344 Matching Annotations
  1. Sep 2025
    1. ea level rise and destruc-tion of ecosystems and livelihoods will cause two types of migration: strategic migrationand managed retreat. Strategic migration is a choice made by individuals. It can beeconomically motivated or specifically because of a perception that staying in placewill be impossible or costly because of climate change (Castro 2023). Managed retreatis the organized movement of communities away from hazards. It will become inevitablein some places, like low lying island nations and other places that become uninhabitable,yet it is highly undesirable and often fiercely resisted

      Strategic migration is more economically or individually motivated while managed retreat will happen as that place slowly becomes unlivable (as opposed to rapidly in the case of disaster)

    2. involving ‘conflict, disease, pol-itical change and economic crises’ (Kemp et al. 2022, 6). Should such large scale societaldisruptions occur, migration would surely follow

      Making me want to be a damn climate activist

    3. Estimating the volume of climate migration produces highly varied estimates. Ques-tions about how much the climate will warm, whether the effects will be linear or includetipping points that drastically change climate and cause sea level rise, the role of climatechange as a threat multiplier leading to conflict and government collapse, and the ways inwhich countries will adapt to rising numbers of potential migrants by closing or openingborders are all implicated in these estimates.

      TLDR: It makes everything worse bozos

    4. argue that while climate migration will pose many chal-lenges, it also can be framed positively, and we can use what we know from migrationscholarship to craft policies and to further research that will lead to better outcomesfor both migrants and receiving communities

      What are the good outcomes for receiving communities

    5. successful integration of largenumbers of migrants fleeing climate change should be a toppriority not least because this success will help to preserve thesocial trust that is necessary for successful climate mitigationefforts

      But you are actively fighting against the dominant american thought

    6. is for richcountries to allocate extra visas to poorer countries that aresuffering the effects of climate migration, partly as reparations forclimate injustice.

      Good fucking luck bro

    Tags

    Annotators

    1. TPSis a blanket form of humanitarian relief which allows qualifying nationals of designated countries toremain in the United States and obtain work authorization.

      This I definitely agree with, and it does not seem as reliant on precedented legal definitions

    2. While the asylum and refugeeprotection systems offer protection to some individuals impacted by climate change who have alsosuffered other persecution, there are no formal protection pathways for climate-displaced people underU.S. law. Temporary designations, such as humanitarian parole, do not offer a systemic response toprovide lasting protections to those displaced by climate change

      The counter argument here is that it will sooooooo expand the definition of refugee ironically "opening the floodgates"

    3. Jozef said that after HBA replaced the tents destroyed by theJanuary 2023 bomb cyclone, additional rain storms in late February 2023 destroyed the new tents

      Climate change is both a multiplying factor for why families migrate as well a a direct reason why migrating itself is so difficult

    4. migrants to cross dangerous terrain by foot, making them vulnerable to the adverseeffects of climate change along the journey to the United States-Mexico border

      Vicious cycle

    5. will further endanger asylumseekers and refugees, including those displaced in the context of climate change, by making themineligible for protection based solely on their manner of entry.

      Talked about this in class

    6. asylum in 2015 after the government illegally appropriated their tribal lands,leaving them vulnerable to homelessness and gang violence

      This is persecuation along the lines of a group so it makes them count as refugees

    7. Several asylum seekers interviewed by the research teamreported that organized criminal groups had taken advantage of precarious conditions resulting fromclimate change to exploit their communities, including

      Sort of like what the taliban is doing, you have to bend a knee to power but also the hand that feeds you

    8. The family fled after gang members killed the woman’s brother and uncle andkidnapped her husband.

      This feels like maybe it could apply also maybe a particular social group could be those affected by a climate crisis

    9. He toldthe research team that he had applied for government aid to rebuild his house, but that hisapplication was denied. “They left me with practically nothing,” he said.

      But because the gov. is saying a blanket no its not persecution?

    10. A Mexican woman fleeing an abusive partner reported that her riverside community wasflooded by heavy rains in 2022, forcing her to close her travel agency business and impeding herability to support her children. The woman noted that there were more storms that forced theclosure of local businesses in 2022 than ever before

      This unfortunately defo does not count

    11. threats by gang members who killed her son reportedthat floods from heavy rains over the past two years destroyed her home and heavily damagedthe family’s chicken farm, leaving them without an income.

