In 1899, the Canadian government signed the eighth of a total of eleven treaties partnered with aboriginal tribes in western Canada. Known as the Numbered Treaties, these treaties allowed for the settlement of eastern Canada (as well as the collection and cultivation of the resources offered by the region). Treaty 8 applied to parts of British Columbia, Alberta and Saskatchewan (an area known as the Lesser Slave Lake) and covered lands as far north as the Northwest Territories.
In the 1890’s, rumors of gold strikes in the far west of Canada began to spread, sparking the interest of prospectors to travel to the distant region in search of their fortunes. This movement became known as the Klondike Gold Rush, which saw thousands of Canadians and Americans rushing to the Yukon-Alaska border in search of gold. Substantial amounts of gold were discovered along the Klondike River in the Yukon, driving almost all mining companies north through Canada in order to excavate the area. (8) With a huge increase in the number of Canadians traveling through western provinces, increased opportunities for contact with indigenous people arose. This increased contact with previously isolated indigenous people led to the signing of Treaty 8 in an effort to head off possible hostile confrontations between gold prospectors and indigenous tribes. Furthermore, while most prospectors opted to travel to Northwestern Canada, the Canadian government also chose to include in Treaty 8 the region settled by the Sekani tribe in McLeod Lake, British Columbia. While less popular to prospectors than the Klondike River valley, the Canadian government was aware of substantial mineral deposits in the region.
Some historians believe that Treaty 8 was also drawn up to protect the land and mineral rights of the Sekani in British Columbia, though others resist this theory. Historian Robert Irwin argues in a response to an article by Arthur J. Ray that the “[Sekani] cultural landscape was not a significant enough reason to extend the eastern boundary of the treaty.” (9) Furthermore, Irwin conversely argues that Canada greatly limited the borders of Treaty 8, which effectively reduced the amount of land reserves granted to the Sekani. The Treaty 8 Sekani boundary issue became a subject of controversy in years following the signing of the treaty. (10)
Ray responded to Irwin’s counter arguments, debunking most of his claims and points. Ray contends that the boundaries of Treaty 8 were mostly ambiguous, yet not nearly as small as Irwin suggested. While many topographical landscape features, such as the Liard River representing the Northernmost boundary, are assumed to be treaty borders, Treaty 8 never defined outright its designated territorial size. (11) However, Ray agrees with Irwin that the treaty's ambiguous boundaries precipitated controversy after the treaty's signing. Because the border was not officially determined, the Sekani tried to reassert their rights in the treaty, “after they had become disillusioned with the ongoing comprehensive claims and the modern treaty negotiation processes.” (12)
(8) Bockstoce, John R., and Felipe Fernandez-Armesto. "End of the Century." In Furs and Frontiers in the Far North: The Contest among Native and Foreign Nations for the Bering Strait Fur Trade, 355. Yale University Press, 2009.
(9) Irwin, Robert. 2000. "TREATY 8: An Anomaly Revisited." BC Studies no. 127: 85. America: History and Life with Full Text, EBSCOhost (accessed November 5, 2017).
(10) Irwin, Robert. 2000. "TREATY 8: An Anomaly Revisited." BC Studies no. 127: 87. America: History and Life with Full Text, EBSCOhost (accessed November 5, 2017).
(11) Ray, Arthur J. 2000. "TREATY 8 AND EXPERT WITNESSES: A Reply to Robert Irwin." BC Studies no. 127: 104. America: History and Life with Full Text, EBSCOhost (accessed November 24, 2017).
(12) Ray, Arthur J. 2000. "TREATY 8 AND EXPERT WITNESSES: A Reply to Robert Irwin." BC Studies no. 127: 103. America: History and Life with Full Text, EBSCOhost (accessed November 24, 2017).
Caption:
Map of Dominion of Canada corrected to January 1887, to show lands covered by Indian Treaty No. 8, 1898
Photo Credit: MIKAN no. 2171999