9 Matching Annotations
  1. Last 7 days
    1. Many, if not most, HPE studies are primarily focused not on testing general causal theories, but on tracing historical roots or origins of things. Implicit in such studies is a view that an explanation of a phenomenon amounts to a reconstruction of its concrete historical pathway

      This is essentially what macro-causal analysis does in comparative historical analysis. This is the focus of Pierson, Mahoney, Skocpol, Thelen et al. History becomes the tool for a) elongating the causal chain (e.g. not just focusing on short/short explanations), b) focusing on temporal causal dynamics.

    1. A, and if (ii) cases A and B have similar factors XA and XB with causal capacities under m, then (iii) m can be inferred to operate in case B. Thus, one can make credible causal statements in case B without a direct empirical study of that case, on the basis of credible identification in case A

      Seems odd. How do you know that case B is identical to case A. This involves empirics.

  2. Jul 2018
    1. Five Dimensions of Immigration PolicyWhen it comes to managing and shaping migration flows, as opposed to simply controlling their entry, it is possible to identify five principal constituent elements of this field: labor migration, the increased importance of political asylum, the growth of immigration of dependents, ethnic immigration, and issues related to the integration of immigrants into the host country

      Identifies the five dimensions of immigration. This allows you to break down the topic into more specific subtopics.

  3. Jan 2018
    1. By contrast, annotations can link an argument advanced in the main text of a publication to an excerpt from the source(s) the author is positing supports the arguments

      How is this difference from data access?

  4. Feb 2017
    1. hift of tone came about almost overnight, from doubt about whether ordinary Americans had really suffered from economic and political globalization in the last generation to regret that their certain suffering had caused them to cast such a desperate vote

      Well put. But this shift was not limited to the media. It applies equally to Republicans and Democrats. It happened across the board. And certainly the catalysts were Trump and Sanders.

  5. Jan 2017
    1. central importance.

      So identification seems to be the term used for using randomized experiments to solve causal inference problems. It thus denotes a testing approach to causal inferences problems as opposed to the theorizing, causal process tracing approach.

  6. Nov 2015
    1. Universities should also officially and strongly discourage trigger warnings. They should endorse the American Association of University Professors’ report on these warnings, which notes, “The presumption that students need to be protected rather than challenged in a classroom is at once infantilizing and anti-intellectual.” P

      One curious and unstated dimension in all of this is how sway students actually have in all of this. AAUP, many faculty members seem to have little patience for the more extreme forms of this PC none-sense. So where does the pressure for all this come from ?