Describe the two high-energy dance numbers, “Chaiya Chaiya” and “Badi Mushkil
They get pretty sensual and stuff
Describe the two high-energy dance numbers, “Chaiya Chaiya” and “Badi Mushkil
They get pretty sensual and stuff
What is noticeable about the Sufi performance in Jodha Akbar?
They're too coordinated and there's no improv
Who is Lata Mangeshkar and why is she important in the study of Bollywood films? Compare Lata’s two songs featured in this topic.
The most prolific playback singer ever born in 1928. She has done over 30k recordings for 2000 films
Why are playback singers used in Bollywood films?
Because they are popular in and of themselves
What is the role of song and dance in Bollywood? Compared to American musicals, why do song and dance figure so importantly in Bollywood?
They don't stop the action but continue the narrative trajectory in ways that explore paths through intertextuality of lyrics as well as rhythm, melody, genre, timbre, vocal production, etc.
Why is India presented as spectacle and fantasy in Bollywood films?
Escapism
When did women begin to work as actors in the film industry? Why were they able to do defy the age-old ban against female performers on a public stage?
In the 1920s Because the screen acts as a sort of veil
Why was Western film “perfectly suited to the Indian context of storytelling”?
Cinema techniques are able to enhance the mythical and they're able to routinely tackle the epic and the big questions
Why have women dominated the visual arts in India’s major urban centers? Why are women artists who make traditional art objects (like Ralli quilts) not part of this movement
Because they've been excluded for so long they've claimed this unique space as their own
Describe Rina Banerjee’s interest in repurposing objects. How might her work be seen as a way of contesting boundaries?
They explore specific colonial moments and reinvents place and identity as complex diasporic experiences intertwined and sometimes surreal
Describe Nalini Malani’s video on the effects of Partition.
She explores partition's effects on peoples' lives, like the mentally ill guy who refused to move so he died in no man's land.
Why does Zarina Hashmi use calligraphy and language to focus on borders In her work?
It helps her preserve her identity
What is significant about bindis on Bharti Kehr’s sculpture of a dying elephant?
They represent life and fertility on something dying, a striking juxtaposition
How do Shilpa Gupta’s interactive videos address the issue of boundaries?
They incorporate the viewers' shadows that interact with other stuff in the art.
How did the advent of photography affect women’s participation in the arts?
Photography allowed women to challenge high art. They were able to use sets, props, costumes, etc. to make art
What was the effect of rural retreats like Shantiniketan on the development of the modern arts in India?
They were places rendered "pure" because of their distance from the industrial west. They were equidistant from both the West and India's cultural past
How did urbanism and modernity affect the visual arts in India?
Printing and photography allowed social, religious, and educational reform. This allowed a lot more exposure for women in modern art
How do you interpret Rushdie’s penchant for exploring issues of identity
He often writes about people feeling out of place because he feels like an outsider wherever he goes
How do the stories in East, West reflect Rushdie’s unique world view?
Cultural boundaries are blurred, blended, and challenged throughout the book. He shines light on the problem of displacement in the lives of those who find themselves living in circumstances that are radically different from their country of origin. He generally is very willing to tear down figures in popular culture of both countries.
Why was The Satanic Verses considered so controversial?
It spans a lot of history from the time of Muhammad to now. Orthodox Muslims believe that it's a work that disparages and insults Mohammed and the religion of Islam
Describe the novel Midnight’s Children.
Magical realism where 1000 children born at midnight on partition have magical powers and have fates tied to the fates of India and Pakistan
What are some of the influences on Rushdie’s unique oral register?
He uses the oral voice in his writing. He tries to show that all speech and writing comes from somewhere and is therefore highly shaped by the subjective concerns of an unreliable individual performing to meet their demands of a fickle audience. Pretty much showing that it's heavily dependent on culture, history, community, etc. It "removes the authority of the disembodied voice"
Why could one say that the English language has been both a tool of colonial oppression and a tool of power in the post-colonial world?
