Review coordinated by Life Science Editors Foundation Reviewed by: Dr. Angela Andersen, Life Science Editors Foundation Potential Conflicts of Interest: None
PUNCHLINE This preprint uncovers how embryonic oxygen levels act as a regulatory switch controlling limb development timing in mammals. Using mouse and chick embryos, the authors demonstrate that hindlimb initiation in mammals is delayed due to hypoxia-induced expression of NFKB transcription factors (cRel, Rela) and Hif1a, which repress the limb-initiating gene Tbx4. In contrast, chick embryos in normoxia activate fore- and hindlimbs simultaneously. This oxygen-dependent repression is lifted as placental oxygenation increases, triggering hindlimb EMT and Tbx4 expression. Notably, limb heterochrony is not due to cis-regulatory evolution, but instead arises from differential trans-acting factor expression. The findings reframe heterochrony as an environmentally cued developmental program in placental mammals.
BACKGROUND Heterochrony—alteration in developmental timing—has long been recognized in limb evolution. While birds initiate fore- and hindlimb development simultaneously, mammals typically exhibit delayed hindlimb formation. This developmental delay has been hypothesized to reflect an "energy trade-off" during early embryogenesis. Yet, the molecular mechanisms linking the environment to timing remain unexplored. Zhu et al. provide the first mechanistic insight by identifying oxygen levels and NFKB signaling as modulators of limb timing in mammals.
KEY QUESTION ADDRESSED What molecular and environmental factors underlie the delay in hindlimb development in mammalian embryos compared to avian species?
SUMMARY Using mouse and chick embryos, the authors first demonstrate that mammalian hindlimb development is delayed starting from the earliest stage of limb bud formation—specifically, the epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT). This delay correlates with delayed expression of the hindlimb-specifying transcription factor Tbx4, but not its upstream activators (Pitx1, Isl1) or its forelimb counterpart (Tbx5). Surprisingly, enhancer-swap experiments rule out differences in Tbx4 cis-regulatory elements as the cause. Instead, bulk RNA-seq and functional screens reveal cRel, a member of the NFKB family, as a repressor of Tbx4 in early mouse hindlimb buds. Further experiments show that cRel and Rela are upregulated by hypoxia, and their expression is suppressed as the embryo transitions to normoxia via placental oxygenation. Culturing mouse embryos in normoxic conditions prematurely induces Tbx4 expression and EMT in the hindlimb. Knockout and overexpression experiments with cRel, Rela, and Hif1a confirm a hypoxia–NFKB–Hif1a–Tbx4 regulatory axis. This mechanism links maternal oxygen levels to developmental timing and may be an adaptive feature of viviparous mammals.
KEY RESULTS Hindlimb EMT and Tbx4 expression are delayed in mice but not chicks * → In mouse embryos, hindlimb EMT is delayed by ~18 hours relative to the forelimb (Figure 1A–B) * → In chick embryos, forelimb and hindlimb EMT occur nearly simultaneously * → Expression of Tbx4 (hindlimb) and Tbx5 (forelimb) correlates with EMT timing in both mouse and chick embryos (Figure 1C–I)
Early limb patterning signals are not delayed (mouse and chick) * → BMP, Wnt, and RA signaling are active in both forelimb and hindlimb fields in mouse and chick embryos at the same developmental stage (Figure 2A–B) * → Expression of upstream transcription factors Pitx1, Isl1, and Hoxb9 occurs on time in both limb fields in mouse and chick embryos (Figure 2C–F)
Tbx4 enhancer function is conserved across species * → The mouse HLEA/HLEB and chick Tbx4-Rec1 enhancers drive equivalent spatial and temporal expression when introduced into either mouse or chick embryos (Figure 3C–E, H) * → CRISPR/dCas9-KRAB repression of Tbx4-Rec1 in chick embryos reduces Tbx4 expression (Figure 3F–I) * cRel and Rela repress Tbx4 in mouse hindlimbs * → Bulk RNA-seq of early hindlimb buds from mouse embryos reveals cRel as a candidate repressor of Tbx4 (Figure 4A–C) * → Electroporation of cRel and Rela into chick hindlimb buds reduces Tbx4 expression and limb bud size (Figure 4D) * → In cRel knockout mouse embryos, Tbx4 expression is elevated and EMT occurs earlier than in controls (Figure 4E–H)
Oxygen regulates hindlimb timing in mouse embryos * → In mouse embryos, early hypoxia is evidenced by nuclear Hif1a accumulation in hindlimb mesenchyme (Figure 5A–C) * → Culturing mouse embryos under normoxic conditions leads to precocious Tbx4 and Pitx1 expression in hindlimbs (Figure 5E–G) * → EMT is also accelerated under normoxia in mouse hindlimbs (Figure 5H–I) * → qPCR on lateral plate mesoderm (LPM)-derived cells from mouse embryos shows cRel is upregulated in hypoxic vs. normoxic conditions (Figure 5J)
cRel and Hif1a functionally interact in mouse embryos * → In Hif1a knockout mouse embryos, Tbx4 expression is elevated and hindlimb EMT is precocious—mimicking the cRel knockout phenotype (Figure S9I–J) * → Manipulating cRel expression alters Hif1a levels in mouse embryonic cells (Figure S10) * → scRNA-seq from mouse LPM derivatives confirms upregulation of Tbx4, Pitx1, and Hox9 under normoxia (Figure S6E)
STRENGTHS * Identifies a molecular mechanism linking environmental oxygen levels to developmental timing * Demonstrates that heterochrony arises from trans-acting regulatory inputs, not enhancer evolution * Uses a broad and rigorous toolkit: enhancer reporters, genetic knockouts, hypoxia assays, ex utero culture, single-cell and bulk RNA-seq * Highlights the adaptability of developmental programs to viviparous life history * Conceptually reframes heterochrony as plastic and environmentally modulated
FUTURE WORK & EXPERIMENTAL DIRECTIONS * Characterize direct chromatin binding of cRel and Hif1a at Tbx4 enhancers * Examine other NFKB targets in the LPM that might contribute to limb timing * Explore whether similar timing mechanisms are conserved in other mammalian species, including humans * Investigate how oxygen levels interface with metabolic and mitochondrial signaling during early development * Test whether early normoxia affects other embryonic heterochronies beyond limb formation * Directly test whether hypoxia modulates limb timing in birds. Although oxygen manipulation in chick embryos is technically challenging, comparative data would clarify whether the hypoxia–NFKB–Tbx4 axis is a placental adaptation or part of a broader vertebrate timing program.
AUTHORSHIP NOTE This review was drafted with the assistance of ChatGPT (OpenAI) to organize and articulate key insights. Dr. Angela Andersen checked the final document.
FINAL TAKEAWAY This preprint provides a paradigm shift in our understanding of limb heterochrony by uncovering a mechanism through which maternal oxygen availability regulates the timing of hindlimb development. By linking environmental hypoxia to NFKB- and Hif1a-mediated repression of Tbx4, the authors show how the embryo delays hindlimb formation until placental oxygenation is sufficient. This elegant mechanism offers an evolutionary and physiological explanation for mouse hindlimb delay, and it opens new avenues in developmental timing, maternal-fetal signaling, and the evolution of viviparity.