eLife assessment

This study presents valuable findings on the changes of immune cell populations and stromal cells occurring at the CNS borders in a neonatal bacterial meningitis model, focusing on fibroblasts, macrophages and endothelial cells. The study provides solid snRNA-seq dataset and high quality immune fluorescence images of dissected brain border regions, that will be useful for the community. These observations and datasets will be of interest to the neuro-immunology community.

eLife assessment

This study represents a valuable body of work in which the authors assemble a molecular description of colorectal cancer and classification into subtypes. Overall, the evidence supporting the findings is solid and could be improved with more detail. Consensus over a diverse range of data from publicly available sources is convincing. When added to existing knowledge this work may contribute to future biomarker discoveries for colorectal cancer.

eLife assessment

This important study advances our understanding of the metabolic and hemodynamic underpinnings of different brain networks. The evidence is convincing, drawn from multiple datasets and including simultaneous fMRI and PET, although the authors should make clear which claims are supported by their evidence and which are speculation based on the literature. The study will be of interest to neuroscientists and researchers who use functional neuroimaging tools to study brain activity.

eLife assessment

This study presents useful information on the environmental and epigenomic associations of obesity in children and adolescents. The data were collected and analyzed using a solid and validated methodology and can be referenced at the clinics and health authorities to make a guideline and a policy strategy.

eLife assessment

This manuscript presents an exciting set of experiments on the mechanisms through which PSD proteins induce actin bundle formation. The work included deep mechanistic analyses which determine the necessity of upper vs. lower levels of PSD proteins for actin bundle formation, identify the domains and interactions of these proteins that are necessary and sufficient to induce actin bundles, and provide a first assessment in neurons of potential roles of the newly discovered mechanisms.

eLife assessment

This paper presents a valuable cross-validation study of mesoscopic measurements of axonal orientations from three different modalities: x-ray tomography, scattered light imaging, and diffusion MRI. The authors show convincing similarities and differences in fibre orientations from all three methods over partial ex vivo brain samples, though as only a single diffusion method is investigated, there is inadequate evidence to support conclusions about diffusion MRI reconstruction methods in general. As a first example of work comparing these three modalities, it is of interest to researchers who want to apply x-ray tomography or scattered light imaging to image the white matter ex vivo or use these methods for future validation of diffusion MRI methods.

eLife assessment

This study has important implications for the impact of sexual conflict on population viability under different temperatures. The authors propose that male harm to females in sexual conflict can be reduced as a function of temperature within the optimal reproductive range of a species. The evidence for this proposal is currently incomplete because there is methodological detail that needs to be further clarified. The results could have implications for the likelihood of the evolutionary rescue of species facing the climate crisis.

eLife assessment

The authors use computational modeling of the mammalian visual system to address an important and understudied problem: how precise temporal properties of synaptic transmission might impact the kinds of neuronal correlations that instruct development. The present description of the simulations provides mixed evidence for the authors' conclusions. That slow NMDA currents help to minimize rapid timescale correlations is compelling, but other aspects of the simulations, such as neuronal heterogeneity may also contribute.

eLife assessment

In this important study, the authors generate and analyse single-cell datasets for the human parasitic nematode Brugia malayi. The new resource has the potential to uncover new details of the biology of secretory systems in this filarial nematode but the main claims are only partially supported and strengthening them would require additional experimental support and new analyses. With the methodological part strengthened, the new resource would be of broad interest to parasitologists and nematode biologists and would have the potential to accelerate research in the search of new anthelmintics and vaccines.

eLife assessment

We believe this study has the potential to be fundamental for the field of microbial communication and compelling evidence with the chance of changing the current state-of-the-art in this area has been presented. This is will be of natural interest to the field of parasitology, but scientists in the general area of cell-to-cell communication will certainly benefit from this contribution too. A major strength of this manuscript is the clear demonstration of the role of cytoneme-like structures and extracellular vesicles in parasite communication using the Trichomonas vaginalis model. Given the potential of these findings, the authors could deepen their discussion and perspectives for other areas.

eLife assessment

This study reports a cutting-edge set of experiments examining evolutionary models of paralog function differentiation for the mammalian ribosomal proteins eS27 and eS27L. No differentiated roles were identified for either paralog, but the paralogs are differentially expressed, and they preferentially associate with different transcript classes. Reciprocal switching of their coding sequences yielded no detectable phenotypes, but loss of either paralog resulted in lethality at different developmental stages, suggesting that subfunctionalized expression patterns underlie the retention of these paralogs. The work will be of interest to colleagues studying the evolution and diversification of ribosomes.

eLife assessment

The authors show that tunneling nanotubes or TNTs are used by cells to transfer full-length mRNAs. The data show that as much as 1% of the endogenous mRNA are passed between cells by this procedure. The transferred mRNA affect the transcriptome of the acceptor cells thus highlighting the significance of this nanotube mediated trafficking of mRNA between cells. We appreciate the difficulty of this exercise. The strength of the presented evidence could be questioned based on technical limitations.

eLife assessment

After mating, animals show a repertoire of behavioural changes. In flies, this includes an increase in egg-laying, salt, and food (particularly protein) consumption, and a concomitant decrease in sexual receptivity. This valuable study compellingly shows that flies also have an increased sugar appetite and they identify the central brain circuitry that controls this increase in the mated condition.

eLife assessment

The large genetic association studies conducted in East Africa have shown that the Dantu blood group provides substantial protection against severe malaria since it increases the surface tension of red blood cells making it harder for malaria parasites to invade. In this important work, the authors show that parasite growth is indeed restricted in vivo by testing this hypothesis in adult Kenyan volunteers infected with P. falciparium under careful monitoring. They were able to show convincingly that indeed, parasite growth was reduced amongst Dantu adults.

eLife assessment

Seelbinder et al. describe a new method for perturbing chromatin in living cells by local heating. Employing this approach, the authors uncover interesting behaviors that underscore the variability in the mechanical response of subnuclear domains and structures. The study is timely, and if some conceptual and technical aspects are improved, it should be of broad interest to both the cell biophysics and cell biology communities, in particular since the method can also be applied to study mechanical relationships of subcellular compartments in other cellular and multicellular systems.

