40 Matching Annotations
  1. Jun 2023
    1. Conservatives see parking as liberals see health care—as a right, to be underwritten by the state

      Even though the political discussion when it comes to parking meters is mostly unheard of today, it's inclusion in the article draws the reader's attention to how parking and the costs of owning a car have changed over time. In general, I feel that this section of the article shows the effectiveness of incorporating historical events or records into an explanatory feature for the purpose of broadening a reader's perspective.

    2. rabar’s book, though smaller in the scope of its indictment, is more entertaining in the specificity of its indignation.

      This section continues the narrative once again with "Grabar's book" and the discussion about parking. This narrative style, in my opinion, is successful because it allows for cleaner transitions between sections, even if they are a bit abrupt at times.

    3. a ghetto of the wealthy.

      I like this description of the street as it effectively paints a clear picture in the minds of the reader in terms of what it looks like and the effect that pushing out people from their homes by raising prices has on communities. One connection that I can draw here is in the concept of gentrification, which pushes out lower class people from their neighborhoods.

    4. Knowles also blames expressways—he focusses on one that goes through Atlanta—for enforcing the segregation of American life, by separating suburbs and inner cities ever more aggressively

      "Aggressively" is an interesting descriptor here that shows the sort of visualization that the author wants to portray when it comes to the development of infrastructure for cars. I think that this description is effective because it makes it clear that the expressways create a large barrier between cities and suburbs, and more importantly, that barrier is constantly expanding.

  2. May 2023
    1. It’s how trips begin, and accidents happen. ♦

      This conclusion feels very well developed because of the storytelling aspect once again. I feel that this article as a whole shows a clear narrative and the importance of anecdotes in explanatory features in general.

    2. Rules got drawn up and were almost universally accepted—because the logic seemed impeccable and because no one goes to planning meetings to dispute such things except other planners.

      This is yet another example of a disadvantage of cars described by the author in terms of parking in major cities. I like the reference the author makes to the manual itself and its history.

    3. the dream of a driverless car can never be realized

      I think that the way the author positions Knowles and his beliefs makes him lose a lot of credibility in the eyes of the readers. I feel that it doesn't really help the claim made in the article's headline "How to quit cars" outside of showing that there exist people who see the flaws in relying heavily on cars.

    4. America has exported its car addiction to the developing world, where congestion, pollution, and destruction of the urban fabric are even worse than they are here. The swelling metropolises of emerging nations

      The syntax and vivid imagery used by the author in these lines is very effective in drawing the reader into the article further and also creating a better understanding of the disadvantages of cars as cities scale.

    5. or Knowles, cars are unredeemable instruments of evil. He is a writer for The Economist

      The feature article starts the next section by introducing a new character to the "story". I think that this choice of structure is successful because of how it creates a clear line between each section and also adds another layer to the article.

    6. the history of transportation tends to span half-century intervals, marking whole epochs in consciousness.

      This point made by the author is also very well placed, as it drives a lot of questions in the reader's mind about what the next wave of transportation will be, and the role transportation plays in the development of cities and civilization.

    7. he car is the consumer economy on wheels: atomizing, competitive, inhuman—and implicitly racist, hiving people off to segregated communities—while the subway and the train are communal zendos.

      The clear contrast that the writer draws in this sentence alone provides the reader with a lot more understanding of the issues with cars and the advantages of public transport.

    8. In Jack Kerouac’s “On the Road,” the car was the vehicle of liberty for the bohemian kids of those working-class Brooklynites. Allen Ginsberg’s “Howl”

      I think that these references in the second paragraph are a bit out of place because at this point the reader still does not really know the purpose of the article yet. Furthermore, the provided references and their explanations seem to only loosely link to the topic of reducing the use of cars and promoting public transport.

    9. “The Honeymooners” (1955-56), the greatest American television comedy

      This article chooses to lede the readers in by referencing a piece of media and creating a scene in the readers mind of what it is like to use public transportation. I think that this lede worked pretty effectively just because of the language.

    1. But at least Patti wasn’t murdered, at least Barbara hadn’t been robbed

      Interesting use of alliteration from the author, as it conveys to the reader the importance of valuing what you have and how dark the victim's situations actually are.