      Could this not qualify as a refugee status because of persecution

    12. intersecting threats push people to seek safety across international borders.

      Climate can create internal displacement which eventually spills over into international displacement

    Annotators

    Annotators

      • striking first line, and very good hook
      • I mean the obvious question is who the fuck is this boy and why is he being kept in just an obviously inhumane place?
      • For some reason its really portrayed as idyllic
      • he has no dialogue
      • yikes bro, he was like raping kids or some shit?

    Annotators

    1. ips. However, the administration was ultimately unsuccessful in preving the development of a policy regime based firmly in legal advocacy. Leglessons, strategies, and best practices from the early successes and failures ofHaitian advocates were passed to Central American advo

      Surely in part this is just a backlash of having tried to swing the pendulum so far in the other direction

    2. 85 found that "hostile statapplicants were 3491.4 percent more likely to obtain refugee status than wereapplicants from non-hostil

      Still using refugees and asylum seekers as political tools

    3. outh Florida. The program gave thegreat leeway to detain Haitians and quickly deny their asylum claims befreturning them to Ha

      Again, very Ad Hoc at a time where there was enough demand for a systematic procedure

    4. Nixon, and Carter used their executive authority to parole additional peobeyond that cap.18 As these actions became increasingly frequent, key memberCongress grew frustrated with what they viewed as an executive bypasslegislative authority over immigration admissions.19 To restore congressiooversight, a legislative revision appear

      Ad Hoc behaivor mentioned in class

    5. d States took afairly unilateral approach to refugee policy. The United States admitted peoplebased on its own refugee definition that paid homage to, but was much moreideologically restrictive than, the definition in the UN Refugee Convention. Mea

      Because the ratification was still mainky for europeans and the demand for refuggee status or asylum was not great

    6. ism. Third, in the1980s the field of asylum cause law grew in response to the resistance of PresidentReagan's Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) to implementing the 1980Refugee A

      Reagans gonna fuck us up

    1. Afaf, a mother of eight children, four of whom were inthe United States, also prepared food that the resettlement agency purchasedfrom her for arriving families.

      Informal skills

    2. The womenshared tea during their breaks, and on Fridays when there was no class, theyheld get-togethers, preparing meals of yogurt and bread fatta or eggs and falafelto share alongside strong Arabic coffee and black tea. These were spaces tounwind and crack jokes while listening to the latest in Arabic pop music,

      First positive of this whole chapter?

    3. While the demands ofthe self-sufficiency imperative were met by their spouses, women, includingRima, were able to attend English class.

      The unequal opprotunities for men gives women a chance to bolster their human capital

    4. The thread went dead after that. “They just wanta handout,” Nader said, shrugging.

      Again, a new hostility of people who feel like they have succeeded and can't understand why other people haven't

    5. However,this wasn’t advertised or promised, and the agency policy was to end finan-cial assistance after the Welcome Money was depleted or shortly thereafter.

      This is kind of the work mom should do, also I wonder how this looks different now. To what extent do these NGOs have to work with the gov.

    6. Many new arrivals would not learn to identify with others who wereminoritized, nor would they identify their own position within the Americanracial hierarchy.

      Another way its hostile

    7. so long as [the vettingprocess] is fully implemented and not diluted, it will allow us to safely admit themost vulnerable refugees while protecting the American.

      It was never a partisan behavior

    Annotators

    1. the strategic interest of the US to shift the economic burden of supporting refugeesonto the Iranian government in order to weaken an adversarial regime

      Refugees are a drain, no matter how you put it, so the US will use them as a weapon or a burden relief to solidify allies or harm enemies

    2. hese elements made localintegration and repatriation more practical options for the US policy towards Afghanrefugees. In addition, it was in the interest of Pakistan to offer temporary refuge forrefugees who doubled as insurgents battling the Afghan Government as their mutualenemy.

      This argument feels more sound and makes more intuitive sense than the guilt one at least

    3. The US did not accept a broader responsibilityfor the millions displaced in Iran or Pakistan, instead funding humanitarian aid andrepatriation.

      Right, there was no guilt

    4. “With repatriation now a real possibility for manyAfghans and Iraqis, we expect to process [for resettlement] only extremely vulner-able refugees from those countries who cannot return to their homes.”

      but why was this mainly carried out for afgans and not also for iraqis

    5. The US refugee policy in the region was to offer aid, rather than resettlement –some USD 26 million for food and local relief efforts in 1980, administered mostlythrough the Government of Pakistan and UNHCR.

