9 Matching Annotations
  1. Feb 2021
    1. When two-thirds of Republicans believe that Antifa was involved in the assault on the Capitol, selling the base a bogus narrative about the Texas electricity disaster is practically child’s play.

      Krugman once again repeats the comparison to the capitol attacks, critiquing how easy it is to be swayed by what politicians tell you. It's hard to admit that you are wrong, and it is easy to believe something when it has been repeated over and over. Krugman is almost admiring the ability of Republican politicians to sell a narrative, comparing it to child's play.

    2. it’s a way to please fossil fuel interests, which give the vast bulk of their political contributions to Republicans; and since progressives tend to favor renewable energy, it’s a way to own the libs. And it all dovetails with climate change denial.

      Krugman reveals his thoughts on why the Republicans would push such lies. He claims that it is economically and politically motivated, while also pushing a tenet of conservative policy that many believe in - that climate change is not real. Politicians at the end of the day are selfish people and they will look out for themselves and their party at the cost of the truth.

    3. It’s also true that extreme cold forced some of the state’s insufficiently winterized wind turbines to shut down, but as I said, this was happening to Texas energy sources across the board, with the worst problems involving natural gas.

      Krugman concedes that renewable energy failed as well, but he continues to emphasize that it was not the main problem. By at least acknowledging that renewables can fail, he builds credibility while not getting too far from his argument attacking the conservative politicians.

    4. officials from Gov. Greg Abbott on down, backed by virtually the entire right-wing media complex, have chosen to lay the blame on green energy, especially wind power.

      He describes how it is not only the Texan politicians that are feeding the public lies, but it is an entire half of media in the country. Krugman continues to play on the idea that this disaster was turned into an attack on political enemies. Common people turn to the media for their news, but when the media spreads obvious lies, it turns into a dangerous weapon.

    5. A power grid poorly prepared to deal with extreme cold suffered multiple points of failure. The biggest problems appear to have come in the delivery of natural gas, which normally supplies most of the state’s winter electricity, as wellheads and pipelines froze. Nor was this merely a matter of the lights going out; people are freezing too, because many Texas homes have electric heat. Many of the homes without electrical heat rely on, yes, natural gas. We’re looking at enormous suffering and, probably, a significant death toll.

      Diction such as poorly, extreme, and enormous convey the severity of the situation while continuing to put blame on Texas lawmakers. Krugman also explains the main root problem behind the disaster in Texas, the frozen natural gas pipelines that meant electricity plant could not generate power anymore.

    6. Texas authorities also ignored warnings about the risks associated with extreme cold. After a 2011 cold snap left millions of Texans in the dark, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission urged the state to winterize its power plants with insulation, heat pipes and other measures.

      Krugman builds on the fact that this disaster was brought on by negligence, not radical environmentalists. He builds credibility by referencing a previous event that should have caused overhaul in the power system, but was ignored in favor of keeping costs low and in the name of deregulation.

    7. It’s the energy-policy equivalent of claiming that the Jan. 6 insurrection was a false-flag Antifa operation — raw denial of reality, not just to escape accountability, but to demonize one’s opponents.

      Krugman makes an apt comparison to advance his point, as he references a well known incident to highlight the level of malfeasance that is committed by the current Texas politicians. These events have repeated themselves, and bring the deja vu of politicians turning even tragedy and disaster into an outlet to attack their fellow American "enemies"

    8. the claim that wind and solar power caused the collapse of the Texas power grid, and that radical environmentalists are somehow responsible for the fact that millions of people are freezing in the dark, even though conservative Republicans have run the state for a generation.

      This is the main idea of his opinion, as he sees Republicans shifting blame on to renewable resources as an insane attack on the liberals. He also notes that liberals have not run the state for a while, meaning that conservatives got themselves into the mess. Pointing this out highlights the absurdity fo the politicians' argument, appealing to the reader's sense of logic.

    9. Politicians are neither gods nor saints

      Krugman knows that politicians are usually not the greatest of people and makes that clear. He uses hyperbole as no one is a god or a saint, but it clearly gets the point across that he knows no one is perfect. He has a certain level of lenience, but some people do more than just evade blame.