eLife assessment

This study presents a useful inventory of chromatin modifications and genes that are up- and down-regulated during cerebellar development in vivo and in primary culture. The main claims were incomplete and would benefit from further analysis and/or additional experiments. The work will be of interest to biologists working on brain development.

eLife assessment

This study presents important findings regarding the quantification of dynamics in fish communities in changing ecosystems by combining a large-scale environmental DNA metabarcoding time series with novel statistical approaches. The methods are convincing, with controlled experiments, thorough statistical analyses, and a substantial dataset covering two years of detailed observation, which can provide sufficient power to detect fine-scale ecological interactions. This work is relevant for informing future research on assessing community stability under climate change.

eLife assessment

The authors use a combination of structural and MD simulation approaches to characterize phospholipid interactions with the pentameric ligand-gated ion channel, GLIC. The general agreement between structures and simulations increases confidence in the description of the lipid interaction poses, and provides a solid basis for the prediction of a state dependent interaction site where lipids could dynamically modulate channel gating. The results will be very useful to understand the nature of phospholipid interactions with pentameric ligand-gated ion channels, although the functional or structural significance of these lipid interactions remains unclear.

eLife assessment

This interesting study builds on previous work by the PI implicating Greatwall/MASTLKinase in recovery from DNA damage in cultured human cells. This study identifies a ubiquitin ligase that may regulate the stability of Greatwall/MASTL protein stability, and the authors propose that this constitutes a molecular "timer" that controls recovery from DNA damage. Should this be validated it would be an important advance for the field, but the data presented are currently incomplete and do not yet fully support this claim.

eLife assessment

The authors have uncovered a new target that may be exploited to selectively kill BRCA2 mutant cancer cells. Strengths of the study include the novel pathway uncovered (ROCK kinases) and the strong data in support of the findings. Weaknesses include limited detail regarding the mechanism of BRCA2-specific cell death by ROCK kinase inhibitors, limited information on why some ROCK kinase inhibitors are not effective, as well as whether the cell killing in BRCA2 wild-type cells by ROCK kinase inhibitors is the same mechanism but just attenuated. The work will be of interest to cancer biologists and colleagues studying kinases.

eLife assessment

This manuscript is of interest to readers in the field of neural development. The study is important as it examines two mutations within a homeodomain transcription factor called Cone-Rod Homeobox (CRX) that cause retinopathy in humans. The data are solid, and the work contributes to our understanding of the underlying pathogenetic mechanisms.

eLife assessment

This study combines experiments in developing embryos and embryo extracts to investigate a fundamental relationship in biology - how the size of mitotic chromosomes scales with changes in cell size during development. By combining the unique tools available in the Xenopus system with modern genomic approaches, the authors convincingly demonstrate that mitotic chromosome scaling is mediated by differential loading of maternal chromatin remodeling factors during interphase. Although it remains unclear exactly how these factors impact chromosome size, the findings reported here will be of broad interest to the cell biology community and are likely to spawn new avenues of experimental inquiry aimed at understanding intracellular scaling relationships.

eLife assessment

This study provides important estimates from international cancer screening data repository about the impact of the COVID-pandemic related disruptions on cancer screening programs in selected low- and middle-income countries. The evidence supporting the study is solid and relies on national-level screening program attendee volumes and assessments of screen positives during 2019 (pre-pandemic) and 2020 (during the pandemic). The study provides real-world data estimates of proportions/volumes of missed screenings due to pandemic control measures (lockdowns and closures) and may contribute to future modelling efforts for measuring the impact on late/advanced stage detection and excess case burden and mortality.

eLife assessment

This paper addresses an important clinical concern which is how the antidepressant ketamine exerts its effects acts rapidly. The authors suggest the reason is that ketamine increases glutamatergic transmission in the hippocampus. The strengths are the data are mostly very good, and the limitations are a lack of compelling evidence that the hippocampus is the location where effects occur, as well as several other issues.

eLife assessment

This important study will be of interest to those working on mycobacterial signal transduction. A combination of experiments provides convincing evidence to show how universal stress proteins bind to cAMP and function by direct sequestration of the second messenger. Although the methods, data and analyses broadly support the conclusions, the main claims are only partially supported and can be strengthened through further analytic approaches.

eLife assessment

Villalobos-Cantor et. al. describe a new technique for cell-type specific in vivo labeling of nascent peptides, which they call POPPi. POPPi is based on sequence-independent incorporation of the puromycin analog OPP into an elongating peptide, which also simultaneously terminates the growing peptide. To achieve cell-type-specific labeling, the authors used an OPP derivative, PhAc-OPP, as the labeling substrate. The method is potentially interesting but needs further characterization to be able to assess its use.

eLife assessment

This important study combines a screen of known N6-methyladenine (m6A)-dependent RNA modifying factors to identify ALKBH5 as critical in crush injury response. They demonstrate through gain and loss of function an effect on ALKBH5 m6A-dependent Lpin2 mRNA stability during injury-induced axon regeneration in both dorsal root ganglia nerve and optic nerve regeneration. The results provide new insight into the role of RNA modification on neural injury. However, the limitations of the experimental design on the conclusions drawn require additional consideration. With additional control experiments and further consideration of the limitations, the paper will provide a link between N6-methyladenine and neurotrauma.

eLife assessment

This study describes important results and convincing evidence linking myofibroblast senescence in the aged heart with a pro-arrhythmogenic phenotype. This is in turn related to higher mortality after myocardial infarction in the aged rabbit heart. These constitute important empiric as opposed to detailed findings. They nevertheless will be of interest to clinician scientists studying cardiac function and disease.

eLife assessment

Non-communicable diseases (NCDs) are rising rapidly in urbanizing populations in many parts of the developing world, including in sub-Saharan Africa. Temba and colleagues show important evidence that healthy Tanzanians display a pro-inflammatory phenotype with enrichment of specific immune-metabolic pathways. Dood-derived metabolites were identified as an important driver of inflammation-related molecules. These findings provide solid evidence that the dietary transition that occurs in urbanizing areas in sub-Saharan Africa may contribute significantly to the increased incidence of non communicable diseases in this part of the world.

