25 Matching Annotations
  1. Oct 2017
    1. You may not use all of them for a single project, becau~e each mode has its own strengths and weaknesses in specific situa-tions-just clS a wrench is more useful in fixing a faucet than a ham-mer is.

      The key to using the modes is to think logically on how you want an idea to come across. You have to think on a case by case basis for what would be the most effective strategies to accomplish a goal. Gaining attention can easily be done by sensory cues: auditory and visual, which can then by followed up with a combination of the other modes as well as the previous two to spread an idea.

    2. The linguistic mode often affords readers specificity, exactness, and logical connections, but this can slow readers down as they work to make sense of the information. The visual mode, on the other hand, often can't be as detailed.

      The best way to provide information of this type and scale would be to apply a combination of the modes more evenly as shown in the map. By combining the geography and locations of the map with the numerical information from the chart, a better sense of scale is created. Visually, a striking image is shown of the lands affected by the Works Progress Administration as well as how population could be centered, with larger populations receiving more government assistance. Linguistically, while less numerical values are shown, they are reflected in the color coding of the map area to area, which shows greater relations, instead of general, overall totals, which do not reflect the dispersion of the WPA's assistance programs.

    3. At other times, words may work better than images when we arc trying to explain an idea because words can be more descriptive and to the point. It may take too many pictures to convey the same idea quickly

      Relating it back to our lit class, this is the whole point of Primary Source Descriptions. The source descriptions not only give a physical description of what can be seen in a picture, but they also provide further insight to the physicality of an object that cannot be determined solely through images, such as textures, and descriptions of colors that don't always appear accurately in digital images. The descriptions that accompany images in primary source descriptions can also provide context by including other related documents that give the object a more clear depiction to how it fits in place and time.

    4. The spatial mode can also refer to the placement of navigation on a Web page to maximize access for users

      The arrangement of a website is crucial to keep users coming back to it. If a user interface is clunky and difficult to use, then what could have been potential returning users could easily never return, instead, turning to other sites that do essentially the same thing but with better UI. If a website has many pages that could be linked and organized together, but has no tabs or other layouts to arrange this, it likely won't have as many users as one that does. Similarly, having a layout too close-knit can be an issue; writing, be it on a webpage or an essay that doesn't separate ideas with effective means (such as paragraphs), will not have the same traction as one that does.

    5. but what about the increas-ingly tense background music in a lV drama, or the sounds that let us know when a computer is starling up?

      Sound is a necessity to the success of any film or show. Soundtracks provide an atmosphere to the feeling a film is trying to give off. With a shift in soundtrack (as well as some visual changes), the animated kid's movie Frozen can become a dark scene of horror https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9eD2UpdhbwA Sound is another strong psychological trigger, that can cause reactions anywhere from joy and elated moods, to lowered heart rates and relaxation, to anxiety and fear. For example, the song Weightless by Marconi Union https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UfcAVejslrU was created with the intention to relax listeners, and was found by neuroscientists to effectively accomplish just that (https://health.good.is/articles/relaxing-song-ever-recorded-stress)

    6. These Twitter prolilcs (Figs. 1. 7 and 1.8) have a lot of words (the linguistic mode), but their visual mode-the colors, layout, prolilc pictures, and logo-plays a big role in how users read and under-stand each page.

      The visual mode seems to be essentially the most important of the five modes in today's society. To most, appearance is everything; with news sites needing viewership to generate income, sensational titles that don't always reflect the article accurately are highly demanded. If someone is scrolling through a site and doesn't see an article that interests them, then they aren't likely to click on anything. Not only online, visuals are key to many productions for film and art. Mental cues can be triggered simply from colors, but can also be more direct with present images. For example, the pussyhats worn during the Women's march were pink, a color specifically chosen as it is viewed as a color of the weak by society, a color that is feminine. The hat, rather than promote the color as weak, sought to represent it as a powerful color, a sign of women's strength.

