- Dec 2020
-
web.archive.org web.archive.org
-
Ziad Tarik, 24
-
Compared to Saddam, the Americans are better," he said
why does the author choose to end on this note?
-
Ex-detainee Muslim says he knows of a worse fate – to have been imprisoned under Saddam Hussein, as his late father was for three months in 1995.
evaluative comparison of two situations
-
Fawzia Ibrahim
-
"There's no law," Rahad Naif said. "It's up to them. It's arbitrary."
-
Saad Naif said he saw a prisoner shot dead at Abu Ghraib when he approached the razor wire.
-
elderly woman "whose hands were tied up and she was lying in the dust."
-
Seeing her lying bound in the sun, the brother angrily started to cross the razor wire ringing his tent, "and they shot him in the shoulder," Naif said.
-
especially when we saw Iraqi women punished in the same way as men."
-
There was an old black soldier we called 'al-Haji' who argued with the other Americans if they weren't respecting our rights."
-
punished by having rations reduced or withdrawn,
-
"The Gardens" – a razor-wire enclosure where prisoners were made to lie face down on the burning sand for two or three hours, hands bound.
-
Sometimes we'd fight the Americans with tent poles. The Americans would come at us behind riot shields, firing plastic bullets and electric pistols (stun guns).
-
"Twenty or so of us would start shouting, 'Get us out! Let us go!
-
He said two died in the next tent while he was there.
-
The ex-prisoners, uniformly, said the sick men among them were the camps' saddest sight
-
They'd give us hot water while we'd see them drinking cold water
-
throw ice into the sand just to make us suffer psychologically
-
Kuwaiti translators
-
Water was the first concern for internees everywhere, especially as summer temperatures topped 120 degrees. There was never enough to drink and wash with, they said.
-
Hassan Ali Muslim.
-
Baathists
-
ICRC's decision to reduce its Baghdad staff, because of the bombing of its headquarters, may limit its ability to visit detention sites.
rationalizing lack of agency as a consequence of resistance
-
organization's policy does not allow any public comment on any abuse or other poor conditions detected
policy is prohibiting accountability
-
representatives are the only outsiders allowed into the camps
explains why testimonies are so sparse
-
Geneva Conventions
legal reference
-
The Baghdad spokeswoman for the ICRC
anonymous
-
listing and processing of detainees has improved in recent weeks.
positive
-
responsible under international law for inspecting wartime prison camps,
responsible for oversight
-
International Committee of the Red Cross
-
unjustly held Iraqis
actor/moral
-
Iraqi lawyers and judges
-
Iraq's chief U.S. administrator, L. Paul Bremer
-
In toppling the Saddam government last April, the U.S.-British invasion force inherited a legal vacuum and began incarcerating ordinary criminals with prisoners of war and less well-defined detainees.
-
The U.S. command says it holds 5,500, but some lawyers and other Iraqis believe the figure is higher
dispute between speakers
-
In one, four soldiers are accused of beating Iraqi prisoners; in the other, two Marines are charged in connection with an Iraqi's death in detention.
legal proceedings
-
no response has been received
has not yet been received, actors asking for a response
-
treated humanely and fairly
-
Brig. Gen. Janis Karpinski, the U.S. Army commander
speaks positively on behalf of US Army
-
a half dozen former detainees
6 mediated accounts
-
Amnesty International
-
Associated Press
-
They confined us like sheep
use of animal simile
-
Baghdad airport's overcrowded Camp Cropper, was closed.
-
most notorious U.S. center
-
Ex-detainees
speaker but plural and anonymous rather than named as above
-
and none compares with Saddam's bloody political prisons
-
good people" among the U.S. guards, like an older man the Iraqis respectfully dubbed "al-Haji" – "Pilgrim.
-
curfew-breakers and drivers who tried to evade U.S. checkpoints, suspected common criminals, anti-U.S. resistance fighters, and many of deposed President Saddam Hussein's Baath Party leadership.
-
They never faced charges
-
Americans
-
influential neighbor
suggests connection with the US troops
-
Naif, 31
-
detainees in wheelchairs, and of a man carried into a stifling hot tent in his sickbed. "They humiliate everybody."
cruel treatment of physically impaired prisoners
-
they don't respect anyone, old or young,
respect, more, expresses deference according to age
-
to recently released Iraqis.
firsthand testimony
-
By Charles J. Hanley
prominent byline
-
riots, punishment in the sun
on the subject of event: accounts of abuse have not yet solidified in the international press as a single event & scandal as evidenced here by a lack of proper nouns in the article's headline. does this factor actually affect the event's reception?
-