eLife assessment

This important interdisciplinary study substantially advances our understanding of the prolactin receptor interactions with the membrane lipids and the effect of these interactions on cell signaling. The authors use a combination of state-of-the-art NMR structural analysis, simulations, and cellular assays to provide compelling experimental evidence for protein complexes being regulated by IDR-membrane interactions. The work will be of broad interest to structural biologists and biochemists, and the results presented herein are likely relevant for other non-tyrosine kinase receptors.

eLife assessment

This important study demonstrates that the transcription factor Chinmo is a master regulator that maintains larval growth and development as part of the metamorphic gene network in Drosophila. Chinmo does so in part by regulating Broad expression in imaginal tissues (exemplified in the wing disc) and in a Broad-independent manner in other larval tissues such as the salivary gland. Finally, they demonstrate that the role of Chinmo in promoting larval development is conserved between holometabolous insects and hemimetabolous insects, which lack a pupal stage. The data were collected and analyzed using solid and validated methodology and will be of interest to a broad audience including those interested in development and evolution.

eLife assessment

Using surface micropatterning, optical activation, and theoretical analysis, the authors provide compelling evidence that adjacent cells actively propagate mechanical stress in epithelial tissues. The response of the receiver cell is active and enhanced when the principal stress direction is perpendicular to the orientation of actin fibers. This work is important and a must-read for everybody wanting to understand tissue mechanics.

eLife assessment<br /> <br /> This is an important study that uses the song system in a bird model to understand the transcriptional mechanisms underlying neuronal adaptations to sensory deprivation. The manuscript offers compelling data in support of their hypothesis that these transcriptional changes are related to song plasticity. The work will be of interest to biologists who study neuronal plasticity mechanisms.

eLife assessment

Inferior olivary neurons drive complex spiking activity in Purkinje neurons of the cerebellar cortex, ultimately playing critical roles in controlling motor coordination and plasticity. Using transgenic mice or optogenetic techniques to independently control a major excitatory and inhibitory pathway to the inferior olive, the authors show that the probability and phase of olivary neuron output depend critically on the relative timing of excitation and inhibitory inputs. Network models predict that appropriately timed excitatory and inhibitory input patterns efficiently synchronize larger clusters of inferior olivary neurons, raising the possibility that input timing can gate the output of the motor commands. These valuable findings have the potential to impact the field's understanding of sensorimotor processing, but the strength of evidence is currently incomplete.

eLife assessment

The study provides evidence that the hormone PTH increases bone mass by, at least in part, regulating the factor Zfp467. In turn, Zfp67 controls expression of the receptor for PTH, thus creating a feedback loop that overall augments bone mass. The findings are novel and of potential great interest. Overall, the study is of interest to a broad audience and significant as it unveils a novel feedback loop involving PTH, a critical endocrine regulator of calcium, phosphate, and bone mass.

eLife assessment

This paper describes a new method to investigate Staphylococcus aureus intracellular virulence that has produced important insights into the mechanisms of staphylococcal pathogenesis. The results are convincing and the methodology is state-of-the-art. This paper will be of interest to scientists studying microbial intracellular pathogenesis and cell biology.

eLife assessment

This paper demonstrates the genetic architecture of heart mitochondrial proteome that influences cardiac hypertrophy, using a panel of inbred mouse strains called the Hybrid Mouse Diversity Panel (HMDP). The HDM panel is a very powerful tool to study the genetic basis of various physiological and pathological processes in mice. The authors have used this panel extensively before, and in this paper, they extend their proteomic studies to demonstrate the genetic basis of cardiac hypertrophy. The studies will allow us to better understand the genetics of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy.

eLife assessment

This important study greatly expands our knowledge of the fossil record of Mermithid nematodes, modern members of which are ecologically important parasitoids of arthropods, annelids and mollusks today. The most important finding, convincingly presented, is that mermithids parasitized a number of insect clades in the Cretaceous that they are not known to infect today or in Cenozoic amber. The evidence for a shift in exploited hosts from heterometabolous insects in the Cretaceous to holometabolous ones in the Miocene is solid but could be made exceptional by adding a small quantitative analysis with confidence intervals and bar plots from the data already compiled in the supplementary material; potential collection bias should be addressed as well.

eLife assessment

This fundamental work uses deep neural networks to simulate activity evoked by a wide range of stimuli and demonstrates systematic differences in latent population representations between hearing-impaired and normal-hearing animals that are consistent with impaired representations of speech in noise. While the evidence supporting the conclusions is compelling, additional analyses would facilitate the generalizability of the neural-network approach. The research will be of interest to auditory neuroscientists and computational scientists.

eLife assessment

This manuscript provides valuable data gathered using a new video fluoroscopy method by which movements of artificial joints can be visualized in real time. These solid data add to the understanding of the links between symptoms of unstable joints after total knee replacement and actual joint instability. The paper should be of interest to those who study biomechanics after total joint replacement.

eLife assessment

In this study, Li and al describe valuable insights into the mechanisms underlying sex-differences diet-induced obesity in mice, with a role of macrophage-derived RELMa secretion in female-specific protection. They provide solid evidence for the impact of RELMa signaling in eosinophil recruitment for diet-induced obesity protection in female mice. Single-cell RNA-seq analysis of the stromal vascular fraction of control and RELMa deficient animals methods were used to investigate molecular mechanisms underlying the protection as a powerful method, although the analysis of this data is difficult to evaluate with incomplete methodological information.

eLife assessment

In vertebrates, ciliary motility is powered by axonemal dyneins, known as OADs, tethered to doublet microtubules by a pentameric docking complex including the Armc4 and Calaxin subunits. This valuable study combines zebrafish genetics with cryo-electron tomography to convincingly show that Armc4 plays a critical role in the docking of OAD and that Calaxin stabilizes the molecular interaction. The work will be of interest to those studying the structure and function of the axoneme, and motile cilia in general.