People in India were forced to learn English and is still the language of the elite. It was used to cement and extend the dominion of the English that they already had through military and economic means. Because it's so common it's the language of global power
Characterize his unique use of the English language
He conquered English and made it his own by using it very uniquely, remaking it, colonizing it, "carving out" his own territory Just using it as a tool of reverse colonialism pretty much
Describe his literary output and his influence on world literature
Midnight's children, the Booker of the Bookers about partition Shame - idk about this one but it was apparently good East, West - you already know The Satanic Verses - made fun of Islam and whatever It was a symbolic for non-British English Language authors
Describe Salman Rushdie’s upbringing
Born in Bompay/Mumbai right before partition. Born to Muslim parents in Hindu area. He spoke Urdu as a lil kid at home but then moved to the UK and learned English. His family moved to Pakistan and he stayed but also did live with them in Pakistan for a hot minute
How are Ray’s films different from the kinds of films that are directed towards mass entertainment
Everything. Pacing. Music. The focus on seemingly inconsequential. His singular control over everything in the movie. Lots of silence in scenes.
Why are music and non-verbal qualities paramount? How do these qualities contribute to the communication of rasa?
This gives the film itself a sort of rhythm. Helps us to feel the underlying themes and emotions he wants to communicate. Shankar's score really emphasizes the Rasa through Raga, especially the weeping instrument (dilruba) he plays in the scene when the dad finds out durga is dead
What does Ray communicate through the pace of his films?
Communicates the subtleties and halftones of human behavior. Catches the essential in the ordinary and the sense of large and imminent in the small and supposedly inconsequential
How
Lots of emphasis on Rasa. poetic realism. underlying emphasis on change. His films are almost musical. Lots of nonverbal stuff.
Why
How raw and artsy it is I guess?
What
Illustrations
What
It was originally a novel for which Ray himself had provided illustrations. It was really popular among Bengali readers, became a school text, and has never gone out of print.
What
Inspired by the techniques as well as the content in Bicycle Thieves, Ray determined to use non-professional actors, modest resources, and shoot on actual locations Bicycle Thieves is a triumphant rediscovery of the fundamentals of cinema, and De Sica has openly acknowledged his debt to Chaplin. The simple universality of its theme, the effectiveness of its treatment, and the low cost of its production make it the ideal film for the Indian film-maker to study
Who was Satyajit Ray’s primary mentor in making film?
French film-maker Jean Renoir who made "The River"
What might be a reason why Shakespeare continues to occupy the minds and hearts of modern South Asians?
There are some alive today that were subjects of the British Raj. They haven't forgotten its impact as its so recent. Also Shakespeare is just really good and they naturally incorporate things they like into their culture
What is the purpose of the Bismil performance in the movie?
To heighten the suspense and drama. Also to please the crowds and make it a bollywood movie. Also to put an Indian spin on Shakespeare
Why did the British leave Kashmir’s status undetermined?
It was a tough call as it was this border state and had deep cultural roots for Buddhists, Hindus, and Muslims. They figured that the South Asians would figure it out I guess ????
What is the central conflict in the film?
Kashmir. India vs Pakistan. "Do we exist?"
Haider is an adaptation of which Shakespearean play?
Hamlet
Who directed the film Haider?
Vishal Bhardwaj
What might be a reason why South Asians are adept at adaptations?
Their eclectic cultural and religious traditions
Characterize the two conflicting views of Shakespeare among South Asians?
Basically one group that says he's an amazing world poet who they revere. Another group that says there's nothing special about him and that he can't be separated from being a sign of neocolonial hegemony
The first is the notions of Shakespeare as the bishwokobi or world poet, a writer to whom all Indians feel a natural affinity. The other is that there is nothing timeless or universal about Shakespeare. His works are not those to which Indians automatically relate . . . Shakespeare is, in fact, a sign of neocolonial hegemony, something that the colonial rulers slyly used to make their Indian subjects docile and obedient. The latter school believes that the Shakespeare text cannot be separated from its historical moorings. It cannot be disassociated from the social and political upheavals of the post-colonial world. They argue that Shakespeare enters India as a colonial tool and ends up as a sign of market forces in academic and cultural phenomena