      Partly, the US is saying "we did not have a hand in starting this so we do not need an explicit hand in finishing or resetling" but what makes this a foreign policy tool and not guilt.

    6. I hypothesise that if the US is a closeally with a neighbour of Iraq or Afghanistan, it may prioritise the neighbouring coun-tries’ interests by resettling more refugees from the neighbouring territories.

      Refugees becoming an act of goodwill between allies

    7. his programme was, in part, a recognitionthat the US had a moral responsibility to support the Vietnamese refugees who werein danger because of US military actions

      How is this different motivation from what was mentioned above?

    8. “escapees” or “defectors” and were used for their symbolic and propaganda value to“serve to embarrass enemy nations and discredit their political systems”

      Figureheads

    9. 1) to undermine enemies by welcoming defectors, 2) to mitigate damagecreated by foreign policy failures, and 3) the politics of neighbours.

      These first two reasons make sense to me but the politics of neighbors is still a gray area

    10. DHS officers traveling to Afghanistan and the surrounding region to process applica-tions. These two factors

      All evidence that if security was the end all be all, we would have no iraqis

    11. security does not ex-plain why the US prioritised Iraqis and not Afghans

      If they truly cared only about or primarily about security, then they should have been resettling FEWER iraqis

    12. n this way, the differences in US refugee policy toward Iraqis and Afghans cannotbe explained by international law.

      TLDR: The US gets to choose when and with whom they participate with as far as resettlement goes, so international law variation can not explain the difference

    13. that countries interpret and apply international refugee law in different ways, leadingto large variations in asylum recognition rates

      This could be a way to conceal true intentions though: "Oh we just thought it was applied that way"

    14. Fundamentally, it is not American relationships with refugee-producing countries, but rather their neighbours – the refugee-receiving countries – thatdetermines how the US prioritizes refugee resettlement.

      Thesis

    Annotators

    1. Capitalism * Migrants have fewer protections under labor law and are discouraged from joining a union * migrants have a great wage disparity because they are easily exploitative labor * Language barriers, knowledge gap of legal process, and paying for a lawyer make it hard to have equal access to the law

      Race and Gender * Racial stereotype that women have the "maternal instinct" that keeps them from opportunities for other jobs (meaning people do not offer them) * There was a lack of mobility because of the socialization of women and indigenous people to do a certain kind of labor * minority groups are faced with the challenge of mobilization in a system set up against them

    2. Finally,women also generated new forms of social capital through interactions with theiremployers and other women working in the same household or neighbourhood

      These women are also finding these informal areas of learning

    3. They generated migration and employment networks in which they matched femalefriends and family with their employer’s contacts. Sandoval-Cervantes (2017) findsthat this helped migrant women develop a sense of autonomy and independence notfound in other migrant contexts at the time.

      Perhaps a blueprint for what woukd eventually happen in america?

    Tags

    Annotators

  2. Aug 2025
    1. , ‘Hey girls, will you help me? If Idon’t like it there, will you help me to come home? Help me pay for my return?’ Theyagreed

      Sort a touhcing story throughout of gendered support. I'm sure the bracerro program ghas also been studied. I wonder if the support was the same.

    2. Nachita told me about howyoung girls, mostly the poorest of the poor, migrated for work.

      What did they do with the money? Was it sent back for remitences or were they familially unattached and financially independent?

    3. While post-revo-lutionary nationalist discourses and policies celebrated women as wives and mothers,domestic workers were expected to remain childless to better serve their employers.They were the invisible support aiding the growth and coherence of middle-class,mestizo, families

      More of a review of the first section

    4. nabled Black and Chicana women to leavedomestic service and find other areas of employment.9 Meanwhile, immigrant women– mostly Mexican – took their place, especially in areas with high rates of Latino immi-gration.

      This cause and effect in migration is so interesting. Maybe it is easiest to see in labor migration but it must happen in other facets too.

    5. Drawing on previous employmentand social connections, they generated migrant networks through which they sharedimportant information about how to migrate and find to work, thus making migrationeasier for friends and family members to follow in their footsteps

      Chain migration

    6. the dark underbelly of capitalism, its backstage operations where cheap and irre-gular labour is used up in the search for hyperprofit’

      There has to be a loser in capitalism and racial lines present a very easy way to pick a loser

    7. They foundwork in one of the most devalued spheres of labour, domestic service

      To tie into other reading, they might have had skills that transfered from their own domestic life

    8. Subsequently, they helped other women tomigrate.

      I'm so interested in this idea of chain migration and what avenues people use to do it. Like is it because there are existing pathways like physically,m or just rumour brings people to the same place.