      https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/pink-pussyhat-creator-addresses-criticism-over-name-n717886

    7. his ~ choice of words-"small people" -infuriated the public because it • demeaned those impacted by the spill

      No matter how well intended a cause is, there will always be those who are offended by positive attempts to solve a problem. With this, it was the phrase "small people" that caused audiences to find issue with his actions. While this not only detracts from his point, Carl-Henric Svanberg's message is completely derailed by these grievances. Similarly, while the pussyhat was meant as a symbol of femininity used to unite, critics took it to be a sign of transphobia and in a much farther leap racism. The critics took the initial point of the hat, and turned it against itself, creating negativity towards an object solely meant for awareness and unity.

      https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/pink-pussyhat-creator-addresses-criticism-over-name-n717886

    8. all of the mode-. at play in a simple TV

      I feel like the idea of the pussyhat fits in well here. Not only was the pussyhat multimodal, but it could also be used to amplify the multimodality of the Women's march it was used in. While the Women's march was most certainly spacial, taking up large spaces with the numbers in attendance, it was also visually striking with those present, particularly so with the flashes of color from these pussyhats.

      https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/pink-pussyhat-creator-addresses-criticism-over-name-n717886

    9. The spatial mode is about physical arrangement.

      This section provides further explanation for the earlier assertion that writing alone can be multimodal. I feel like that section, however would be much better placed around this section of the text. Logically, it fits better as a sidenote here, where it can be referenced easily to the text as opposed to at the beginning where no supporting material can be found.

    10. The supplemental text I chose was the NBC article "Pink ‘Pussyhat’ Creator Addresses Criticism Over Name". The article goes over an explanation of what the pussyhat is: a hat worn at the various Women's Marches that occurred in January, created by wearers to promote feminism, then goes on to describe a controversy involving how people viewed the hats as transphobic and in some cases racist. The article continues by provide the creator of the pussyhats' reaction to this, with her feeling that none of the perceived issues were intentional, and explaining her reasoning for the specific issues. I feel that this text relates to the main text due to its dealings with the hat itself being multimodal. The creator Krista Suh stated in the article the name of the hat's significance,“I think ‘pussy’ refers to the female anatomical part, but it’s also a word that’s used to shame people who are feminine … whether they are men, women [or] genderqueer. And I think what it comes down to is that femininity is really disrespected in our society.” Along with the name, the color is also used to represent this femininity, with pink typically being seen as a weak color by society.

    11. The answer is yes! Let's take Figure 1.2 as an example. It might seem that an audi-ence could understand this text's argu. ment just by reading the written words. In fact, to understand the full message being communicated in the text, the audience has to make sense of other elements as well. They must also look at the images and read the captions that explain what the images contain. The format of the text-a single column of black printed words on a white background, with a margin on either side-also tells the audi-ence something important: that this text Is probably an academic work of some kind . (In fact, it's a page from fenny's disserta-tion.) Knowing what kind or text it is will influence the way the audience reads it.

      This section is confusing and somewhat conflicts the section of the text it is in and personally, I find that it detracts from writers' ethos. In the surrounding text, the multimodal examples provided all clearly incorporate distinct modes of communication, while describing solely writing as multimodal stretches this schema. The explanation for this is that the lack of images combined with the readers view of the columns of words act as an image because from this, the work can be determined to be academic in nature. I feel like this isn't a valid argument, however, due to the basis of it is that the lack of images as a second mode acts as an image in itself. It provides an argument that isn't overly clear or persuasive.

  2. Sep 2017
  3. spring2018.robinwharton.net spring2018.robinwharton.net
    1. Analysis should digest, develop, and present per-ceptions generated from these exercises, but differ from them in being struc-tured by an argument, a clearly-worded claim

      Without an argument to carry through after analysis, the analysis is not overly useful; it just becomes information and ideas floating by. The need for argument is necessary for it to be brought to others' attention. Argument leads others to similar thoughts, whether for or against, but nonetheless, these thoughts shed light on a particular idea.