eLife assessment

This important study combines behavior, computational modelling and magnetic resonance spectroscopy to address the question whether age-related declines in learning are driven by declines in working memory or deficiencies of the RL system. The general approach is solid, but the presented evidence to support the papers' main claims could be stronger. With additional analyses and adaptation of the main claims, the paper could be of high interest for researchers in the field of cognitive aging and decision making.

eLife assessment

The authors present a manuscript aiming to understand the mechanism(s) underlying myeloid bias in HSCs, specifically focused on the role of Pcgf1, and therefore PRC1.1, in the regulation of hematopoiesis. This important work is of interest to the community of researchers interested in myeloid differentiation, lineage fate decisions in hematopoietic stem cells, and the molecular mechanisms that contribute to the initiation of myeloid malignancies. The methods are rigorous and the results convincingly support the authors' conclusions.

eLife assessment

This is a valuable paper describing an attempt to reconstruct the evolution of Dicer. Using ancestral reconstruction approaches, the authors carefully examine the biochemical characteristics of reconstructed proteins at various junction points in the animal lineage. They provide solid evidence that the deepest ancestrally reconstructed protein has double-stranded RNA stimulated ATPase activity and that this characteristic was lost along the vertebrate lineage. This paper will be of interest to scientists in the RNA-protein interaction and protein evolution fields.

eLife assessment

The authors have established new formulas to predict maximum oxygen uptake for cyclists and runners based on submaximal exercise testing and anthropometric characteristics. This is an important study with a large and comprehensive dataset, which may be helpful for many exercise labs. The work is convincing, using appropriate and validated methodology in line with the current state-of-the-art, as shown by references to common exercise books.

eLife assessment

In the current manuscript, the authors study the effects of hypoxia or genetic and pharmacologic modulation of the hypoxic pathways on T cells. The findings about T cells sense hypoxia and how hypoxia affects T cell (and CAR T cell) differentiation and function are significant and interesting for the field. The data supporting these findings are mostly robust, yet some questions remain open and some statements seem unsupported by evidence.

eLife assessment

This fundamental work substantially advances our understanding of polymer physics underpinnings of genome folding, organization, and regulation. The conclusions are supported by both convincing computer simulations and analytical theory. The work will be of significant interest to the genome folding community.

eLife assessment

This manuscript will be of interest to scientists in the field of tissue injury and repair. It provides novel molecular mechanisms of a transcription factor, Prrx1, in fibroblast activation following lung injury. Overall, the work suggests that PRRX1 plays a functional role downstream of TGFb1 to elicit some aspects of the fibrotic response and that PRRX1 could represent an important therapeutic target to treat fibrosis. The strengths of this work are the multiple approaches applying human and mouse lung tissue used by the authors to test the role of PRRX1 in lung fibrosis, however, in its current form, major limitations need to be addressed.

eLife Assessment

The study has advanced our mechanistic understanding of lung regeneration. While the importance of regeneration of alveolar capillaries for long response to injury has been long recognized, the regulation of this process has not been well understood. Your study provides novel, comprehensive, and compelling evidence that the expression of the transcription factor Atf3 in alveolar capillary endothelial cells plays a critical role in the regeneration of alveolar capillaries following lung injury.

eLife assessment

This study concerns an important area, that of monoallelic expression, but the study does not provide sufficient information about the candidate regulatory RNA to provide a significant advance over previous work, which should also be discussed in more detail.

eLife assessment

This important study provides convincing evidence that locus coeruleus is activated during visuomotor mismatches. Gain of function optogenetic experiments complement this evidence and indicate that locus coeruleus could be involved in the learning process that enables visuomotor predictions. This study, therefore, sets the groundwork for the circuit dissection of predictive signals in the visual cortex. Loss-of-function experiments would strengthen the evidence of the involvement of locus coeruleus in prediction learning. These results will be of interest to systems neuroscientists.

eLife assessment

The study examines the principles according to which neurons connect to each other in the brain. The authors find that data could be best explained by the homophillic wiring principle where neurons preferentially connect to neurons within overlapping groups. The work will provide a valuable resource to the neuroscience community once analyses are standardized across various datasets included.

eLife assessment

This valuable work advances our understanding of the acoustic features driving the attraction of female mice to male vocalizations. The evidence supporting the conclusions is solid, with well-designed place preference assays and manipulations of male song structure. The work will be of broad interest to neurobiologists and ethologists working on mouse social interactions, auditory processing and communication.

eLife assessment

This manuscript combines cryo-EM and a suite of compelling whole cell and proteoliposome transport assays to establish the mechanism and structure of the full-length human SLC26A6 chloride/bicarbonate exchangers, including the first partial view of the previously unresolved IVS region of an SLC26 STAS domain. In combination with prior studies on additional SLC26 paralogs, including the SLC26A9 paralog initially reported by the same group, the current study provides important insight into the mechanistic diversity of the SLC26 transporters. This study is of interest to the biophysics community and the field of membrane transport.

eLife assessment

This study evaluated how naturalistic behaviors are encoded in the striatum by analyzing neural ensembles engaged during grooming behavior. The study shows that neural responses are highly heterogeneous during grooming, but ensembles were detected in which units were more correlated during grooming than during the entire session. This study presents an important contribution to the field by shedding light on how ensembles of neurons encode innate behavior. The results are convincing.

eLife assessment

This important study uses an innovative genome-wide approach and targeted testing to identify S. aureus genes that affect susceptibility to serum, serum-derived antimicrobial products, and commonly used antibiotics. The findings are significant in that they highlight evidence of evolution of virulence determinants in the setting of exposure to host stressors expected to be present during bacteremia and antibiotic therapy. The evidence is solid, but the presentation could be improved by providing details that clarify the methods and highlighting the limited current understanding of the major target, tcaA.

