52 Matching Annotations
  1. Apr 2017
  2. Feb 2017
    1. Your essay conflates grades and measurement with a culture which focuses on grades and measurement

    1. There is a growing technology, as the late Gerald Bracey once remarked, “that permits us to do in nanoseconds things that we shouldn’t be doing at all” (quoted in Mathews, 2006).  In fact, posting grades on-line is a significant step backward because it enhances the salience of those grades and therefore their destructive effects on learning.

      This goes back to responsible use of technology in a way. Just because we are able to post grades late at night doesn't mean that we should and that it is beneficial to students. Particularly when these grades are just numbers without any constructive feedback.

  3. Jan 2017
    1. We have a very similar teaching style which I enjoy because for the most part I work with people in engineering who have a very different style.

      Engineers, ugh...

    1. seek out more information (thank you google!) mid-conversation

      thank goodness for our handy, dandy, knowledge boxes!

    2. “Being taught” (phrased in the passive voice) may remove that even farther as the activity falls on the teacher and the student is just the recipient.

    3. “the acquisition of knowledge or skills through experience, study, or by being taught.”

      with no mention of method of acquisition.

    4. it may be a small distraction, but it can actually keep me more present in the conversation.

      One could argue you looking up the words is actually a form of engagement.

    5. ubiquitous, diatribe, what years millennials were born in, and the Tacoma Narrows Bridge obviously.

      Did you have to Google opine?

    6. I Google big words

      Me too.. I Google small words sometimes too.

    1. benefits of mindfulness

      But which mindfulness? Hippie aunt mindfulness or Ellen Langer mindfulness?

    2. It’s not shoving information down their throats, teaching directly from the book, or death by powerpoint.

      I agree it's definitely NOT that.

    3. I think it’s our responsibility as educators to meet our students half way.

      You're right and I think all of you're previous statements put a lot on the students. I'm interested to read what you propose...

    4. We obviously can’t follow them home and make sure they’re meditating for ten minutes or laying in bed without any distractions.

      No? No, yeah, you're right. No.

    5. I personally believe mindfulness is an important part of self-care. It’s the ability to acknowledge and reflect on experiences, emotions, and thoughts without allowing them to overwhelm or control you. It’s giving positive energy to your thoughts, nurturing them, and allowing them to grow peacefully.

      Mindfulness in a different context perhaps?

    6. “the hippy aunt”

      I think everyone should have a hippy aunt.

    7. I don’t think my generation (1) knows that mindfulness exists, (2) knows what it is, (3) knows how to practice it, and (4) knows why they should practice it. It’s something that I believe a majority of my friends, peers, and colleagues could benefit from and yet none have any inclination to actively practice it.

      Like in general or in specific contexts?

    1. ‘in your own words, help your little brother to understand what osmosis is by designing an experimental illustration that tells him a story that pertains to his life history, which will make his friends laugh, but make his aunt and uncle proud of him, while getting him on the teacher’s favorite pet list’

      As a victim of the American education system for something like 25 years, I would be horrified too, tbh.

    2. smartness

      "smartness"

    3. As such, students blessed with retentive memories were deemed very smart while students that might not have this ability but are creative enough to truly understand the term and define it in their own way, are at a disadvantage.

      I would be so far at the back of the class that I wouldn't even be in the room anymore. That sounds ROUGH!

    1. The question, parameters, or context can influence my answer or plan of action by putting a box around the possibilities I feel are available to me.

    1. I think it is so important to bring humor to important topics such as education, for many reasons.

      I think we're going to get along just fine, Sarah Donnelly.

    2. “Every child is an artist. The problem is how to remain an artist once he grows up.” ― Pablo Picasso

    1. I firmly believe my educational experience would have been drastically improved had I 1) been diagnosed with ADHD earlier

      I'm with you on this one.

    2. He made a very valid point about education: it is not a mechanical system, it’s a human system.

      THIS! We treat education as a mechanical system instead of a human system, we discount human variation and treat them as if they are all the same. This is not a way for people to excel.

    3. Personally, it seems that being a mindful learner means being actively aware of knowledge as it becomes available while critically evaluating its potential to be applied in a variety of present and future contexts.

      Go on....

    1. I think that if we, as educators, can be more cognizant of the pitfalls within the educational system, then we will better recognize when students journey down the path into “Death Valley” and we can be ready to engage them in mindful learning to show them the path out.

      Unfortunately sometimes it's not the educators, but the board of educators or the governing body. Which stinks.