Why was Shakespeare introduced as part of the curriculum of schools and universities in South Asia?
As part of the "civilizing mission" of the British as they sought to enculturate their subjects
Why was Shakespeare originally performed in South Asia?
First to entertain the British elite. Then as part of their "civilizing" mission
If we can argue that biodiversity is important for ecosystems, could we similarly argue that cultural diversity is important for human societies
Yes. Life becomes meaningless without culture and art and stuff
Why is Bollywood usually escapist? What might Bollywood movies provide for the average Indian citizen?
Life in India is hard. Bollywood tends to represent an idealized, even romanticized view of life (even in the rural parts). It does so in order to provide people an escape so that their imaginations can run wild for a while as they enjoy a movie
Why do kathputli performers often use film songs (filmi) in their performances?
Because over time their craft has been more and more about entertainment. As they've felt threatened by Bollywood they've incorporated flimi in an attempt to gain more popularity
Why is the bhopi completely covered?
It was disrespectful for a woman to perform uncovered, even associating her with prostitution ???
Who is the sutradhar?
"the one who holds the strings". He's the main puppeteer who also wears a string of bells on his hands and plays the boli (the reed instrument)
What is kathputli? What is one unique feature of the puppetry?
Puppetry that centers on the stories of a 17th century Rajput chieftain named Amar Singh Rathor. The flute representing divine speech The puppets which turn from male to female, god to demon just by being turned upside down
Why do we consider the Pabuji performances to be multimodal?
They display a dynamic relationship between music, visual arts, drama, dance, and poetry.
Who is the legendary figure associated with the Painted Ballads?
Pabuji, a 14th century Rajput Chieftain who now seen as a deity/folk hero.
What has been the role of the Rajputs in South Asian history?
Legendary defenders of the subcontinent from outside forces in it's most vulnerable part
Where on the South Asian subcontinent is Rajasthan located?
Northwest
How do the songs and poetry of the Bauls epitomize Bateson’s notion of the arts as a corrective
They functioned as a corrective to religious traditions that to them were so rigid that they actually inhibited a man knowing God. Furthermore, their cultural traditions functioned as correctives to the oppressive leadershi of the British Raj.
Who are the Bauls?
Means "crazies" or "mad for God". These people believe that God is hidden in the heart of man and that temples, mosques, churches, and other relics of organized religion inhibit one's search for truth. They are influenced by Sahaja Buddhism, Vaishnavism, and Sufism.
Why did Tagore especially admire bhatiyali?
He was a native of Bengal and loved the simple beauty of these cultural traditions that helped the people connect with their own identities
What are bhatiyali? What are the lyrics about? What are some of the musical characteristics?
These are the Bengali "boat songs". They are about include contemplative metaphors about deliverance and journeys as mankind rows on wide rivers and deep seas. They also sing about the tedium of work as well as the dangers of the water
What is the name of the university founded by Tagore? Name two of its unique characteristics.
Tagore also founded an unusual university called Shantiniketan in which Indian folk music, dance, drama, and literature constituted part of the curriculum More unique stuff?????
What is Vaishnavism?
A blending of Sufism and Hinduism. It teaches the union of God and man through devotion and love. It's associated with Krishna but also adopted some of the mystical practices of Islamic Sufism
What is the Sahaja sect of Buddhism?
A sect that integrated Hinduism into Buddhism
What is the relationship between the state of Bengal in India and Bangladesh? Where are these areas located on the South Asian subcontinent?
Their is a unifying culture between India's Hindu Bengal and the Muslim Bangladesh. These distinctive cultural forms go transcend national borders.
Why did Tagore promote literature in the vernacular?
Because he was a champion of India and its values and culture. ???? Tagore became passionate about indigenous cultural forms—particularly from his native Bengal—and he urged authors all over India to write in their vernacular or spoken (as opposed to classical) languages. Tagore also founded an unusual university called Shantiniketan in which Indian folk music, dance, drama, and literature constituted part of the curriculum. As a result of his attentions, a popular folk aesthetic developed in India