eLife assessment

This contribution provides important insights into the thermodynamic landscape of cation transporters of the Cation Diffusion Facilitator (CDF) superfamily, together with a detailed structural investigation of the role of the three zinc(II) binding sites of YiiP. Despite the relatively low resolution of the cryo-EM structures presented in this work, the combination of structural, functional and modeling techniques yields solid evidence for the proposed model. This work will be of interest to biologists and biophysicists that work with membrane transporters; it is an excellent example of how different techniques can be combined to obtain relevant information on the complex mechanism of action of a transporter.

eLife assessment

This important study combines behavioral and imaging experiments to understand how levels of important brain chemicals shape the processing of information in the brain in children and young adults. The sample size and data quality are outstanding and some of the data are quite convincing. However, the calculation and interpretation of the brain chemical concentration measurements as well as the interpretation of the model-based behavioral parameters are not fully justified and support for the overall conclusions is incomplete. This work will be of interest to neuroscientists, psychologists, and neuroimaging researchers investigating the developing brain in health and disease.

eLife assessment

This is a valuable addition to the literature as it helps us understand the role of tRNA modifying enzymes in Mycobacterium tuberculosis. By knocking out one of the enzymes, the authors convincingly demonstrate the importance of tRNA-modifying enzymes for intra-host growth of tubercle bacteria. Some of the claims regarding modification as well as the role in virulence could be strengthened through further bioinformatics and phylogenetic analyses as well as experimental approaches. The work will be of interest to microbiologists.

eLife assessment

Müller glial cells of the zebrafish retina can differentiate into all neural cell classes following injury, providing full regenerative capabilities of the zebrafish retina. This study presents a valuable description of transcriptional changes of Müller glia cells in the adult and regenerating retina using single-cell RNA sequencing. The overall evidence supporting the main claims of the authors is solid, but some aspects of the analysis are incomplete and would benefit from additional experimental evidence to support the existence of different types of Müller glia and their distribution in the retina.

eLife assessment

This valuable study provides insights into mechanisms of placental aging and its relationship to labor initiation. The authors provide solid evidence and have thoroughly investigated the molecular characteristics of normal placental aging using in vivo and in vitro model systems and human placental tissue analysis to corroborate their findings. This work contributes to existing work in placental aging and preterm birth and will be of interest to reproductive scientists.

eLife assessment:

This valuable study presents convincing evidence that metabolite levels in Escherichia coli bacteria from a long-term evolution experiment have changed in consistent ways, which in turn can be explained by recurrent mutations in regulatory genes that affect enzyme expression levels. The use of high-resolution mass spectrometry measuring bulk metabolite levels, in combination with existing gene expression and DNA sequencing datasets provides valuable information linking changes in an organism's genome, transcriptome, and metabolome. The current version of the paper lacks clarity in parts, most critically in the introduction, and would benefit from some rewriting to improve its structure, precision, and readability.

eLife assessment

This study reports important findings regarding the systemic function of hemocytes controlling whole-body responses to oxidative stress. The evidence in support of the requirement for hemocytes in oxidative stress responses as well as the hemocyte single-nuclei analyses in the presence or absence of oxidative stress are convincing. In contrast, the genetic and physiological analyses that link the non-canonical DDR pathway to upd3/JNK expression and high susceptibility, and the inferences regarding the function of hemocytes in systemic metabolic control are incomplete and would benefit from more rigorous approaches. The work will be of interest to cell and developmental biologists working on animal metabolism, immunity, or stress responses.

eLife assessment

Muroňová et al. provide valuable information about CDCC146 as a centriole and microtubule associated protein essential for sperm flagellar formation and male fertility. Mutations were identified in human patients suffering from MMAF syndrome, but the evidence that these human mutations were causative of the abnormal phenotype is incomplete. To further explore the causality, mouse models are generated and the findings from the mouse study, support that the key roles of CCDC146 for microtubule-based structures throughout sperm development in general but requires statical analysis.

eLife assessment

This important study reports investigation of the dynamics of PKA at the single-cell level in in vitro and in epithelia in vivo. Using different fluorescent biosensors and optogenetic actuators, the authors dissect the signaling pathway responsible for PKA waves, finding that PKA activation is a consequence of PGE2 release, which in turn is triggered by calcium pulses, requiring high ERK activity. The evidence supporting the claims is solid. At this stage the work is still partly descriptive in nature, and additional measurements would increase the strength of mechanistic insights and physiological relevance.

eLife assessment

This manuscript reports important findings regarding the potential for self-policing and a division of labor among biofilm-inhabiting Bacillus cells. Overall, this work is robust in its use of various techniques and provides solid insights into the intersections of well-understood regulatory controls and the suppression of cheaters. Despite some concerns about the data, all reviewers were excited by the potential impact of this work. Colleagues interested in microbial social interactions should find this study's narrative about the internal mediation of cell differentiation particularly valuable.

eLife assessment

This study presents important findings on the mechanism as to how Mycobacterium-containing vacuoles are recognized by host cell factors and subjected to membrane repair or autophagic degradation using Dictyostelium discoideum as a useful model. The evidence for the role of TrafE in damaged-membrane repair and xenophagy induction is convincing, but that in autophagosome closure is rather incomplete.

eLife Assessment:

Zemel and colleagues provide a report on the fundamental electrophysiological properties of motor neurons driving song in the zebrafish and provide complementary information about cell morphology, pharmacological sensitivity, and ion channel expression and heterogeneity. They provide mainly convincing data supporting the claim of a particular ion channel class, Kv3, that plays an important role in fast electrical spiking (action potentials) in song-related neurons.

eLife assessment<br /> <br /> Within this paper, the authors describe a rapid and easy-to-implement CRISPR/Cas9-mediated knock-in approach to precisely insert large transgenes in the African turquoise killifish. The established method will be instrumental for many researchers working with unusual model species, and, in particular, will expand the killifish community toolbox. It will revolutionize the field and bring the killifish, an emerging animal model in aging biology and disease modeling in vertebrates, into the spotlight even more.

eLife assessment

This valuable study addresses the anticipated but poorly understood interconnections between ER proteostasis and lipid metabolism. The authors discovered key metabolic enzymes required for integration of ER stress and lipid synthesis and followed up with several direct experiments that provide solid evidence for a broad conservation of the described interactions.