    2. 1) been diagnosed with ADHD earlier

      I'm with you on this one.

    3. He made a very valid point about education: it is not a mechanical system, it’s a human system.

      THIS! We treat education as a mechanical system instead of a human system, we discount human variation and treat them as if they are all the same. This is not a way for people to excel.

    4. Personally, it seems that being a mindful learner means being actively aware of knowledge as it becomes available while critically evaluating its potential to be applied in a variety of present and future contexts.

      Go on....

    1. They need to know that what they are doing is resulting in more than a number or letter that signifies their success or lack thereof.

      I'm in this boat too. If my classes (or even lessons) don't seem relevant to my future goals I am a full blown space cadet.

    2. They hate the schedules, demands, and structure

      That's a bit of an over generalization? Clearly restaurants have very rigorous schedules, demands, and structures; though they are contextually very, very, very different.

    3. no matter how hard we try there will be some students who just can’t be reached in the higher education environment.

    1. I think that if become a mindful learner it will help me to become a better professor, who can hopefully instill the importance of mindful learning onto my students.

      What aspects of mindful learning do you find to be important? How do you think you can curb your mindless learning habits and shift your focus into being more mindful in your learning and eventual teaching?

    2. This is most likely because I am so focused on my research projects that I don’t leave enough time to focus on my course work (for example I left writing this blog post until the very last minute again this week).

      I can relate to this, at times grad school has me feeling like this:

    1. That being said, I fear that pedagogical enthusiasts might wrap themselves in the nuances of mindfulness and mindlessness. Heck, some might even decide to play the troll arguing for the need of a foundation of “mindlessness” in order to allow for “mindfulness” in later learning.

      I follow your logic here, and I do concur, those people are trolls.

      Does one have to be completely close minded in order to then be open minded? No.

      If you think of mindfulness like the dependent output of an equation changing with your experiences with respect to time, your past self will seem less mindful than your current self.

    2. I think it is rather sad that the only class I can legitimately remember anything from is not even remotely related to what my major was at the time
      • Was there something different about that class? [discussion vs. lecture]
      • Did this professor teach in a different way?
      • Was the content vastly different from what you have been working with for your prior years of enrollment?
    3. I can apply tools to the future for without that “one time learning”

      You mean, you didn't forget about everything you learned when you walked out of the room?!?

    4. “students are struggling to find meaning and significance in their education”.

      Sometimes it feels like this.

    5. I would like to try such practices in a lecture that I teach, but I definitely need to sit down and think of how that could be done given the nature of my area.

      The struggle!

    6. semantics

      had to Google this one: definition

      Not sure if I understand.

    7. I learned to resent administrative involvement and protest the idea that somebody can be assessed purely through standardized tests.

    1. By being part of this team I was able to take the knowledge I learned in class and the knowledge I gained from reading books and papers to exercise my creativity through modeling, design, and analysis of the suspension for the car.

      I participated as much as I could in ASCE's concrete canoe team. I found it difficult to manage undergraduate coursework, research, and applying to graduate programs with extra curricular activities, but we made concrete into a boat and it floated..

      And it was Star Wars themed.

    2. This class format really allowed us students to truly learn the ideas of uncertainty analysis and how it effects experimental setup by allowing us to perform a project on a topic that expressed our curiosity. In addition, the professor in charge didn’t have to come up with ideas/design experiments he just had to be there for support and guidance along the way.

      See that sounds like fun.

    3. But while studying engineering you are not really given an opportunity to express that curiosity.

      I played a lot of Minecraft...

    4. So in the end, I think there is a small amount of diversity in the curriculum. Maybe not as much diversity as some think there should be.

      5.c. ABET Curriculum "a broad education component that includes humanities and social sciences, complements the technical content of the curriculum, and is consistent with the program educational objectives."

    5. learn engineering basics before they can branch out into classes where they build off of the basics.

      Doesn't Ellen Langer say something about "learning the basics"?

    6. I would like to take these three principles and use them to comb through undergraduate mechanical engineering curriculum to see if the three principles are carried out.

      Let's do this!

    1. “Mindfulness coupled with ill-intent = Conway.” -Me

      And now we get into ethics.

    2. “Facts, whether derived from science or not, are not context-free; their meaning and usefulness depend on the situation.“-Langer

      Context is highly relevant even if we're discussing science. The laws of physics as they apply on Earth, may not apply in certain situations (like on other planets). Human behavior is not uniform across ages or situations. Context is everything.