Why did he consider the arts to be central to the identity of South Asian people?
They allowed people to connect with the power of their own culture and heritage (?????) He saw that they were the product of rich cultures and were able to unite people
Why were the Little Traditions important during the British Raj?
They functioned to unite South Asians against the British, legitimizing nationalistic feelings and providing a voice of resistance for people of low social standing. These traditions functioned as a corrective to the oppressive leadership of the British.
How are the Little Traditions enculturative?
They educate people on mythology, history, culture, work, geography, etc. and connect them with their ancestors that have been enjoying the little traditions for generations
What are the Little Traditions?
The thousands of folk traditions throughout India. They are discrete cultural genres that are unique to limited geographic areas
What was your favorite poem by Tagore and why did you select it
Flying Man - I thought his intense criticism of airplanes as something unnatural and evil was really interesting, and showed one of the cases in which Tagore was very extreme, perhaps even too extreme for his own countrymen to relate to
What is the name of the university founded by Tagore?
Shantiniketan institute for the arts in Bolpur
Where was English literature first taught as a university subject?
India
What is Gitanjali?
A collection of Tagore's devotional song lyrics that won the nobel prize for literature
What are two of the important themes in Tagore’s work that are listed in topic 14?
fascination with heritage chance and play time, memory, the moment the unity and continuity of creation (as seen through the notion of Brahman) time travel, return, and arrival the notion of the “beautiful”
Who was Tagore and why is he still considered to be so important in South Asia?
He was a native Indian poet who championed Indian patriotism/nationalism/independence but was also deeply influenced by the British education system and culture. He is revered for the role he played in helping India to gain its independence as well as for winning a Nobel prize in literature for his poetry.
What year did East Pakistan become the People’s Republic of Bangladesh?
1971
Why was Azziz portrayed sympathetically and Godbole portrayed as a caricature?
The British respected Muslims as more civilized, especially with them worshiping the same Abrahamic God, while Hindus were seen as backwards and strange.
Who wrote the novel Midnight’s Children? In essence, what was it about?
Salman Rushdie wrote it about a fantastical story about a Muslim family's journey in the years prior to, during, and after parition.
What was Partition? When did it take place?
The division of British India into Hindu India and Muslim Pakistan (East and West) in 1947
Why did the British want Indians to learn to speak English?
Publicly they said it was to civilize the Indians but in reality it was to make it easy for them so they wouldn't have to learn the native languages there for trade and rule.
What is the name of the country that used to be called West and East Pakistan?
The Islamic Republic of Pakistan (West Pakistan) and Bangladesh (East Pakistan)
Who wrote the novel film A Passage to India? Who rewrote the screenplay and directed the film that was based on the novel?
E.M. Forster wrote the book. Santha Rama Rau adapted it into a play and wrote the original screenplay. Later, David Lean rewrote the screenplay and directed the movie
What was the British Raj?
The British occupation of South Asia that started in 1857 as the British taking advantage of the waning Mughal empire
What was the East India Company?
An English company that initiated trade with Mughal India in the 1700s
Part
Topic 15 talked about the British Raj, depicted in A Passage to India, and it's lasting cultural impacts in India. Next, topic 16 talked about Tagore and his beautiful, influential poetry, and the way he helped fight the Raj with the cultural power of the little traditions. Next, we learned about the Bauls of Bengal and Bangladesh and their cultural traditions including the Bhatiyali boat songs and their interest religious sects. Next, we learned about the Little Traditions in Rajasthan such as the painted ballads about the Rajput Pabuji and the Kathpuli puppet shows, also centered on the legendary Rajput defenders. We then learned about the interesting relationship India has with Shakespeare, with the film Haider as a product of the Shakespearian tradition in India.
for
Essay ideas: 1. Humanism: man as measure of all things. Humanizing the gods and exalting the humans 2. Status and Wealth. Art used to display it. Fibula, house paintings, Roman patrafamilia busts
20