    2. A mural across the street from Tops, dedicated to the victims

      This image shows the impact that this event had on the local community, and how devastated it left both the victims and the people of that area. Once again, this image is placed well as it serves as a transition between the end of the "court room" scene and the next day.

    3. The shooter shuffled in, escorted by prison guards, his head facing the ground. The room was silent. Another victim’s family member, a woman in pink, pulled her shirt over her mouth, and began nodding vigorously, as if she were trying to shake him from her vision.

      Once again, the author uses some vivid imagery and detail in order to paint a clear picture of the story and "set the scene" in the courtroom. The quality of story-telling of this article in general seems to stem from the specific moments and details that are covered and the in depth analysis that the author provides.

    4. He was still waiting at the start of November to learn whether Gov. Kathy Hochul would enact Bill S74A, or the Grieving Families Act. Among other things, the legislation would allow emotional distress to be considered as part of a judgment in a wrongful-death lawsuit.

      The article refers to an actual bill that is in the process of possibly becoming legislation, a source that I feel is of questionable relevance to the rest of the story. The insertion about Barbara being "recompensated" through the efforts of a lawyer feels forced.

    5. “And don’t none of you be wimps either!!”

      Something as personal as a letter being quoted within the article further develops the connection that the story has to the reader. It also helps paint a much better picture of what Katherine Massey was like to the readers of the article as well.

    6. A few weeks earlier, Barbara received a phone call from an F.B.I. agent

      I feel that the article layout, in this case, is driven entirely by the major events and news that was released, and although the entire article is not fully chronological, the author still manages to create a logical flow in the article.

    7. Katherine Massey’s funeral at Pilgrim Missionary Baptist Church in Buffalo on May 23, 2022.Credit...Hiroko Masuike/The New York Times

      This image and the others like it make the story much more real to the reader and brings the people described in writing to life in a way. Furthermore, the placement of the image is well placed, as it follows a section where Warren recounts things about Katherine Massey.

    8. arbara told me at a restaurant the first time we met, eight weeks after her sister was murdered

      The fact that the author actually met with and went to Barbara in person provides some credibility to her accounts of what happened and the story itself. I think that the concept of journalists actually going out and gathering a story is very compelling.

    9. She revisited the worst day of her life over and over and over again, in conversation with the F.B.I., the Justice Department, the state and federal attorneys general, the district attorney, local politicians, the press.

      The section above this makes a clear contribution to the narrative of what Barbara had to go through. Furthermore, the way that the author describes the process after Kat was killed allows the reader to better empathize with Barbara's situation.

    10. Her sister, Katherine Massey, was one of 10 people murdered by a 19-year-old white supremacist in a Buffalo shooting last spring. He spent months plotting the massacre, researching nearby towns with the largest Black populations, then neighborhoods with the highest concentration of Black residents.

      The lede connects clearly to what the story wants to discuss, and what event/narrative is driving the story forward. This section that is after the lede also leads into the problem that the article wants to draw attention to (the state of racism and white supremacists in the United States).

    11. When the lawyers called to ask Barbara if she wanted to attend, for the very first time, she declined. Today, she said, was the best she had felt since the day before Kat died.So she didn’t really want to see him, no. She needed a break.

      The concluding statement for this article actually also serves as a resolution for Barbara, in a way, due to how it shows Barbara feeling better and starting to recover from her loss. This also is a stark contrast with the introduction, where Barbara's thoughts were outlined as very violent and troubled. I think that the contrast between the intro and conclusion is what makes it effective.

    12. If Barbara Massey-Mapps had her way, she would kill the man who murdered her sister herself. Her desire is neither secret nor shameful — she’ll tell anybody who asks.

      The lede of the article successfully uses the "shock factor" of Barbara Massey-Mapps' story and paints a clear picture of her emotional state after the tragic murder of her sister. This option for a lede might be one that I use because it is very effective at quickly piquing the reader's interest in the artlcle without revealing too much or "spoiling" it.

    13. Listen to This ArticleAudio Recording by Audm

      This article offers the option to listen to it rather than read, which is something that I feel can be a very useful tool in getting people more interested in reading an article. Most of the time, people might not have time to read and understand it, and its easier to listen to it while they are doing something else.

  3. Apr 2023
    1. But the area in the Indian Ocean is different and could be a coincidental independent increase or somehow connected to what may be a big El Nino, he said.