    2. a world which, in some sense, metonymically, it represents.

      Upon searching for why an object is viewed in a specific cultural setting, we can see how in interacts with and is acted on by its setting. This gives not only a better understanding of the object, but also a better understanding of the culture and its people. This is key in archaeological fields, because to understand a civilization previously unknown of, one must examine the tools and technologies that were available to that civilization.

    3. Specifically, what in or about the object brings those feel-ings out?

      Introspection is the key to understanding and and viewing something for what it really is. As you become aware of why you feel a certain way, you can chose whether or not it was a fair or unfair judgement, and whether or not to continue to act out based on that feeling. This inner thinking provides a truthful look upon an object or being for us as viewers to gain a better understanding of.

    4. only thus can we control for our own-however well-intended-careless or precipitous or culturally-biased leaps to arguably wrong conclusions.

      Before even considering other possibilities, many chose instead to make assumptions about what they see. This lack of reflection is the cause of much strife in the world, from the automatic confrontation and arrest of Jason Wilson for his carrying of his machete, which was perceived as a dangerous weapon, to the widespread issues of racism and xenophobia experience by many in the country. (https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/10/what-is-a-machete-anyway/280705/)

    5. Elucidate

      "to provide clarification; explain." ex. I elucidated this word to clear up any confusion.

      (http://www.dictionary.com/browse/elucidate)

    6. pedagogic

      In simple terms, pedagogic just means related to teaching. So this "pedagogic sampler" is a useful set of teaching examples for the "practical approach to understanding things".

    7. Thoroughly describe this object, paying careful attention, as rele-vant, to all of its aspects-material, spatial, and temporal.

      Part of Prownian analysis, as displayed here, is to break down an object to all of its most literal physical characteristics.

    8. All objects signify; some signify more expressively than others.

      I feel like the AIDS quilt is meant to express this. Both are major topics to the class, and as such I feel like they go hand in hand. The quilt, at first look is just a quilt, but when inspected, it clearly depicts those affected and the aftermath of AIDS.

    9. cultural significance; attention not just to what they might be said to signify but, as importantly, to how they might be said to signify; to their gerundial meaning

      Do to a history of bloodshed and brutality, the machete has been transformed in the minds of many from a simple utilitarian tool into a much more sinister symbol of violence. (https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/10/what-is-a-machete-anyway/280705/)

    10. Prownian analysis

      Essentially, Prownian analysis refers to an object in such a way that it becomes more of a concept. So the essays mentioned express exactly this: using object to define large scale ideas.

    11. Jules David Prown

      Jules Prown is a Professor Emeritus of Art History at Yale University. He developed Prownian analysis, a method of "identifying, and examining objects through detailed physical description, guessing at uses of the object, and treating the object as a fiction as a way of relating the object to more broad concepts." (https://gregcotter.wordpress.com/prownian-analysis-2/)

    12. "The supplemental text is chose was The Atlantic article "What Is a Machete, Anyway?". In this article it is discussed that due to cultural actions around the machete, it was transformed from its original use as a farming and utility tool, into a symbol of violence and brutality. During numerous slave revolts as well as murders during the Rwandan Genocide the machete became a source of fear; in the hands of those using them for violence, those who witnessed these uses were conditioned to view a tool for cutting sugar cane as a weapon for cutting down others.

    1. "Ideas are what matter," Bernadette said confidently. "Getting them to define and handle ideas is what's important, not things."

      This serves as an antithesis to the article. What the author is saying is that the specifics of ideas truly do matter. While abstract ideas are important, there is an ever-present inability to ground these ideas into a usable form.

    1. Due to cultural actions around the machete, from its original use as a farming and utility tool, to a weapon used to carry out slave revolts as well as murder during the Rwandan Genocide, it has become a symbol of violence and brutality rather simple a simple tool.