sense of political responsibility calling Catholics to be informed and active citizens
calls for political responsibility
sense of political responsibility calling Catholics to be informed and active citizens
calls for political responsibility
balance w/ making sure not pushing own agenda on church
Another danger is potential partisanship, the temptation to try to use the parish for inappropriate political objectives.
am I doing this with this assignment?
Does the Catholic church provide half of social services in the U.S.?
No. Only 17-34%
Connecticut’s Office of Early Childhood announced changes in program eligibility rules starting Dec. 31, when the Care 4 Kids program will stop taking applications from people who have received benefits from Temporary Assistance for Needy Families within the last five years, and 18- to 19-year-old parents who attend high school or an equivalent program. The Care 4 Kids program is now unable to serve as many families as it has supported in the past due to new federal policy requirements that increased caseload numbers and longer periods of enrollment for each family, according to CRT.
why specificially TANF users in past 5 years? (bc they have recently been supported?)
and 18-19 yr old parents?
"increased caseload numbers"
But, let me be direct here: if we immediately dismiss the possibility of mental illness and automatically assume spiritual deficiency, our actions amount to spiritual abuse. I know those are powerful and pointed words, but I believe them to be true. Please, don’t miss them.
VERY IMPORTANT
Those who revel in the leisure luxuries – in the pursuit of a hobby, for instance, or time at gaming – do not need to spend much time on the job each week before the income gain from another hour at work starts to look a poor trade-off for an additional hour away from it.
dependent on leisure luxuries...would rather not work...income gain is not worth the extra time working
Not all luxuries are tangible. In the autumn of 2016, Hurst released a paper, co-authored with Mark Aguiar, Mark Bils and Kerwin Charles. They define a class of activities they call “leisure luxuries”. Economists typically (and reasonably) assume that people tend to buy more things as they earn more money. But as they grow richer, they buy proportionately more of some things and less of others. Spending on necessities, as a share of all consumption, declines as incomes rise. Economists label “luxuries” the things that account for an increased share of spending as income goes up. There is a similar logic to leisure luxuries. As the amount of time people spend at leisure (as opposed to work) rises, some activities (like bathing or sleep) account for a shrinking share of total leisure time. Others – the leisure luxuries – account for more.
confusing
I’ve come to thinkthat the primary value of [the intervention] was thatit improved the children’s readiness for school so thatwhen they entered school, they performed better; and,because they had more success, they got more commit-ted to school; and because they got more committed toschool, they had even greater success.
~ starting off on the right foot
So if you can prevent antisocialbehavior in the preschool years, then you could set in motion a reduction in crime that takes placethroughout life.
ex. preventing antisocial behavior vs. simply trying to reduce crime
These interventions provided positive learning experi-ences and supportive, growth-promoting environmentsat a time when the children’s brain circuits were beingbuilt.
neurological theory why programs helped
toxic stress
usually occurs in non-supportive environments, children don't have nurturing relationships to protect
tolerable stress
brain architecture.
in first few years, brain neural circuits become increasingly complex
Healthy children are raised by people and communi-ties, not by government and professional ser-vices—but public policies and evidence-based interventions can make a significant difference when caregivers and neighborhoods need assis-tance
KEYYYY!!!
supports for families and appropriate training for providers of early care and educa-tion
but what does this look like?
The goal is to catalyze informed investments and creative innovations that build on a shared scientific base to achieve significantly improved outcomes for children and society above and beyond the impacts of existing efforts.
policies component
aframework for reconceptualizing
what populations / groups do you think this would appeal to and why?
how would you use to appeal?
significant progress in lifelong health promotion and disease prevention could be achieved by reducing the burden of significant adversity on young children—and this progress could be accelerated through science-based enhancements in a wide range of policy domains, including child care and early education, child welfare, public assistance and employment programs for low-income parents, housing policies, and community development initiatives, to name just a few.
THESIS
whether Tulsa’s CAPHead Start program produced significant impacts in middle schoolfor outcomes associated with academic success and school prog-ress.
question
It is important to note that similar to Head Start, theseprograms exclusively served low-income children, many of themchildren of color. But this evidence comes from children whoattended these programs in the 1960s and 1970s and cannot beassumed to reflect the Head Start of today. They were also small-scale model programs with questionable applicability to the at-scale Head Start program both then and now. The data reportedhere follow a 2005–2006 cohort of Tulsa CAP Head Start partic-ipants into 8th grade, thus providing a more contemporary portraitof Head Start’s longer-term impacts on children’s schooling out-comes.
generalizability of data is limited
Precocial” species such a s ch icke n s rely on h ig h ly sp e c i fi c i n n at e c apac i-ties adapted to one particular environmental niche, and so they mature quickly. “Altricial” species (those whose offspring need care and feeding by parents) rely on learning instead.
