented in a carefully manicured way.

    2. I wish to propose thefollowing educational technique which should prove equally effective for Harvard andShreveport High School. I propose that English poetry and biology should be taught asusual, but that at irregular intervals, p oetry stud ents sho uld find dogfishes on theirdesks and biology students should find Shakesp eare sonnets on their dissection bo ards

      I like this idea, just coming into a classroom expecting one thing, then getting a completely different subject matter would at least somewhat remove the expectations and dismantle the "educational package", then when the discovery is driven by pure curiosity, the students will better absorb the information because they can fully immerse themselves in it without any outer expectations.

    3. The sonnet and the dogfish are obscured by two different proce sses. The sonnet isobscured by the symbolic package which is formulated not by the sonnet itself but bythe media through which the sonnet is transmitted, the media which the educatorsbelieve for some reason to be transp arent. The new textbook, the type, the smell of thepage, the classroom , the alum inum windows and the winter sky, the personality ofMiss Hawkins— these m edia w hich are supposed to transmit the sonnet may o nlysucceed in transmitting themselves

      By taking the subject matter out of it's element or natural setting, it takes away the innate discovery and curiosity behind investigating it. Once it's in a classroom, we are given the subject matter in a specific way, and concerned about discovering it "wrong", so we don't fully grasp the topic because we're concerned about how we're learning it.

    4. . By virtue of the fact that he hasother fish to fry, he may take a stroll along the rim after supper and then we can see thecanyon through him.

      By taking away the figurative pedestal that the canyon was put on and allowing it to simply exist in the background, that strips it of the frame I mentioned earlier and allows us to truly see the vastness of the canyon.

    5. In other words, hesees the canyon by avoiding all the facilities for seeing the canyon.

      I thought of this as the lookout points putting the canyon into this sort of frame and therefore removing it from what actually makes it special, it's something that naturally occurred so having the lookout points removes it from nature and mellows out the experience.

    6. Seeing the canyon is made even more difficult by what the sightseer does when themoment arrives, when sovereign knower confronts the thing to be known. Instead oflooking at it, he photographs it. There is no co nfrontation at all. A t the end of fortyyears of preformulation and with the G rand Canyon yawning a t his feet, what does hedo? He waives his right of seeing and knowing and records sym bols fo r the nex t fortyyears. For him there is no present; there is o nly the past of what has been formulatedand seen and the future of what has been formulated and not seen. T he present issurrendered to the past and the future

      I think with the part that technology and social media is playing in our lives we feel the need to document everything in order to prove that we did it. But the actual documentation of the experience is taking away from actually experiencing it, so you'll actually only ever have the experience from behind a screen because you're so focused on documenting it that you miss actually being in the present moment.

    7. Formo sa

      Means "beautiful isle" in Portuguese, it was given as a name to Taiwan in the early 1540's by passing Portuguese sailors and is still used as a name for the island today