eLife assessment

Motivated by previous demonstrations that cognitive modulation of heart beat evoked responses (HER) might distinguish minimally consciousness state and unresponsive wakefulness syndrome patients, the present work sought to determine whether contextual processing of auditory regularities (local-global paradigm) differentially affects HER in these patient groups. The results provide preliminary evidence for the usefulness of EEG and oddball paradigms in informing diagnosis of the state of consciousness. This paper will be of interest to those researchers studying signs of consciousness in post-comatose patients and more broadly to those studying brain-body interactions. However, some aspects of the study design and data analysis need to be clarified, particularly as these affect the conclusions that can be drawn.

eLife assessment

Hernandez-Perez et al. perform a detailed analysis of Kazrin, a widely expressed protein that appears to be involved in many diverse cellular processes, but whose exact function is unknown. The authors employ mouse embryonic fibroblasts and biochemistry to investigate the function of Kazrin and determine that Kazrin promotes the dynein/dynactin-dependent transport of early endosomes. These findings are valuable to those in the field of intracellular transport, but the story will benefit from additional experiments to prove the main claims, or from textual modifications.

eLife assessment

In the current study, Mondoloni and colleagues reveal how a selective nicotine receptor in the interpeduncular nucleus is involved in nicotine consumption, which is an important contribution to the understanding of individual differences in drug addiction. However, the preferred hypothesis would benefit from testing in additional experimental models, metabolic assessment, and cell-type specificity.

eLife assessment

The cerebellum plays a critical role in motor learning, but exactly which forms of synaptic plasticity contribute to learning, as well as the underlying molecular mechanisms, remain poorly understood. In this study, Wang and colleagues show that presynaptic long-term potentiation at the parallel fiber to Purkinje cell synapse is required for one form of motor learning, and involves a previously-unknown signaling cascade, where EPAC activation leads to PKCε-dependent threonine phosphorylation of RIM1α. This study provides new insights into the underlying mechanisms and functional consequences of presynaptic LTP.

eLife assessment

This paper expands on prior work by using whole-brain calcium imaging in Drosophila to examine how spontaneous and forced walking and turning affect neural activity in the brain. The measurements presented will serve as a valuable resource for the fly systems neuroscience community and suggest many testable hypotheses that may serve as the basis for future studies. Analyses of the data are solid, but conclusions drawn should be presented with more caveats. This article will be of interest to neuroscientists engaged with the central problem of how behavior modulates neural activity.

eLife assessment

This paper provides valuable new information on the mechanisms by which Vibrio cholerae integrates and responds to environmental signals. While the strength of the evidence provided in the paper in support of the conclusions made and the model proposed is solid, there are several issues that if addressed will strengthen the study further. The work is relevant for a broad audience of microbiologists interested in the mechanisms by which bacteria sense their environment.

eLife assessment

This is a valuable study on DNA gyrase that provides further evidence for its mode of action via a double-stranded DNA break and against a recently-proposed alternative mechanism. The evidence presented is solid and is derived from state-of-the-art techniques. The work casts new light on the interactions that occur between gyrase molecules and will be of interest to biochemists and cell biologists.

eLife assessment

This study makes a valuable contribution to our functional understanding of the atypical amino-acid transporter SLC6A177 at nerve cell synapses and the role of SLC6A17 variants in certain forms of intellectual disability. The reported evidence that disease-linked SLC6A17 variants cause behavioral abnormalities is convincing. However, corresponding molecular underpinnings, i.e. the molecular role of SLC6A17 in synapses and the functional molecular consequences of disease-related SLC6A17 variations, remain unclear because corresponding informative experimental approaches are missing - most importantly direct measurements of the transport activity of SLC6A17 in the various genetic contexts studied. This limits the robustness and validity of key mechanistic conclusions drawn from the present work.

eLife assessment

This valuable work in human subjects reports that sounds that were associated with specific memories during waking behaviors can trigger the reactivation of these memory representations during REM sleep. However, the evidence supporting the conclusions is currently incomplete. Still, the work has the potential to expand our understanding of memory processing during sleep.

eLife Assessment

Using a novel multi-depth plan display, this study reveals a valuable finding regarding crowding - it decreases with small depth differences between the target and flankers but increases with larger depth differences. The evidence supporting this finding is convincing, although the explanation of the findings is somewhat speculative. This paper will be of interest to visual scientists, neuroscientists, and ophthalmologists, especially those working on visual crowding and depth perception.

eLife assessment

This study presents useful findings on an important question in cognitive neuroscience - whether the brain can form sensory predictions during sleep. The paradigm used is compelling but evidence supporting the claims of the authors is incomplete. Major issues pertaining to large differences between the pattern of brain responses observed here relative to effects reported in the literature previously, and some evidence that the study might be underpowered to make strong conclusions about certain aspects of the data.

eLife assessment

The authors ask if brain regions change based on the functional constraints or developmental constraints. To address this, they introduce an automated method for brain segmentation based on the zebrafish tool to study brain evolution in Astyanax. A caveat is that it is difficult to test the functional constraint hypothesis using this method, though it works well for testing developmental constraints.

eLife assessment

Antimicrobial peptides (AMP) are a class of antibiotics that are inspired by natural components of innate immunity, which raises the specter of bacteria becoming resistant to both. The author this important study test this idea and find compelling evidence that a plasmid that encodes resistance to the AMP colistin also increases resistance to AMPS produced by humans, pigs, and chickens, enables the bacteria to grow better in low levels of AMP, and increases bacterial virulence in an insect model of infection. The study will be of interest to both evolutionary biologists and microbiologists focused on antimicrobial therapy and suggests that the evolution of resistance to these compounds can have collateral effects on immune evasion as well.

eLife assessment

This important study provides compelling observations of the organization and architecture of haptomonads, a distinct and poorly understood developmental form of Leishmania found in sand fly vectors at later stages of infection. The authors used 3D electron microscopy techniques, including serial block face scanning electron microscopy and electron tomography, to visualize the colonization sand fly by haptomonads in impressive detail.

