One of people’s biggest fears about LLMs in school is that students will simply let the LLM do the writing, thereby engaging in a form of plagiarism.
LLMs themselves are literal plaigiarism generators.
One of people’s biggest fears about LLMs in school is that students will simply let the LLM do the writing, thereby engaging in a form of plagiarism.
LLMs themselves are literal plaigiarism generators.
machine perspectives.
Jim, the machine has no perspective other than the one that is programmed / trained / tuned into it.
Schools do not appear to devote much time to engaging students in the four forms of writing for intrinsically meaningful purposes or to integrating them as a way to develop expansive cognition.
WHICH SCHOOLS JIM?! This feels like a broad and sweeping claim with no evidence cited.
It combines the analytical and processing capabilities
What is being analyzed? What is being processed?
A new form of AI literacy will embody a true partnership between AI and humans. In this partnership, both parties work together to enhance each other’s strengths, address weaknesses, and achieve results neither could reach alone.
I am begging you to stop humanizing the LLM
Generative AIs represent a new form of “literacy” that will integrate with and transform existing literacies, including traditional ones.
NOOOO I thought you said look at social practices first, rather than technologies, omg Jim
In contrast, LLMs do more than generate text; they simulate understanding, provide coherent responses, and interact in ways that can shape human thought and communication.
JIM NOOOOOOOOO
generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools to enhance their cognitive, social, and emotional understanding and creativity beyond what is possible without them
How exactly DO stochastic parrots extend human capabilities?
Calculators presented a dual potential: the potential to de-skill students and the potential to empower them.
Already this is a little weird because do calculators even do algebra? At least the ones generally available to students?
Padlet
Padlet is akin to an online "bulletin board" that students can post on, though there are many ways educators have used it in their practice. Here, I use it as a space for students to share their work with one another.
Step 1. Document your Efforts
Each of these "steps" is accompanied by its own page in the Learning Management System. For additional samples, please contact me at eaguilera@mail.fresnostate.edu.
Process
While I once believed that projects that were defined in a step-wise fashion was bad for student creativity, in practice I have found just the opposite. When I streamline certain aspects of the process, students have demonstrated creative freedom in areas that I did not over-specify.
Evaluates
Another big issue I struggled with was making sure students were still able to get a meaningful experience from the final assignment of the course. This particular objective aligned with an existing final project option.
Analyzes
In line with the current discourses around "ungrading," these objectives eventually become a simple "checklist" for students to ensure they have addressed all aspects of the project. I share more about the specifics of this approach here: Less Grading, Better Teaching.
crisis
As I mentioned in the video, my core tension was the commitment not to add too much additional work onto participants, but instead to draw on their everyday experiences facing their social realities and center that as the core "content" of this project.
support the teaching and learning of students, fellow teachers, parents, families, schools, or communities
I framed this prompt in response to feedback students gave me about how the class included folks who were not all full time teachers, though the majority of the class was. The goal was to expand the notion of "teaching" to encompass the acts that parents, caregivers, community leaders, and community members engage in to support learning.
As [Student Name Redacted] put it in our discussion board, this is truly an exercise of theory into practice.
This project prompt was developed in collaboration with students who offered their own thoughts, ideas, and feedback on initial drafts of the assignment in a course discussion board.
video
The video "talkthrough" below, created specifically as part of the COVID-19 revisions to my assignments, follows conventions of similar videos in the course. In these videos, I highlight:
Note
I include notes on accessibility on any page that includes media other than text.
Rather
A few notes on the instructional shifts that I allude to in the video:
April 13-17, 2020
I tend to schedule the "publishing" of modules on a week-to-week basis. This is meant to promote a focus on shared experience of our content over time.
Current Module
I typically list all modules of the course on the homepage, including the currently active and next available one. For the sake of simplicity, I will only include this reference to the current module that aligns with the video above.
MSJE
"Multicultural and Social Justice Education" is a term used in the MAT program at Fresno State to refer to the wide range of pedagogical approaches advocated by our program. For some essential reading on framings of educational justice, see the work of Eve Tuck & K. Wayne Yang.
video
Unlike the other example mentioned in the article, this video is unscripted. It was created using Camtasia 3 software, though many software platforms can perform similar functions. Prior to this course, I used Open Broadcaster Software to record this "genre" of video.
Week 12
The course is regularly taught over the course of a 15-week semester.
back
This module was posted following the "Spring Break" of our school, a few weeks into the California statewide shelter-in-place.
YouTube
The ethics of video hosting platforms is an entirely conversation in and of itself, and continues to change over time. In my case, I have opted for simplicity, ease of access, and captioning features over other concerns I have about YouTube and its parent company.
video
A few notes on my production process:
Note
I include notes on accessibility on any page that includes media other than text.
few definitions of this concept
In framing these multiple definitions, I was inspired by the work of Carl Grant & Christine Sleeter.
Reflect
While I frame reflective questions around each video I post, these are not "turned in" like an assignment. This move allows me to contextualize media as it relates to our course content, while freeing up students to work on more participatory activities for a given module. For further inspiration, see Jesse Stommel's work on Ungrading.
Big Idea
Each week, I like to frame module content around one "Big Idea" - a broad concept that I briefly overview in a > 5 minute video. These videos are meant to make ideas more widely accessible to students with varying kinds of background knowledge and prior experience. I first heard of "The Big Idea" through the work of Jim Burke, and his book, [What's the Big Idea?](https://www.heinemann.com/products/e02157.aspx) from my days teaching high school English.
Multicultural education
The core text for this course was James & Cherry Banks' edited volume Multicultural Education: Issues and Perspectives. This module featured James' chapter from that book, entitled "Multicultural Characteristics: Characteristics & Goals."
video
This video was made using Adobe Spark Video, which is free to use at the time of this writing. I learned about this through the work of Michelle Pacansky-Brock