    Tags

    Annotators

    1. eyond permanent admissions, the United States also admits hundreds of thousands of workers,foreign students, and exchange visitors annually for temporary residence through a broad swath ofvisa categories, assigned letters of the alphabet from A through V. While temporary visas do not leaddirectly to a green card, temporary visa holders in some cases can get one if they are able to find afamily member or employer to sponsor them.

      Is this what trump is goimg after?

    2. but was 12 years for relatives from the Philippines—and more than 21 yearsfor those from Mexico. As of November 2018, there were 3.7 million people waiting in line abroad for afamily-sponsored green card, and 121,000 awaiting an employment-sponsored green card

      Good fucking lord

    3. “Skilled workers” (foreign nationalscapable of performing skilled labor,requiring at least two years of experience)-- “Professional workers” (foreign nationalswho hold at least a baccalaureate degree)-- “Other workers” (foreign nationalscapable of performing unskilled labor

      Other workers turn out to be important (see other reading)

    Annotators

    1. Those whoused their English to find work in hospitality and tourism were waiters or receptionistsor started their own businesses that cater to English-speaking persons. English languagecapability has enabled some female return migrants to bypass traditional domestic serviceand find work as English teachers or move to tourist towns where they can demand a highersalary because of their language skills

      I suspect knowing the language can actually go both ways as far as in demand skills for countries

    2. Migrants listed hard-to-measure personal achievementsand competences such as initiative, responsibility, self-confidence, follow-through,punctuality, and presentation of self, along with a number of social skills,

      Basically being a good and hard worker translates

    3. Men reportedthe transfer of construction, carpentry, and automotive repair skills; women reported foodand beverage preparation skills and some support and managerial skills such as computerand data entry knowledge.

      This ones to answer q2

    4. host country language facility, formal education, vocational classes,and on-the-job training programs

      But they will bring tons of informal trainings, that is the key part

    5. These transitions werein part facilitated by the acquisition of off-the-job skills acquired in the social spheresof household and community before paid employment.

      The formal education cannot be the explanation because these workers don't have that background (formally)

    6. hey were morelikely than men to discuss not only the technical skills they acquired in their jobs, includingcooking, cleaning, and caregiving, but also social competences, such as team work andintergroup communication skills. Their jobs as receptionists, secretaries, domestics, andcooks made them good candidates for similar positions in the US

      Gendered aqcuisition

    7. Formal learning captures skills and knowledgeacquired through a structured set of learning experiences leading to credentials orqualifications that are recognized beyond the workplace or local industry (Misko 2008), andare thus more easily transferable across local, regional, and national labor markets. Skillsacquired in non-formal social contexts refer to those developed by workplaces for purposesof skill development, such as on-the-job training programs or formal demonstrationsby experienced co-workers (Misko 2008)

      Schooling and the like

    8. Skill level 1 Work that involves repetitive tasks, e.g., dishwasher, leather cutter,laborer who mows lawns.Skill level 2 Requires experience and formal or informal training. Involvesmultitasking or the mastery of a specific skill, e.g., painter, gardenerwith multiple tasks, such as mowing lawns, pruning trees andbuilding walls.Skill level 3 Workers who have experienced extensive occupational mobilityover time and mastered all skills within an occupation throughextensive formal or informal training, e.g., maestro albañil, shoedesigner, factory floor supervisor, carpenter, nurse, teacher.

      Which is most common of these three? Which has the greatest mobility pathway?

    9. ompared to men, women more often citedsocial reasons for migrating, including joining a family member, usually a spouse, a reasonthat the literature reflects

      Chain migration?

    10. human capital skills as a lifelong social process thatis embedded in social networks, families, communities, and labor markets at both ends ofthe migratory stream.

      Basically, it is more complicated than just learning hard skills from work, no duh, could have told you this after my summer

    11. y not accounting for source country on- and off-the-job human capital investments, researchers ignore the value of home country skills forlearning new ones and the role that skill transfers potentially play in the learning and workexperiences of immigrants and return migrants.

      Question three