19

18
![]()
17

16

15

14
![]()
13

12

11

10

9
![]()
8

7

6
![]()
5

4

3

2
![]()
1
![]()
Where the Mind Is Without Fear
She felt like an in-between person that didn't belong in any one culture. She went through a time in which she only saw her husband once every 6 months. Agonized over her family and herself and if she was doing enough. She found comfort in this poem and recited it almost like a prayer.
How many assignments are associated with writing the paper?
5: topic selection, thesis statement, rough draft, oral presentation (optional other draft), and final paper
According to Nusrat, what is the message of Sufism?
Devotion to Allah???
Why might Abida Parveen be seen as a "gynandrous" performer? What might be the significance of her gynandry?
She presents herself in a masculine way, perhaps to elevate herself as to be on the same level of her male counterparts
How might one see gender expression as a corrective in Pakistan?
In Pakistan, a Muslim nation, the male participation in society is multifaceted and very public, while the female participation is limited. Gender expression makes this participation more equal
Who is Abida Parveen? Why is she so important in Pakistan?
She is one of the great female Qawwals who has become internationally famous as the "Queen of Sufi music". She's a local star in Pakistan and one of the greatest Sufi singers ever.
What sounds do you hear in traditional Qawwali performances? Include references to all vocal, bodily, and instrumental sounds.
Loud vocals, tabla beat, harmonium organ sound, clapping
What is sargam? How did Nusrat use it?
Sargam is the use of the Indian "solfege" syllables. He used these frequently, especially in his improvisation
Who was Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan? What made him important as a national figure in Pakistan? As a global figure?
He was the most famous Qawwal in recent history, coming from a tradition of Qawwali of more than 600 years. He was hugely popular in Pakistan and won respect on a global stage. His voice was featured in several movies and he performed in many places worldwide
Explain the idea of Qawwali as a context-specific art form.
Depending on the different contexts that are discovered by the Qawwali as they perform, different languages, poems, and musical styles are used.
Why is poetry so important in Qawwali? Why is music so important in Qawwali?
They recite poetry with religious, sacred messages that are central to Qawwali. Music enhances the spiritual power and message of the mystical poetry
What is the significance of the string tied around the wrist?
Makes the guru-student bond/relationship official and binding
How is Qawwali similar to the Great Tradition? How is it different?
It incorporates some features and instruments from the Great Tradition and some from little folk traditions. It is a Muslim tradition and is more devotional. Sung in Farsi, Hindi, Urdu, and Arabic
Qawwali uses ragas in setting texts and relies heavily on improvisation However, it's more text centered than raga centered. Sometimes ragas are mixed (forbidden in Hindustani music). Qawwals use elements from popular and folk songs too
Explain Bateson’s notion of arts as a corrective. How might the absence of this corrective contribute to degeneracy in society?
Art "corrects" a too purposive/systemic view/practice of life and injects life and "wisdom" into it
What is Qawwali?
Qwalli is the most dominant musical Sufi musical tradition of South Asia
Explain the meaning of Sufism and its relationship to orthodox Islam.
Sufism is a mystical sect of Islam in which music and dance are central to worship. Often considered problematic to orthodox Muslims because they believe music is very worldly
What is the value of using syllables to represent numbers when teaching rhythm in Indian classical music? Explain the meaning of Sufism and its relationship to orthodox Islam. What is Qawwali? Explain Bateson’s notion of arts as a corrective. How might the absence of this corrective contribute to degeneracy in society? How is Qawwali similar to the Great Tradition? How is it different? Why is poetry so important in Qawwali? Why is music so important in Qawwali? Explain the idea of Qawwali as a context-specific art form. Who was Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan? What made him important as a national figure in Pakistan? As a global figure? What is sargam? How did Nusrat use it? What sounds do you hear in traditional Qawwali performances? Include references to all vocal, bodily, and instrumental sounds. Who is Abida Parveen? Why is she so important in Pakistan? Why might Abida Parveen be seen as a "gynandrous" performer? What might be the significance of her gynandry? How might one see gender expression as a corrective in Pakistan? According to Nusrat, what is the message of Sufism?
Helps keep track of the subdivisions
Explain the idea of the “nectar of the tradition” that comes from the guru.
The student gives up personal freedom to learn from their guru but in return receives all the devotion and knowledge, the "nectar of the tradition and the flowering of his or her own music, that the guru has to offer
What is the lax period of initiation?
A student might live with their guru for a year or 2 doing menial tasks and learning little about music in order to test their dedication
What does “schoolmaster-to-grace” refer to?
The rigid rules are like the schoolmaster that lead to improvisation which is like grace
What happened in the concert that validated one of those 4 stated advantages?
Zuckerman was calm and collected about his string breaking and responded accordingly
What are 4 advantages of learning how to improvise for Western musicians?
What is the difference between Pandit and Ustad?
Pandit - used for a Hindu guru Ustad - refers to a Muslim guru
Who was Ravi Shankar’s guru? Was his guru Muslim or Hindu?
Ravi Shankar was Hindu, even born as a Brahmin, but studied music with Allaudin Kha, his Muslim guru
What are sympathetic strings?
Strings on a sitar that lie below the main strings. They aren't played directly but resonate when the upper ones play
Explain the idea of close listening.
Paying very close attention to the sounds heard in music (instruments, number of people, etc)
What happens during the Gat section?
The tala is introduced (the drum comes in)
List and explain the 3 parts of the Alap. What is explored during the Alap?
Why is vocal music considered more important than instrumental music?
