26 Matching Annotations
  1. Jan 2023
    1. Finding ways to reexamine the federal government’s role in many cases can also be effective. Take the recent string of disastrous summer forest fires. For a state like Montana that has been plagued by forest fires, the state Department of Natural Resources has been barred from helping fight the fires in the past because they’ve occurred on federal land. Montana knows about their forests better than anyone else and should have a larger stake in the forests, especially during times of disaster.

      backs up belief of limited federal government and more states rights, anecdote

    2. liberals are willing to work with the “opposing side.”

      maybe it should be addressed that both sides have this issue and why they wont work with the opposing side

    3. Ninety-five percent of Americans support national parks and 74 percent believe the environment should be protected at nearly all costs. Yet they assume the environment is a partisan issue.

      interesting point

    4. nearly all Americans agree that we need clean air, clean water, and a thriving environment.

      source? would be nice instead of just generalizations, even if they are true

    5. In fact, nearly all Americans agree that state and federal governments have a duty to protect our nation’s environment, wildlife, and human health in one way or another.

      generalization with emotional appeal

    6. . Instead of an intrusive punishment for landowners, they should be given the incentives to do the right thing.

      how does the gov manage it and what incentives should be considered? so many generalizations but not many specifics, maybe to appeal to a larger range of audiences to get them thinking and not scare them away

    7. Most notably, it acknowledges the importance of free enterprise and innovation in environmental discussions. Without innovation on energy sources, emissions reduction, transportation, pollution clean-up, and other important environmental issues, we’ll never solve local, national, or global environmental issues.

      how conservative ideas align with environmental activism

    8. Additionally, 42 of the 50 College Republican state chairs signed a letter this spring calling for increased prioritization on clean energy from Republican leaders.

      super cool

    9. With a strong history and inherent care for our environment, young conservatives want to push for policies within their value-set — instead of staying silent.

      mostly an emotional appeal here but the emotional appeal is backed by evidence of a history of feeling this way

    10. Our values, which hinge on limited-government, economic success, and personal responsibility, are no longer represented within environmental discussions. We have been told those values are incompatible with a flourishing environment. Moreover, many older conservative leaders have gone silent on the issue. As a result, many young conservatives have abandoned the environment since they don’t feel they have a home.

      why are these views seen as incompatible and what about them do you think is compatible with the movement - how do they align?

    11. The majority of conservative voters live in rural, natural areas. They may feel alienated by the topic of climate change, but conservatives know the necessity of taking care of the land.

      ethos

    12. Young conservatives are thankful for the God-given land that we were put on Earth to protect.

      pathos, need to come back to this bit several times with a level head. huge eye roll.

    13. a recent University of Michigan study showed conservatives (and climate skeptics) were more eco-friendly in their day-to-day lives than liberals (and most climate activists).

      logos, interesting - would like to read further into this on my own time

    14. Thanks to residing in natural areas of beauty and being a product of an education system that prioritizes environmental sustainability, we have an unmatched love for the environment.

      emotional appeal/pathos

    15. you’ll see that most conservative-voting districts reside amidst nature

      as i noted previously - interesting to address, like how rural communities are most impacted and conscious of the environment but tend to be the most conservative

    16. Without an appealing solution, they have tended to turn away from the problem

      no possible room or solution so they look to work towards other things they feel they can have a say in

    17. early 2000s, when most environmental discussions started to shift focus to solely climate change.

      why weren't conservatives involved in the discussion of climate change? what made leftists push them aside?

    18. the plains of Kansas, beaches of South Carolina, mountains of Montana, or deserts of Arizona, chances are you’ve learned to adore the outdoors.

      places where many conservatives live - out in nature, interacting with nature, etc.