"precocial" species--rely on highly specific innate adapted to one env (chickens)
"altricial" -- need care/rely on learning (humans)
. We h ave a much lon-ger childhood than any other species. Why make babies so helpless for so long and thus require adults to put so much work and care into keep-ing their babies alive?
grande question
Children from the first group played with the toy much less than those from the second group. They already knew how it worked and were less interested in explor-ing it. The second group faced a mystery, and t h e y s p o nt a n e ou s ly pl aye d w it h t h e toy, s o o n u n-covering which lever did what
play with toy more if faced mystery, discovering what lever did
For example, “bi” might follow “ro” only one third of the time, whereas “da” might always follow “bi.” Then they played the babies new strings of sounds that either followed these patterns or broke them. Babies listened longer to the statistically unusual strings.
at 8 mo
Babies can even understand the relation be-tween a statistical sample and a population.
at 8 mo
So even at this very young age, children are not completely egocentric—they can take the per-spective of another person, at least in a simple way.
at 18 months
studies suggest that children learn about the world in much the same way that sci-entists do—by conducting experiments, analyz-ing statistics, and forming intuitive theories of the physical, biological and psychological realms.
children learn about the world ~ scientists
If reliable biomarkers for language learning can be identified, they should help determine whether children are developing normally or at risk for early-‐life, language-‐related disabilities, including autism spectrum disorder, dyslexia, fragile X syndrome and other disorder
so coool!!!
the degree to which a particular pattern of brain waves was present in response to known words predicted the child's future language and cognitive abilities, at ages four and
particular pattern of brain wave (showed ability to learn from others??) predicted child's future language and cog ability
I call "so
social gating: human interaction necessary for language learning!
EX. looking back and forth at object as well as the speaker, when hearing words
Exactly how social context contributes to the learning of a language in humans is still an open question. I have suggested, though,that parents and other adults provide both motivation and necessary information to help babies learn. The motivational component is driven by the brain's reward systems -‐-‐and, in particular, brain areas that use the neurotransmitter dopamine during social interaction. Work in my lab has already shown that babies learn better in the presence of other babies -‐-‐we are currently engaged in studies that explain why
how social context contributes??? = GRANDE QUESTION -- still unanswered
phonemes. Only the group exposed to Chinese from live speakers learned to pick up the foreign phonemes. Their performance, in fact, was equivalent to infants in Taipei who had been listening to their parents for their first 11
results
veat to this story: the statistical-‐learning process does not require passive listening
thesis-- also requires SOCIAL
lm, we monitored their perception of vowel sounds at six months and demonstrated that each group had already begun to focus in on the vowels spoken in their native language.
focusing of sounds occurs as soon as 6 months
one that recognizes sound through mental computation and another that requires intense social immersio
two distinct learning mechanisms
whether a child's language abilities are developing normally or whether an infant may be at risk for autism, attention deficit or other
use brain recordings to determine whether language is developing normally or @ risk autism, ADD etc
At birth, the infant brain can perceive the full set of 800 or so sounds, called phonemes, that can be strung together to form all the words in everylanguage of the world. During the second half of the first year, our research shows, a mysterious door opens in the child's brain. He or she enters a "sensitive period," as neuroscientists call it, during which the infant brain is ready to receive the first basic lessons in the magic of lang
development:
birth -- phonemes, ~800 sounds yr 1 -- sensitive period door opens
They tended to believe that individuals are the captains of their own destiny and should be able to overcome their problems by force of personal will
American view of self: captains of own destiny...when applied to mental illnesses, assume that the person has agency / control over their mental illness.
Thus, they would stigmatize? or not? WAIT, but this seems to contradict finding that if one references biological factors = more stigmatized?