eLife assessment:

Sampaio and colleagues utilize an elegant approach to manipulate fluid dynamics in zebrafish Kupffer's vesicle to ask if fluid movement or something in the fluid governs the break in symmetry. These valuable results support a role for fluid movement and detection as important in breaking symmetry in a ciliated left-right organizer and help set a time window when fluid flow is critical for this process. However, as the fluid extraction experiments affect both chemical and physical features, the authors need to provide further convincing evidence to support their mechanosensory hypothesis or temper the claims.

eLife assessment

In this important study, the role of NBR1 in the degradation of photodamaged chloroplasts is analyzed, advancing our knowledge of chloroplast homeostasis in response to environmental stress. The evidence presented is convincing, in some parts even compelling, and the results are valuable for the plant and the autophagy research community.

eLife assessment

This valuable manuscript presents resources for genome-wide genetic perturbation in the fruitfly, Drosophila. The evidence for the usefulness is solid, with the authors demonstrating that they can identify novel genes that affect an important pathway, the mTOR pathway, which plays key roles in cell proliferation and cell death. The genetic resources are significant for their availability to colleagues in the Drosophila community seeking to to identify genes with important cellular functions.

eLife assessment<br /> <br /> Descovich et al examine the important decision between proliferative (planar) and differentiation (perpendicular) divisions in the basal layers of the skin and find a key promoter of perpendicular divisions is inhibited by its paralog to specify planar divisions. The authors use sophisticated mouse genetics and imaging and discover that LGN and its paralog AGS3 function antagonistically in determining perpendicular vs. planar divisions. Some statements need to be tamed or further backed up, but overall this study provides a significant advance in the field.

eLife assessment

This is an important study on the role of a bacterial cell wall component, D-alanylated lipoteichoic acid, as a bacteria cue in Drosophila melanogaster-microbiome interactions. Overall, the evidence supporting the conclusions is compelling, with a solid approach combining crystallography with biochemical and cellular assays, that take advantage of both fly and bacterial mutants, to demonstrate a physiological role in juvenile growth promotion. The work will be of broad interest to those studying host-microbe interactions, especially as it is related to immunology and metabolism mediated by the microbiome.

eLife assessment

The manuscript describes a fundamental study of the atypical MAPK, ERK3, in the activation of RhoGTPase Cdc42 and the formation of actin-rich protrusions and cell migration. The results show that ERK3 is required for the motility of tumor cells in vivo, providing a new target for fighting metastasis.

eLife assessment

These are important findings that show that pupil size is not only governed by the locus coeruleus but also by other neuromodulatory subcortical systems. Furthermore, the authors demonstrate that using a standard hemodynamic response kernel is not appropriate for capturing the activity of these systems, at least at rest. Thus, this paper presents compelling evidence against two prevalent working assumptions among researchers in the field.

eLife assessment

This important work utilizes a model organism, zebrafish, to explore changes to the proteome and the role of KLHL40, a component of the ubiquitin-proteasome system, in the development of skeletal muscle disease. Using mass spectrometry, the authors demonstrate a major and selective role for proteome remodeling in development. They identify a specific role for KLHL40 deletion in regulating the expression of Sar1 - a key component of biosynthetic secretion, where the resulting elevated levels of Sar1 expression potentially lead to collagen secretion defects in the disease state. The findings are incomplete as further experimental characterization of the overall morphological changes and secretion defects, in particular ones derived from the deregulation of Sar1 levels, is required.

eLife assessment

In this useful study, a GWAS-type analysis is applied to clinical Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates to discover genetic polymorphisms linked to poor tuberculosis outcomes. The evidence for the detected associations is still incomplete, as the corresponding polymorphisms are not adequate to power a prediction model for infection outcome, although key host factors - including patient age, sex, and duration of diagnostic delay (which have stronger predictive value) - appear to enhance predictive capacity.

eLife Assessment:

The manuscript by Godoy and colleagues is an important contribution to the understanding of how lung endothelial regeneration progresses following endothelial ablation. The novelty and elegance of this study are rooted in the regional and specific ablation of lung endothelial cells using diphtheria toxin without the massive inflammatory activation that is seen with lung injury induced by bacterial infections, viral infections, or lipopolysaccharide. The data convincingly demonstrate that there is an emergence of a highly proliferative lung endothelial subpopulation that drives endothelial regeneration. The translational implications of the study include the identification of potential therapeutic targets to augment endothelial regeneration as a treatment for ALI/ARDS. This study will be of interest to vascular biologists, lung biologists, and researchers studying adult tissue regeneration.

eLife assessment

This is an important contribution to colorectal cancer research to understand how we can predict high-risk patients for recurrence. The strength of the evidence is solid and looks at a novel approach but an approach that still has opportunities to improve.

eLife assessment

This study provides an important demonstration that loneliness is associated with smaller hippocampal volume, reduced cortical thickness, and worse cognition in healthy older adults. This has theoretical or practical implications beyond a single subfield. The strength of evidence is solid given the cross-sectional and longitudinal design with a few weaknesses. With the analytical and interpretational part strengthened, this paper would be of interest to gerontologists, and dementia/cognitive aging researchers.

eLife assessment

This paper provides strong evidence for the important point that microtubule function is required for the proper localization of Glut4 glucose transporters in an insulin responsive compartment. This membrane localization is required in turn for effective translocation of Glut4 to the muscle cell surface in response to the hormone.

eLife assessment

This paper deals with an important unsolved problem in developmental biology of how cells execute their dynamics at the right time. The study combines compelling quantitative single cell and single transcript experiments with genetic perturbations and computational modelling and provides important insights into how the timing of transcription is regulated. The work would be strengthened by better integration of modeling and data.

eLife assessment

This important study uses two well-established colorectal cancer models to estimate the potential impact of disruptions in screening caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. By dividing the population into separate cohorts based on age and pre-pandemic screening status, the authors provide convincing evidence for the adverse impact of delays in screening, switching regimens, and screening discontinuation. The finding that discontinuation has a much greater impact on screening-associated gains in life expectancy than shorter-term delays or switching of regimens suggests that access-related barriers to screening resumption may lead to the worsening of current disparities.