      I feel like the speculation about the warming in the Indian Ocean is underdeveloped, and although I understand that most readers don't have a very long attention span, I feel that a better analysis of all topics introduced is necessary to maintain the flow of a paragraph or section.

    2. El Nino is the natural warming of parts of the equatorial Pacific that changes weather worldwide and spikes global temperatures

      The author defines terms or jargon that are used throughout the article and are absolutely necessary to include. I think that this is useful when writing to a public audience in general, since you aren't always going to be able to omit all "technical" aspects of the field you write about.

    3. It’s about 30 to 40 zettajoules of heat, which is the energy equivalent of hundreds of millions of atomic bombs the size that leveled Hiroshima

      A very good line that the author incorporated in this section because it puts some vivid imagery into the mind of the reader, allowing a better conceptualization of exactly how much energy is found in the recent ocean heat increase.

    4. It’s been about seven years since the last El Nino, and it was a whopper.

      In my opinion, the choice of informal language by the author scattered throughout the article is nothing more than distracting. It feels as though the article either contains direct quotations from various sources or a sub-par analysis of the situation by the author.

    5. He found a long stretch across the equator from South America to Africa, including both the Pacific and Indian oceans, responsible for much of the global temperature spike.

      The author effectively summarizes the findings of the University of Colorado team and applies it to the context of the article itself. Since the actual source may contain a lot of surrounding information may not be relevant.

    6. 1 of 2FILE - The sun rises above the Atlantic Ocean as waves crash near beach goers walking along a jetty, Dec. 7, 2022, in Bal Harbour, Fla. The world's oceans have suddenly spiked much hotter and well above record levels, with scientists trying to figure out what it means and whether it forecasts a surge in atmospheric warming. (AP Photo/Wilfredo Lee, File)

      The visuals for this article don't contribute much to the actual story and mostly just plays a role in improving the aesthetics of the article. I think that having some other visuals to convey the impact of increasing ocean temperatures would add a lot to the article.

    7. Princeton University climate scientist Gabe Vecchi. “That is a huge, huge signal. I think it’s going to take some level of effort to understand it.”

      The author uses a very large quantity of sources from experts and researchers, at a much higher frequency than most "explanatory features".

    8. Some researchers think the jump in sea surface temperatures stems from a brewing and possibly strong natural El Nino warming weather condition plus a rebound from three years of a cooling La Nina, all on top of steady global warming that is heating deeper water below.

      This paragraph serves as the lede as it provides a sense of urgency and the possibility of future increases in heat due to global warming.

    9. Some, like University of Pennsylvania’s Michael Mann, quickly dismiss concerns by saying it is merely a growing El Nino on top of a steady human-caused warming increase

      Acknowledging a counter argument in this section of the passage provides more context to the claims that the author is making. However, I feel that it offers very little for the readers because the author does not really address the argument made by "University of Pennsylvania’s Michael Mann".

    10. If that’s the case, they said, record-breaking ocean temperatures this month could be the first in many heat records to shatter.

      The author once again pushes the point about why this article should matter to the general public, and draws attention to the potential for the issue to worsen.

    11. That may sound small, but for the average of the world’s oceans — which is 71% of Earth’s area —to rise so much in that short a time, “that’s huge,” said University of Colorado climate scientist Kris Karnauskas.

      The author does a good job in providing context for the large numbers of facts and figures that are thrown around in this paragraph. I think that the author also uses expert opinions very rigorously and as a result makes the claims of the article feel more factual to the reader.

    12. Karnauskas said what’s likely to happen will be an “acceleration” of warming after the heat has been hidden for a few years.

      The concluding sentence of the article does a good job in raising questions about the future of global warming. However, it feels rather abrupt as the author of the article does not provide more context to the expert's statement, and it feels very cherry-picked.

    13. The world’s oceans have suddenly spiked much hotter and well above record levels in the last few weeks, with scientists trying to figure out what it means and whether it forecasts a surge in atmospheric warming.

      The author introduces the article in a very direct manner and draws the reader in with a shocking fact about the temperature in the oceans in recent years. However, I would have preferred something more quantifiable as "much hotter" is a bit of a poor descriptor.

  4. Oct 2022

    Annotators