Well, bio factors = can't change them...thus, you assume more stigmatized...
ower relapse rates
lower relapse rate: takes a shorter amount of time to relapse into mental illness <- WRONG
lower relapse rates: lower rates of relapsing (i.e falling back into illness after recovery)
higher relapse rates for people who have a diagnosis of schizophrenia.
so interesting!
high expressed emotion (criticism, hostility, emotional overinvolvement) correlate with higher relapse rates
With schizophrenia, however, symptoms are inevitably entangled in a person’s complex interactions with those around him or her.
with other mental illnesses too?
affected by how others act around person
esides keeping the sick individual in the social group, the religious beliefs in Zanzibar also allowed for a type of calmness and acquiescence in the face of the illness that she had rarely witnessed in the West.
resulting in attributing mental illness to an outside force
The problem, it appears, is that the biomedical narrative about an illness like schizophrenia carries with it the subtle assumption that a brain made ill through biomedical or genetic abnormalities is more thoroughly broken and permanently abnormal than one made ill though life events
possible explanation
Those who believed that their partner suffered a biochemical “disease like any other” increased the severity of the shocks at a faster rate than those who believed they were paired with someone who had a mental disorder caused by an event in the past.
results of experiment
But does the “brain disease” belief actually reduce stigma?
Does emphasis that patients have little choice or responsibility when it comes to mental diseases actually reduce stigma?
There is now good evidence to suggest that in the process of teaching the rest of the world to think like us, we’ve been exporting our Western “symptom repertoire” as well. That is, we’ve been changing not only the treatments but also the expression of mental illness in other cultures.
argument
It means that a mental illness is an illness of the mind and cannot be understood without understanding the ideas, habits and predispositions — the idiosyncratic cultural trappings — of the mind that is its host
thesis!
what cross-cultural psychiatrists and anthropologists have to tell us is that all mental illnesses, including depression, P.T.S.D. and even schizophrenia, can be every bit as influenced by cultural beliefs and expectations today as hysterical-leg paralysis or the vapors or zar or any other mental illness ever experienced in the history of human madness.
but actually
Western mental-health practitioners often prefer to believe that the 844 pages of the DSM-IV prior to the inclusion of culture-bound syndromes describe real disorders of the mind, illnesses with symptomatology and outcomes relatively unaffected by shifting cultural beliefs.
practitioners believe...
Many modern mental-health practitioners and researchers believe that the scientific standing of our drugs, our illness categories and our theories of the mind have put the field beyond the influence of endlessly shifting cultural trends and beliefs.
Many modern practitioners believe...
Would anorexia have so quickly become part of Hong Kong’s symptom repertoire without the importation of the Western template for the disease? It seems unlikely.
grande question
What is being missed, Lee and others have suggested, is a deep understanding of how the expectations and beliefs of the sufferer shape their suffering.
Dr. Lee argument
Because the troubled mind has been influenced by healers of diverse religious and scientific persuasions, the forms of madness from one place and time often look remarkably different from the forms of madness in another.That is until recently.
purpose behind article
attitudes toward balancing their job and their family life are highly correlated with their experiences as parents.
hard to balance work and family less likely to say being a parent is rewarding all the time
Men have, of course, become much more involved parents over the past couple of decades,
Men have also come more involved parent, broad support for changes to balance work and family
relationship between family-friendly policies and economic performance.
What is the relationship between family-friendly policies and economic performance?
Her willingness to speak out now is a strong step in the right direction.
Speak out about family obligations! Make it more of a norm
71.
past arc of a career
Many people in positions of power seem to place a low value on child care in comparison with other outside activities.
low value on child care in comparison to other activities
Long hours are one thing, and realistically, they are often unavoidable. But do they really need to be spent at the office?
more time in office = more benefits?
what about technology?
If more women could strike this balance, more women would reach leadership positions. And if more women were in leadership positions, they could make it easier for more women to stay in the workforce.
ARGUMENT: If more women can strike balance between work and home, more women would reach leadership positions. And if more women were in leadership positions, they could make it easier for more women to stay in the workforce.
how long they can “stay out” before they lose the competitive edge they worked so hard to acquire.
women worried about having kids too late, not establishing a career, losing competitive edge once they have kids etc.
Ultimately, it is society that must change, coming to value choices to put family ahead of work just as much as those to put work ahead of family.
supportive mate is necessary but society must also change the woman's mindset
a price worth paying.
fathers' commitment to public vs. family is praised // reverse for mothers
Such a standard sets up most women for a sense of failure.
can't compare to 'top women'?
Only when women wield power in sufficient numbers will we create a society that genuinely works for all women. That will be a society that works for everyone.
Think about this more
“new gender gap”—measured by well-being rather than wages
What is the new gender gap?