In the same way the words and sounds of the Vedas are believed to reach the gods, the lyrics of Hindustani classical music inspire devotion in a special way
Explain the concept of raga. Explain the concept of tala. What are the bols?
Raga - the generator of Hindustani classical music. It defines the pattern of notes, the essence/emotion of the piece, and the associations. Many are believed to have curative powers Tala - Metrical framework of rhythm and melody. It is a long cycle usually of 12, 14, or 16 beats. There are different kinds of beats (claps and empty beats) as well as subdivisions. Tala is kept by the audience Bols: idk what tf these are
Why is improvisation central to this musical tradition?
It can only be learned after years of painstakingly rehearsing skills and ragas and other musical rules/structures The composed pieces are used as part of an improvised whole
What are the 3 parameters of Hindustani classical music?
Why might it be helpful to strive for being fair, reasoned, and reasonable when first listening to Hindustani classical music?
It's very different from our own music but that does not mean it's any less developed or that one music is culturally superior
What are 3 names for Hindustani classical music?
What is the relationship between Debanjan Bhattacharjee and Swapan Chaudhuri? What instrument do they play? What is the significance of Dr. Bhattacharjee being a STEM scholar?
Debanjan is a Muslim professor at UVU who is a disciple of his Hindu guru Swapan. He learned the tabla (drums) from him. This shows that many musicians lead a professional career besides music
What is the guru-shishya parampara? How is the oral tradition related to it?
That is the guru-student relationship. The guru orally teaches everything about how to be a musician in terms of actual music as well as how to lead their life. There is no written form of Hindustani music
What do we mean when we say that Hinduism enfolds—rather than absorbs—differences?
Those differences become part of Hinduism (like how Buddha is considered an avatar of Vishnu)
What was the Indianizing of Muslim musicians and the Islamicization of Hindustani music? What was the Brahmanical legacy? The Islamic legacy?
The Muslims musicians were revered instead of looked down upon in India and a "caste" of Muslim musicians was formed. The Indians were taught actual skillful musical technique. The Brahmins taught that music was sacred and something honorable The Muslims had the actual technical ability
List 3 different kinds of buildings created by the Mughals. What was depicted on these buildings? What was NOT depicted on these buildings? Why?
Explain why the paintings were small. What were Akbar’s thoughts about painting?
Because originally anatomy textbooks got approval to draw stuff as long as the images were small and that size practice extended to art Akbar thought it was an act of devotion/honor to God that would deepen faith
What were the 3 main examples of cultural syncretism during the Mughal period?
What was unique about Fatehpur Sikri? Why was Queen Elizabeth I impressed with Akbar?
Experiment of creating new religion out of the best parts of all religions She liked him because of his prowess with ruling such a diverse nation, especially being a Muslim ruler of a Hindu nation
Name the founder of the Mughals, his grandson, and the grandson’s grandson.
Babur - founder Akbar - his grandson, the best Sha Jahan - Akbar's grandson, made Taj Mahal
What is QRBOWE? What is a contestable thesis?
Question Research Brainstorm a contestable thesis/claim and write thesis Outline: create outline of evidence to be used Write the first draft Edit your paper at least twice
Who performs the Call to Prayer? What are its unique qualities? Why is it not considered singing? Do we have something similar to the “Call to Prayer” in our church?
The Adhan is performed by the muezzin who chants and puts his fingers in his ears Not singing because music is worldly We've got hymns and personal prayers
Can you name one of the poets or scholars mentioned by Professor Kuddus? What is the theme of the poem Professor Kuddus read to us?
Mentioned Ibn Sina (the father of modern medicine) Umar Khayyam (mathematician, astronomer, philosopher, poet) He reads his poem "In the house of the milk square"
What are some of the basic differences between Islam and Hinduism?
1 god vs many gods Absolute truth vs many paths to moksha Prescribed path that all must publicly take vs religion being a personal thing Hinduism is very flexible while Islam is not Islam promotes social equality vs Hindu caste system
What are the 3 additional principles Toronto mentions? (Why might we, as members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, have holy envy regarding the third principle?)
What are the 5 pillars of Islam? (TPAPF)
There were 3 waves of Islamic invasions in South Asia, and when were they?
When is the early submission deadline for the first draft of the paper?
First draft due Friday 3/4
How many events are you required to attend for the course? Where and how do you list the events on the paper?
3 Events listed in bullet points at the top of the research paper
The first step is to summarize each topic in terms of a narrative, providing what I call a “big picture approach” to studying. My “big picture” story for topics 8–13 goes something like this:
Topic 8 focused on important points for writing our paper Topic 9 introduced the topic of Islam in South Asia, its basic tenets, and why Islam and Hinduism clashed in India Topic 10 focused on the Mughal rule and the syncretism during the time that happened primarily in the arts, especially through Hindustani classical music, Mughal architecture, and Mughal miniature paintings. Topic 11 focused specifically on Hindustani classical music, its basic structure, and the guru-student relationship Topic 12 continued with the theme of Hindustani music, specifically on the oral way it was taught, culminating in workshop with Ken Zuckerman Topic 13 focused on the Qwalli musical tradition within sufism, often seen as a correction to orthodox Islam.
Please pay attention to the reasons why he considers improvisation an important skill.
Builds musical skills that can't be learned as well by other methods. Historical musicians were masters of improv. It is purely musical and provides immense satisfaction. From technical skills, to ensemble playing, to memorizing pieces more quickly, to analysis and interpretation, learning to improvise sharpens many of a musicians’ skills and even trains new abilities that may otherwise never develop
1.