eLife assessment

This is an interesting study investigating the propagation dynamics of ripples recorded from the dorsal hippocampus of mice using an open-access dataset. Findings may have theoretical and practical implications for the study and manipulation of sharp-wave ripples, a main oscillatory event underlying memory consolidation. While the strength of evidence is solid and claims broadly supported, there are some points requiring additional analysis to clarify issues regarding the anatomical axes involved and to reinforce mechanistic insights.

eLife assessment<br /> <br /> This study presents valuable findings on how the ectopic expression of the Lck protein tyrosine kinase in Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemias (CLL) contributes to malignant transformation. The evidence supporting the claims of the authors is solid, although the use of gene editing to directly explore the functions unique to LCK in a CLL model would increase the appeal of the work.

eLife assessment

This study provides valuable insight into the diversity within the NRAMP superfamily of transporters. Evidence of divalent metal ion transport and the structure (obtained without added metal ions) are convincing. However, molecular insight into Al3+ recognition and transport is incomplete, and the work would be strengthened by the determination of a metal-bound structure or additional experiments (such as molecular dynamics simulations or quantitative Al3+ binding/transport assays) to support the proposed Al3+ binding site. The work will be of interest to structural biologists and biophysicists studying NRAMP transporters.

eLife assessment

The authors use data from 3 cross-sectional age-stratified serosurveys on Enterovirus D68 from England between 2006 and 2017 to examine the transmission dynamics of this pathogen in this setting. Understanding these dynamics, including how it changes over time, may help uncover potential changes in the transmissibility of the virus. While the topic is relevant, interpretation of the results challenging largely due to the great uncertainty around how to interpret the serological (serostatus) data, and the impact this has on the inferences made. We ask the authors to perform some additional analyses and to provide more intuition to understand some of the key findings of this analysis.

eLife assessment

In this manuscript, a method to test a large number of drug combinations in a single cell culture sample is presented. The strength of the evidence lies in their multiple experiments with different combinations of agents. The paper suggests that results from this application are feasible and the methodology could be applied in other laboratories to use drug combinations for defined outcomes.

eLife assessment

The authors' finding that Btk kinase activation relies on specific interactions with the Grb2 scaffold protein, including for recruitment into signaling clusters on membranes, is an unexpected finding that will potentially be of broad interest. The authors make a case for reinterpretation of the "Saraste dimer" of Btk as a signaling entity and assign roles to the component domains in the Src module in Btk activation, but the data provided are not yet fully convincing for this scenario.

eLife assessment

This is a very interesting and important study that convincingly demonstrates a descending pathway for the control of nociception in non-mammalian organisms.

eLife assessment

By combining electrophysiological analysis of mutant channels and molecular dynamics simulations, this important study identifies a common binding site for two structurally distinct activators of KCNQ1-KCNE1 channels. The findings represent an important advance for the field, with convincing functional data to support it. The simulations are still partially incomplete and would benefit from additional data and discussion. The work will be of interest to those studying the binding of small molecule drugs to membrane protein complexes.

eLife assessment

This is a valuable study that shows the involvement of phosphoinositide 3-kinase (PI3K) signaling downstream of platelet-derived growth factor receptor alpha in latero-medial migration of cardiomyocytes during the formation of the early heart tube during zebrafish development. The authors provide convincing evidence using multiple drugs and expression of a dominant negative PI3K subunit, to inhibit the pathway, approaches that show the strong alignment of phenotypes, and which are quantified using live imaging. The demonstration of cardiomyocyte protrusions biased in the direction of migration, and randomised after PI3K inhibition, is a promising area for future exploration.

eLife assessment

The study integrates experiments and data of various kinds to address the important biomedical problem of carbapenems resistance in Klebsiella. The authors present compelling evidence for loci that are sufficient for carbapenem resistance in this strain, with further evidence of their fitness cost. This study will be of interest to those across multiple audiences, including the microbial evolution community, and those interested in the biomedical problem of antibiotic resistance.

eLife assessment

The authors describe the first full-length crystal structure and solution conformation of the GAC protein from Toxoplasma gondii. The data are convincing and support a model in which GAC uses multiple conformations and lipid-binding surfaces. This paper presents an important contribution to our understanding of the molecular machinery involved in host cell invasion, but questions remain about how this protein links to the cytoskeleton and functions during the invasion process.

eLife assessment

This study explored practitioners' assessments of the impact of the pandemic on cervical cancer screening and follow-up. This is a very important topic that could continue to have implications for how this screening process is delivered now, after the pandemic. The authors need to more fully describe their methodology and temper conclusions to fit within those limitations.

eLife assessment

This valuable study discovers that zinc ions can activate some OTOP proton channels, identifying a pharmacological tool for research, and further establishing that OTOP channels gate. The data presented provide convincing support for the conclusions made by the authors, and the study is expected to be of considerable interest to physiologists investigating OTOP and other proton channels.

eLife assessment

This study provides important evidence regarding the development of concept representations, using functional brain imaging to compare concept structure in people with different amounts of language experience. The analyses, which are overall solid, suggest that representations in the left lateral anterior temporal lobe differ as a function of childhood language experience.

eLife assessment

This useful paper describes a sensitive method for identifying the contributions of different behavioral and stimulus parameters to neural activity. The method has been convincingly validated using simulated data and applied to example state of the art data sets from mouse and zebrafish. The method could be productively applied to a wide range of experiments in behavioral and systems neuroscience, but it remained unclear how it relates to or improves on similar, existing methods.

eLife assessment

The authors present an important contribution to the field of deep brain stimulation (DBS) for depression by providing further evidence for the validity of the lateral habenula as a DBS target. The evidence provided is compelling and particularly strong in its use of fMRI to delineate target subregions best corresponding both to clinical and downstream fMRI response. This study provides information relevant to both surgical targeting and the mechanism of action for this DBS target.