9 Matching Annotations
  1. Oct 2024
  2. inst-fs-iad-prod.inscloudgate.net inst-fs-iad-prod.inscloudgate.net
    1. The middle grades are where the rubber meets the road. This is where college-bound freshmen and all the rest are separated like oil and water. Here the issue of school funding and the deleterious effects of how we fund publi~ education in this country becomes an obvious barrier to students' academic suc-cess and their ability to move upward in the social classes.

      Middle school is such a important time in education, and this passage makes me realize just how early the stratification between students begins. It's alarming to think that by middle school, students are already being sorted into paths that will determine their future access to higher education and social mobility. The lack of funding for public schools, particularly in lower-income areas, means that students in these schools are set up to fall behind their peers in wealthier districts. It’s frustrating to see how much potential is wasted simply because of unequal access to resources, qualified teachers, and support systems. This divide underscores the urgent need for systemic reform to ensure that all students, regardless of background, have an equal shot at success.

    2. In the throes of his 2012 election-year bid for president, and deeply steeped in his own wealth, Mitt Romney issued a word of advice for young people about what it might take to be successful and wealthy.

      Romney’s advice reveals such a disconnect between the wealthy and the realities faced by most students, especially those from low-income backgrounds. Telling someone to "borrow from your parents" assumes a world where wealth is easily accessible, showing complete ignorance of the struggles faced by students who have no financial safety net. It’s infuriating to see how little understanding exists among those in power about the true barriers to success in education and beyond.

    3. Historically and contemporarily, U.S. public schools illustrate th · 1. · f . . . . . . e s1mp 1c1ty o reproduction-that 1s, the mdehble relat1onship between curre t d 1 . n an eventua class membership-by way of replicating class status in the superior ed t. I · · f h · h uca 10na opportumt1es o t ose wit more money

      This quote exposes the deep systemic nature of class replication through education. It's frustrating to see that the same cycle of privilege continues unchecked. The way schools are funded, how access to good teachers and resources depends on wealth—these all ensure that education keeps reinforcing class divides. It feels like we are trapped in a cycle that we are unwilling to break because doing so would threaten the privileges of the wealthy.

    4. Mann chided the economic elite for shirking obligations to their fellow man by favoring private education over common schools. He conceptualized public education as "the great equalizer," or the most powerful mechanism for abating class-based "prejudice and hatred," and, most important, the only means by which those without economic privilege or generational wealth could experience any hope of equal footing.

      Mann’s idea that education could serve as “the great equalizer” is both inspiring and frustrating. The vision of a system that counters class-based inequality is powerful, yet the fact that private education still dominates feels like we’ve betrayed that mission. It’s clear that the gap between public and private schooling perpetuates rather than closes divides, making me wonder if we’ve lost the will to truly make education equalizing.

  3. inst-fs-iad-prod.inscloudgate.net inst-fs-iad-prod.inscloudgate.net
    1. Public schools are essential to make the American dream work, but schools are also the arena in which many Americans first fail.

      This quote emphasizes the unpalatable truth about public education: it serves as both a springboard for opportunity and a breeding ground for inequity. The concept that failure in school practically assures lifetime failure sounds so devastating, yet it represents the way structural racism and economic inequality pervade education. The idea that schools, which are supposed to be equalizers, frequently end up serving as environments where generational disadvantages are reinforced rather than eliminated, is unsettling.

    2. Irrational policymaking can be explained by the fact that public official have made their choices at least partly on the basis of claims that pursuing col~ lective goals of the American dream could endanger or has endangered the in-dividual achievement of privileged children.

      The idea that leveling the playing field will somehow harm those at the top exposes one of the central inconsistencies of education policy, as this quotation demonstrates. It's as though privilege, especially in instances where it sustains inequity, requires defense. Any significant progress toward equitable education for everyone is undermined by legislators' seeming preoccupation with preserving the status quo for the affluent rather than eliminating fundamental obstacles.

    3. The gap between belief and action has emerged in different school districts at different times over different issues; education policy has therefore been not only contentious but confusing.

      This quote really makes me think about how education is such a battleground for values in America. It's frustrating how policymakers constantly shift directions, responding more to political winds than what actually works. There’s a profound disconnect between the stated values of equal opportunity and the reality of how education is implemented. School reforms that are supposed to help the most disadvantaged often get derailed, leaving the most vulnerable behind.

  4. Sep 2024
  5. inst-fs-iad-prod.inscloudgate.net inst-fs-iad-prod.inscloudgate.net
    1. Despite this consensus Americans disagree intensely about the education policies that will best help us achieve this dual goal.

      It's crazy how such marked disparities can persist despite widespread agreement on the value of education. This quote makes me think of how discussions about education sometimes center more around preserving privilege than promoting equal opportunity. Even while everyone says they support education, there seem to be gaps in the consensus when it comes to things like bilingual education, vouchers, and school finance. People seem to want school change, but only insofar as it serves their personal agendas.

    2. T HE AMERICAN DREAM IS A POWERFUL CONCEPT.

      The American Dream is a powerful concept, and I've discovered that it's inherently individualistic. It's all about accountability and self-actualization, but this doesn't truly address larger societal systems like systematic inequity. Believing that everyone has an equal chance of success is naïve, as access to opportunities is determined by several variables such as privilege, color, and class. Though inspiring, the dream lacks clarity if these obstacles aren't addressed.