20

19
18

17
![]()
16

15

14

13

12

11

10.
9
8.

7
How did Buddhism emerge from Hinduism?
Belief in reincarnation. Buddha dwelling on the Upshanids, becoming a yogi. Dissatisfaction with the caste system. Desire to be done with reincarnation NOW. Desire to learn the root of suffering
What is the role of fractals in the Khandariya Mahadev Temple at Khajuraho?
Alludes to the Hindu idea of the time wheel—that time and life repeat.
Carl Sagan and Hindu cosmology: what is the Hindu idea that aligns with modern science?
The idea of a universe that's hecka old. (billions of years)
Vedic assertion that the entire universe is infinitely cyclic and self-similar in structure
Give two examples of myths depicted on Hindu temples.
Descent of the Ganges Myth humans rejoicing at the water coming from the Ganges Durga - Some Buffalo headed fool was wrecking everything so the gods came together and created Durga, a chick who killed him then married Shiva
What was the lingering effect of Buddhism on the visual arts and architecture of the Gupta period? What were the two ironies?
Irony 1 The Ajanta paintings reflect Buddhist stories in a predominantly Hindu culture. Irony 2 The Ajanta paintings depict the flamboyance and worldliness of the Hindu court, yet the underlying messages of the stories behind the paintings are Buddhist, and Buddhism shuns worldliness
The role of Bodhisattvas in Buddhism was reflective of the role of avatars in Hinduism. Why were intermediaries so important?
Bodhisattva in Buddhism and the avatar in Hinduism were expressions of a humanism that brought divinity within the reach of everyday people
What was the role of Fa Xian’s diary?
Best source for daily life in the Gupta dynasty
How were Hindu sculpture and architecture the beneficiaries of Buddhist art and architecture?
Temples were inspired by Buddhist architecture Future Hindu depictions of their gods were inspired by Buddhist art of the Buddha
We see Buddha depicted in the art of the Kushans. What were the two main artistic styles of Kushan art? How did they differ in terms of inspiration and style?
Gandhara Style : Roman influenced Mathura Style - "Indian looking". Knot on head, long ears, "wet" looking clothes
The Kushan Dynasty (50–320 CE) assumed power after the fall of the Mauryans and made Mahayana Buddhism the state religion (even though most citizens were Hindu). How did the Kushans facilitate the spread of ideas and cultural artifacts?
Over land and sea. Also they portrayed western ideas in art
Eventually, two major sects of Buddhism emerged: Theravada (“works”) and Mayahana (“grace”). What is significant about this division?
The Kushans adopted Mahayana Buddhism
What is the significance of sixth century BCE in terms of world religions?
4 noble truths and 8fold path: To be is to suffer The cause of suffering is desire To eliminate suffering one must eliminate desire The way to eliminate desire is to follow The Noble Eightfold Path, which includes the correct views inclinations sayings conduct livelihood endeavor mindfulness meditations
What were the three major forms of Buddhist architecture?
Stupa - Hemisphere mounds that contain ashes of Buddha. Chaitya halls - a building with a barrel-vaulted roof. At the center of the rounded end is a small stupa. Living rock = matrix that contains the potential for all forms even though the rock itself is unformed Vihara - longer rectangular building directly behind the domed structure. Dwelling place for monks
Why was Buddhism enfolded into Hinduism (with Buddha received as the ninth incarnation of Vishnu)? What influence did Buddhist art have on Hindu art and architecture?
In order to regain control especially as motivated by the Brahmin caste that felt threatened by Buddhism Buddhist art (and especially architecture) continued in the Hindu dominated Gupta period
What is the story associated with Siddhartha Gautama's birth? His quest? His enlightenment? What is the cause of suffering? How does one release oneself from suffering?
Born in extreme luxury. Parents told that he'd either be a prince or a holy man so they protected him from any discomfort. He ended up seeing people suffering and forsook his kingdom in order to find the root of suffering. He discovered that the cause of suffering is desire and that one must eliminate desire to eliminate suffering
What is the significance of sixth century BCE in terms of world religions?
The Buddha achieves enlightenment Lehi leaves Jerusalem
What is significant about the meeting between Vishnu, Brahma, Shiva, and other deities in the first part of the Ramayana?
It is similar to our belief in the pre existence with deity coming down from heaven to confront one cast out from heaven
Why are there so many versions of the Ramayana?
Each is adapted to the circumstances and needs of the people at that time.
What is Richman’s main thesis about the Ramayana?
There is no single definitive Ramayana. Each tells a unique story adapted to those people and their circumstances while drawing from the same general pool of characters and plots.
What is enculturation? Why is it essential for non-literate peoples?
An activity that promotes socialization or the teaching of values (especially for the non-literate) It is the primary way for them to receive these values and practice them
How does Foley explain oral tradition? What are several of its important features?
oral tradition refers to a dynamic and highly diverse oral-aural medium for evolving, storing, and transmitting knowledge, art, and ideas. It remains the dominant form of communication and transmitting ideas Most notably, they are rule-governed. They use special languages and performance arenas while employing flexible patterns and structures that aid composition, retention, and reperformance. In addition, they assume an active role for the audience and fulfill a clear and important function for the societies that maintain them
