G. S. Howard et al., Do research literatures give correct answers? Rev. Gen. Psychol. 13, 116–121 (2009). doi: 10.1037/a0015468
Howard and colleagues examine how the file drawer problem---that is, the tendency of researchers to publish positive results but not negative or inconclusive results--affects a body of research literature. They compare "old," existing bodies of literature that could be suffering from the file drawer problem with a newly constructed body of literature guaranteed to be free of the file drawer problem, which they achieved by conducting new studies.
This investigation suggests that some bodies of literature are supported as relatively file-drawer-free, while other bodies of literature raise concern and kindle further studies on the effects they include.