Many of these women are worrying not about having it all, but rather about holding on to what they do have.
what do they do??
although we are still blazing trails and breaking ceilings, many of us are also reinforcing a falsehood: that “having it all” is, more than anything, a function of personal determination.
But it cannot change unless top women speak out.
top women.
what role do 'bottom' or 'middle' women play?
How could anyone voluntarily leave the circles of power for the responsibilities of parenthood?
On one hand, money/power is desirable (capitalism?) but on the other hand, so is commitment to family...
is suspect
why?
don’t talk about: the necessity of a primary caregiver spouse.”
don't talk about it because they are ashamed? Forgoing the duties of childcare?
Lead parenting is being on the front lines of everyday life.
Did they agree on this role? Or happened naturally? What kinds of conversations --> this, and why aren't more happening?
First, being a lead dad can be good for your marriage.
benefits of lead father:
The result is that, except around organized sports, most fathers have difficulty finding buddies from whom to seek support
support system not in place for lead fathers
Put hot triggers in the path of motivated people.
can do this with learning?
or behavior/reinforcement?
multiple childhoods counters NGO "saving"
framing = incapable of seeing value in childrens' lives, only see the corruption of earning income
childrens' ambivalence of NGO's exclusion og other worlds.
income, for survival etc vs. education for thriving (At odds)
children would stay and be a part of NGO's reform efforts as long as they could keep gaining income outside
street conditions often better than those at home
"innocence works less as the property of childhood than of adult desire and empties children of their political agency, making them available to perfectly fulfill the symbolic demands made on them by adults"
"Not being able to tell the diff between them and children form 'regular families' was the stable fantasy of improvement that staff worked with"
skit children act out: serve as place of passivity, need of saving, fitting the mold of "street child"
-highlight reason for leaving rather than close ties
NGO competes against government's services
influx in NGOs, all competing for same money, RISE in estimates in # of children? --> empathy talk with Paul Bloom
children on street became not visible -> only a category of a problem
child's right to file complaint...doesn't bc police is his friend.
--> points to complicated nature of "child rights"
anti-politics & childrens rights?
Social policy needs active involvement of people, thorough understanding of children's lives and livelihood should inform policy making
--flexibility and adaptability of law
pg. 68: call for womens and childrens need to be center for policy
Author: "Difficult to divorce economic policy from social policy?" -"What is the difference between this and a call for adjustment with a human face?" think shes going for adjustment --two differences:
1) Convention supposed to be used as yard stick, immediate application not what was in mind. 2) "enabling" feature of an approach inclusive of rights
human face doesnt have to do with rights.
pg. 66: Child is silenced when speaking of childhood -> capitalist mindset ("exploitation")
pg. 60: Interviews:
-Big: have money, work but gain a lot of money, more responsibilities (that affect others) -Small: play, school, work but give money, absence of authority in decision making, can't be married -Middle: Being by self but still reliant on prents,
pg. 58: Population: -all (-1 or 2) exposed to factory work environment -2/3 were under 14 -majority girls
pg. 56: Problem with "Ideal Childhood"
Blanchet: "In the eyes of the samaj (moral society), children who are exposed to the adult world 'before their time' are 'spoiled'--no longer considered children"
Author argues that Blanchet is writing for Western readers
pg. 50: Author is examining children alongside "social constructs" --> lost and abandoned childhoods?
but doesn't want to use her research as "this is how their experiences are less than the social norm" ???
shewasmerelybringingtoanendmyintrusiononaconversationEricawashavingwithChris
hmmm.
Althoughsome had argued that self-financing colleges were elitist and would exclude thepoor, he disagreed and stated that those who could afford to pay should have theopportunity to do so and this would lead to healthy competition and higher quality.
two views on private edu
The “civic” is increasingly tied to discourses of con-sumption and a free market
argument
it would create the kind of public that theywanted to be a part of, a civic public full of opportunity and growth
women too?
it has been destroyed
figurative
the student–citizen does not destroy but builds
contrast between these students + those from protest?
The masculinity of wandering about freely in an undisciplined way is the conditionof possibility for producing a masculinity in which movement is disciplined
????
parallel institution
subsitute
It’s only when there is a strike that it’s worth it to come tocollege. That’s when you must come to college
???
women are expected to go home
women cannot be in "public" without a purpose?
emptiness of the classrooms
???
19
main idea!
with young militantsons dragging their elders into a new Kerala
What does this mean?