What was the significance of sound for the Aryan conquerors? What forms of artistic expression were suppressed? What happened to female fertility figures? How does Foley explain oral tradition? What are several of its important features? What is enculturation? Why is it essential for non-literate peoples? What is Richman’s main thesis about the Ramayana? Why are there so many versions of the Ramayana? What is significant about the meeting between Vishnu, Brahma, Shiva, and other deities in the first part of the Ramayana? What is the significance of sixth century BCE in terms of world religions? What is the story associated with Siddhartha Gautama's birth? His quest? His enlightenment? What is the cause of suffering? How does one release oneself from suffering? Why was Buddhism enfolded into Hinduism (with Buddha received as the ninth incarnation of Vishnu)? What influence did Buddhist art have on Hindu art and architecture? The Maurya Dynasty (322–185 BCE): Chandragupta Maurya, Bindusara, and Ashoka (273–236 BCE). Ashoka converted to Buddhism and made it the state religion—although most of the population was Hindu. Early Ashokan Buddhist sculptures did not depict Buddha but did depict his mother (reminiscent of female fertility figures of Dravidians). What were the three major forms of Buddhist architecture? Stupas represented the cosmos in miniature, reflecting Vedic as well as Buddhist ideals about the universe; chaitya halls were sometimes built into rock or the “living matrix.” Eventually, two major sects of Buddhism emerged: Theravada (“works”) and Mayahana (“grace”). What is significant about this division? The Kushan Dynasty (50–320 CE) assumed power after the fall of the Mauryans and made Mahayana Buddhism the state religion (even though most citizens were Hindu). How did the Kushans facilitate the spread of ideas and cultural artifacts? We see Buddha depicted in the art of the Kushans. What were the two main artistic styles of Kushan art? How did they differ in terms of inspiration and style? The Gupta Dynasty (320–540 CE) was considered the golden age of Hindu rule in northern India. The three important rulers were: Chandragupta I, Samudragupta, and Chandragupta II. Grandson effect? How were Hindu sculpture and architecture the beneficiaries of Buddhist art and architecture? What was the role of Fa Xian’s diary? The role of Bodhisattvas in Buddhism was reflective of the role of avatars in Hinduism. Why were intermediaries so important? What was the lingering effect of Buddhism on the visual arts and architecture of the Gupta period? What were the two ironies? Literature of the Guptas: court poetry, drama (driven by rasa or emotions, not by plot), and fables known as the Panchatantra. Science—astronomy, mathematics, and textiles—were more advanced in the first two areas than Europe by a thousand years. The Rajput paintings, developed by artists from Rajasthan after the fall of the Guptas, moved away from Buddhist style and became rasa-driven (not meant to depict realism). Hindu temples—from simple shrine to elaborate temples—were highly influenced by Buddhist art and architecture. In Hinduism, secular and religious imagery combine; mythology revealed in Hindu architecture and sculpture. Give two examples of myths depicted on Hindu temples. Carl Sagan and Hindu cosmology: what is the Hindu idea that aligns with modern science? What is the role of fractals in the Khandariya Mahadev Temple at Khajuraho?
Correct oral transmission was imperative. They believed the sounds of the vedas themselves were the source of power and communication to the gods Initially suppressed images of the gods
When did the Aryans invade? What did they bring with them? How did cultural syncretism take place between the Aryans and Dravidians? What are the four legacies of the Aryan invasion?
1500 BC. Brought religion, caste system, their culture, their language (sanskrit). Ex: Dravidians worshipped bulls, Aryans worshipped cattle. combined in Hinduism cows are worshipped Hindu religion and social system are results of that cultural syncretism
What are the Ralli quilts and what relationship do they have to the artifacts from the Indus Valley Civilization?
Handmade quilts that are made from memory and passed on strictly through oral civilization. Super similar to ancient pottery from the area = connection and tradition passed down unchanged through memory/oral tradition
We began this topic with a discussion of the Indus Valley Civilization (also known as the Harappan Civilization), with Harappa and Mohenjo-Daro as its major cities. Where are these cities located? Who are the Dravidians? What artifacts did they produce? What gods did they worship? How did they communicate?
NE India/Pakistan along Indus River Dravidians were a city dwelling agricultural people Produced Ralli quilts, pottery. Worshipped bulls
We covered five geographical areas of the subcontinent: highlands, plains, Ganges, Deccan Plateau, and coastline. What is one significant characteristic or feature of each area?
Highlands: Himilayas, mountain passes in the NW that are India's Achilles heel Plains: Home of the Rajput Maharajas (kings) Ganges: Spiritual home, sacred, source of life and crops Deccan Plateau: Middle of India, divider between N/S, home to Dravidians Coastline: sandlewood, gathering place for merchants and sailors
Indo-Aryan: Hindi, Bengali Dravidian: Tamil, Telugu Pakistan: Urdu
Varna: Kshatriya—warriors, rulers Brahmin/Brahman—scholars, religious leaders (most distinguished of all the castes) Vaisya—merchants, petty landowners Sudras—peasants, artisans Pariahs—untouchables, lowest caste
Reincarnation: Dependent upon karma. Could move up or down in caste until you are released (moshka)
Shiva the destroyer, Brahman the creator, Vishnu the preserver